The Igloo Trailmate Marine is chock-full of features and rocks some giant wheels with high clearance to cart your festivities just about anywhere. While we generally liked this cooler's usability, funky variety of features, and ability to roll with us, we found ourselves disappointed in its insulation and durability. The lid actually pulled right off the cooler with very little effort, and though we were able to reattach it, we're bummed it happened in the first place. For a feature-rich rolling cooler with a lot better durability, we recommend the Rovr RollR, featuring the best wheels in all the land.
Igloo Trailmate Marine Review
Cons: Poor insulation, no seal, not durable
Compare to Similar Products
Igloo Trailmate Marine
|Price||$280 List||Check Price at Amazon|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$334.97 at Amazon||$230.59 at Amazon||$399.00 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Easy to use, large capacity, feature-filled||Excellent insulation, super durable, easy to use, great size||Excellent insulation, great drainage, durable, compact design||Very durable, less expensive than competitors, good insulation, comfortable handle grips||The best wheels, very durable, comfortable to pull, useful accessories|
|Cons||Poor insulation, no seal, not durable||Expensive, no leash for plug, smaller than claimed||Tall narrow shape is hard to dig through, expensive, not our favorite handles||A bit large for one person, no leash for plug, latches are scarily stretchy||Not amazing insulation, awkward latches, expensive, on the heavy side|
|Bottom Line||An impressive-looking cooler with a relatively unimpressive performance.||If you want the best insulation and the longest lasting cooler, look no further than this simple yet effective model.||Excellent insulation in a compact, durable cooler.||A high-performing and durable cooler that’s a bit softer on the wallet.||A wheeled cooler that is even more handy than you’d imagine.|
|Rating Categories||Igloo Trailmate Marine||Yeti Tundra 65||ORCA 58 Quart||RTIC 65||RovR RollR 60|
|Ease Of Use (15%)|
|Specs||Igloo Trailmate...||Yeti Tundra 65||ORCA 58 Quart||RTIC 65||RovR RollR 60|
|Shelf Life of Food (Measured Days Below 40ºF)||3.2 days||6.5 days||6.5 days||6 days||4.7 days|
|Weight (lbs)||35.4 lb||31.9 lb||30.6 lb||34.9 lb||40.5 lb|
|Measured Capacity (quarts)||75 qt||56 qt||56 qt||67 qt||60 qt|
|Advertised Capacity (quarts)||70 qt||65 qt||58 qt||65 qt||60 qt|
|Days of Cold Beverages (Measured Days Below 50º F)||3.4 days||7.4 days||7.3 days||6.8 days||5.3 days|
|Exterior Dimensions (L x W x H)||37"/53" x 19.5" x 23.5"||30.75" x 17.5" x 16"||26.75" x 20" x 19.4"||32" x 18.5" x 17"||25.9"/40.25" x 20.75" x 20"|
|Construction||not specified||Rotomolded polyethylene||Rotomolded||Rotomolded||Rotomolded|
Our Analysis and Test Results
Up against some pretty intense competition, the Igloo Trailmate didn't turn any heads in our torturous insulation testing. The USDA recommends maintaining raw food temperatures below 40º F to avoid the growth of pathogenic bacteria. While the coolers we tested averaged 4.5 days maintaining these cooler temperatures, the Trailmate managed just 3.2 days of wavering right at or just below 40º.
Don't need the steak and eggs, but bringing all the beer? The Igloo managed to hold refreshing brew temperatures at or below 50º for an additional several hours, for a total of 3.4 days of cold beers. Though we aren't totally shocked at this lackluster performance when considering the Trailmate is a relatively thin cooler, standing up to some rather thick, rotomolded competition. And realistically, a wheeled cooler like this is less likely to be your choice to strap into your canoe for that 10-day whitewater trip, and more likely to be your choice for a picnic in the park. In which case this level of insulation will surely get you through a single warm summer's day.
Lacking the impressive durability of the many Interagency Grizzly Bear Committee certified coolers it competed with in this review, the Trailmate is nothing to write home about. When subjecting this cooler to our standard battery of tests and overextending the hinge on the lid, the whole piece just came right off in our hands. Upon further inspection, we could see why - it's held on by some short, thin plastic pegs in small plastic holes and a single screw attaching a short lid leash to try to prevent this exact thing from happening. While we were able to pop the lid back on nearly as easily as it popped off in the first place, we're rather disappointed with the lack of durability in this cooler's construction. Even the simple Coleman with its thin hinges and similar style of dry screws in plastic didn't break as easily as this cooler did - and it costs a couple of hundred dollars less!
Ease of Use
With no latches to mess with, the Trailmate is fairly easy to open when you want some of its contents. It does require a good push down to close it all the way, but that requires less effort than many other coolers, rather a conscious thought to remember to do so before all the ice melts - a feature it shares with the Coleman Xtreme. The telescoping trolley handle is easy to slide in and out when you need it. It also doubles as a front handle for those few occasions you may actually need to pick your cooler up.
On numerous occasions, we found our hand searching for a front handle that doesn't exist, only to latch onto the bottom of the little white box nestled on the front. Unfortunately, that little white box slides up and off the cooler as soon as you apply pressure - not a great handle, so the retracted trolley arm will have to do. Our least favorite aspect in terms of usability is the drain found in this cooler. Though it has a wide channel to help empty it of meltwater, the inside of the drain also is turned into a protruding tunnel into the interior by a white plastic tube. Why this is a thing, we're not sure, as it made the Trailmate the least conducive to emptying via drain plug of any model we tested.
Ahh, wheels. These two round discs are the most redeeming feature of the whole cooler. Though they don't provide nearly as luxurious of a ride as the air-filled tires of the Rovr RollR, they're large and wide and the cooler has a tall clearance, helping you to roll with relative ease over lawns and loose sands alike. At just over 35 pounds, the Trailmate is also the lightest of the three wheeled models we tested.
Additionally, its telescoping trolley handle provides an ample amount of space between the front of the cooler and the backs of your heels. This added space makes the Igloo the only wheeled cooler we tested that we never hit our heels on - a pretty big deal. And while we greatly appreciate this fact, we feel that the Trailmate still can't quite live up to the smooth ride we got every time we took the Rovr out for a spin. We should also add that the telescoping handle doesn't have a smooth action — it definitely doesn't feel high quality.
One of the major selling points of the Igloo Trailmate, in our eyes, is the myriad of features that come standard with this cooler. We were initially pumped about this array of features, though our excitement lessened throughout testing. The plug leash - a great feature for any cooler - is attached in a way that we had a pretty hard time unscrewing the actual plug, and typically had to use two hands to accomplish. The extra boxes and fishing rod holders on the outside kept popping off when we lifted the cooler or pushed it up against something in a certain way. The butler tray isn't quite the right size to fit snugly in the trolley handle, and so slides a lot when in place. We did find the internal dry basket and two bottle openers on the outside to be fairly useful though.
This cooler is bound to put hearts in the eyes of features and accessories fans. But in terms of performance, we think it leaves a lot to be asked for. If features are your love, we suggest checking out the Rovr RollR, a higher performing cooler with useful accessories that we think truly make your life easier.
Igloo makes a lot of products, many of which we think are excellent values for what they bring to the table. Unfortunately, we don't feel the same way about the Trailmate Marine. We found its performance and overall quality to be less than what we had hoped, though its price is not much less than many of the seriously impressive coolers we tested. If you don't need wheels on your cooler, consider the RTIC as our Best Buy for a High End Cooler award winner. Really want the wheels? We'd recommend the more expensive, but also better performing Rovr RollR.
Though at first glance the Trailmate looks like a great deal, we're not so sure. Its wide wheels and high clearance help it navigate a variety of challenging terrain, but the performance of this cooler in insulation and particularly its lackluster durability leaves us wanting more. But if wheels are what you're after and a budget is what you're on, the Igloo might be the right fit for your life.
— Maggie Brandenburg