IceMule Pro Review
Compare prices at 2 resellers Pros: Durable design, comfortable to carry when full, good capacity, relatively inexpensive
Cons: Learning curve for best use, not 100% leakproof, no extra pockets
Manufacturer: IceMule
Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
 This Product
IceMule Pro | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Awards |  |  | | ||
| Price | $114.95 at REI Compare at 2 sellers | $239.99 at Amazon | $249.98 at REI Compare at 3 sellers | Check Price at Amazon Compare at 3 sellers | $110.00 at REI |
Overall Score  |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Pros | Durable design, comfortable to carry when full, good capacity, relatively inexpensive | Very durable construction, excellent insulation, useful handles and features, comfortable shoulder strap | Extremely durable, easy to use, great insulation, tons of handles, convenient size | Good insulation, extremely durable, top opens wide, no zipper to worry about | Soft cooler body, good pockets and features, comfortable shoulder strap |
| Cons | Learning curve for best use, not 100% leakproof, no extra pockets | Zippered exterior pocket not waterproof, very large | Very expensive, no extra pockets, flips upside down easily | Magnetic closure won't stay open, difficult to load alone, huge, picky shoulder strap arrangement | Exterior and zipper not waterproof |
| Bottom Line | With a unique design and comfortable carry straps, we love it for long distances | Our choice for best all around soft cooler | Sized for personal use, this option is a high-performer | Swapping zippers for magnets is an intriguing move, but we're not fully convinced it was perfected here | A pleasant mixture of solid insulation, usable capacity, and simplicity of design |
| Rating Categories | IceMule Pro | Engel HD30 | YETI Hopper Flip 12 | YETI Hopper M30 | REI Co-op Cool Haul 18 |
| Insulation Value (30%) | |||||
| Ease Of Use (25%) | |||||
| Portability (25%) | |||||
| Durability (20%) | |||||
| Specs | IceMule Pro | Engel HD30 | YETI Hopper Flip 12 | YETI Hopper M30 | REI Co-op Cool... |
| Measured Capacity (qt) | 25 qt | 32 qt | 13 qt | 30.5 qt | 18 qt |
| Measured Capacity (cans with no ice) | 39 cans | 48 cans | 18 cans | 50 cans | 28 cans |
| Carry Style | Backpack | Messenger Bag | Lunchbox | Messenger Bag | Messenger Bag |
| Internal Maximum Height (in) | 17" fully closed 23" max |
13" | 8" | 13" fully closed 15" max |
11" insert 12" lid |
| Fits Standard Wine Bottle Standing Upright? | Yes | Yes | No - will fit on side | Yes | Yes |
| Shelf Life of Food (Measured Hours Below 40ºF) | 40 hr | 98 hr | 82 hr | 73 hr | 58 hr |
| Days of Cold Beverages (Measured Hours Below 50ºF) | 48 hr | 103 hr | 92 hr | 76 hr | 61 hr |
| Measured Weight (lb) | 3.0 lb | 5.9 lb | 3.6 lb | 7.1 lb | 4.3 lb |
| Exterior Fabric | Mule SkinET 1000D ripstop tarpaulin/vinyl/nylon | Abrasion-resistant fabric | 840D double-sided thermoplastic urethane | 840D double-sided thermoplastic urethane | Ripstop nylon, polyester shell |
| Closure Method | Roll-top | Zippered top, watertight zip | Zippered flip top, watertight zip | Magnetic seal and over-the-top clips | Zippered flip top |
| Handles and Straps | Backpack straps, sternum strap | Shoulder strap, end handles, duffel handles | Shoulder strap, top handle, end handles | Shoulder strap, end handles, top handle | Shoulder strap, end carry handles |
| Additional Storage | No; exterior shock cord panel | Yes; 1 larger exterior zippered (meant to be waterproof but isn't) | No; webbing attachment loops | No; webbing attachment loops | Yes; 2 slip exterior, 1 internal zip, webbing attachment loops |
| Removable Liner? | No | No | No | No | Yes |
Our Analysis and Test Results
The IceMule Pro is one of several backpack coolers we tested and the only model in this review with a roll-top closure rather than a zipper. It features 1,000D ripstop tarpaulin/vinyl/nylon with a 23L capacity.
Performance Comparison
Insulation Value
When it comes to insulation, the IceMule Pro isn't as impressive as some of the best insulators we tested, but it still performed decently.
During our intensive insulation testing, the IceMule kept its contents under the FDA-approved 40º F for just 28 hours. While this doesn't sound particularly impressive, it then lasted almost another full day with delicious beer-serving temperatures below 50º F — or an impressive 51 hours. Which, if you're planning to head out for a hot day hike or even a single overnight in the desert, is plenty of time to keep your food and beverages on ice.
Compared to the other backpack coolers we tested, the IceMule Pro holds its own. The decently large inside compared to some other models, which does tend to cut down on the amount of time ice lasts. This bag also has a double layer of waterproof fabric sandwiching insulating foam and featuring an air valve to add and release air for additional insulation. IceMule claims that it is waterproof when you roll the top three times before clipping it. We were only able to achieve three full rolls with next to no insulating air in the cooler, and even then, a little water dripped out when we inverted the whole thing.
Ease of Use
At first, we found the IceMule to be a bit challenging to use. While the top opens easily and quite wide, the material starts very stiff and is difficult to roll appropriately. The more we used it though, the more the material softened up, and we got used to how it works. As a roll-top bag, it's a bit odd to load and unload when it's open because the roll-top makes the cooler so much deeper than it looks when it's closed. But the cooler is wide and has a pretty good sized capacity of 25L, making it fairly straightforward to fit everything we needed along with ice inside.
This tall, roll-top design can't quite compete with the easy zippered, flip-top models we tested. However, it also will never need zipper lubricant for an overly sticky zipper, like many of those models do. Additionally, using air as an insulator means that when done with the IceMule Pro, you can roll it up and put it away - a fairly unique feature among options we tested. It even comes with a handy security strap precisely for that purpose. And while we appreciate the ability of the bungee cord on the front, most of the other options we tested have one or several pockets to store non-chilled items or other handy things like a bottle opener, silverware, or your keys. Having extra pockets like these would certainly make the IceMule even more pleasant to use.
Portability
This aspect is where the IceMule shines. While we do our best to factor in the weight of each cooler only as it relates to its usable capacity, the IceMule is the best of both worlds. Not only does it have a large capacity that can fill with tons of heavy drinks in glass bottles (if you so desire), but it's also one of the most comfortable coolers to carry of any we tested. Even among the numerous backpack models we tested, the IceMule shines brightly.
This drybag-style cooler has the longest torso of all the backpack models we tested. Combined with that air insulation and a more flexible shape, the IceMule Pro is quite rounded and more forgiving to carry up that summit. While the back panel provides a moderate amount of padding, covered in mesh to aid airflow, the shoulder straps are wide and soft and set far enough apart to fit most sizes of shoulders. For people with narrower shoulders, a sternum strap allows you to keep the shoulder straps exactly where you want them. In contrast, several of the other backpack models we tested have straps that are thick and stiff and trap heat against your back. Many also have shorter torsos with more rigid corners, which are far less comfortable against your back during a trek up a steep hill.
Durability
This pack is built to last. Made of 1,000D ripstop tarpaulin/vinyl/nylon with welded seams, the IceMule is one among the most intense-feeling coolers we tested. Not only does meltwater not soak into the inside lining of this cooler, but no water from the outside will soak in either. Even after sitting in a sizeable puddle at the bottom of a kayak for a full day, the IceMule took on no water.
We had no issues with the durability of the IceMule during our testing, despite all the shenanigans we put it through. However, we do have a few questions about the durability of the plastic clips, as they seem like the least beefed-up part of this bag. We also scoured the internet looking for issues others have had with this model, and a handful reported the buckle on the top failing and a few reported the integrity of the fabric that gets constantly rolled down was starting to fail after years of use. While we didn't personally experience either of these failures, we also couldn't get years' worth of use into just a few short months. In our experience, the IceMule is a solid piece of gear.
Value
Falling on the lower side of average price among coolers we tested, we think the IceMule Pro offers a great value for what you get. If you're not game for a backpack cooler, this one might not be enough to sway you. But if you want to be the hero of your next adventure climbing expedition, we think the price of this cooler is worth it.
Conclusion
The IceMule Pro is an excellent backpack cooler, and remains our Top Pick for Long Distance Carrying. Its ability to hold a good amount of weight while remaining fairly comfortable to carry is unmatched by the competition. It features durable construction to last you a long time and without any zippers to get stuck, will never require zipper lubricant. Though it lacks additional pockets and we couldn't get it 100% leakproof, we continued to come back to this comfortable and handy cooler for all our long distance picnic destinations.
— Maggie Brandenburg