Nikon Monarch 5 8x42 Review
Compare prices at 2 resellers Pros: Good clarity and brightness, smooth focus knob
Cons: Mediocre close focus range, mediocre field of view
Compare to Similar Products
Nikon Monarch 5 8x42
|Price||Check Price at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$219.00 at Amazon||$307.56 at Amazon||$146.65 at Amazon||$135.16 at Amazon|
|Pros||Good clarity and brightness, smooth focus knob||Good clarity, decent brightness, great close focus range and field of view||Good clarity and brightness, big field of view, relatively inexpensive||Inexpensive, good clarity and brightness||Good clarity, small and lightweight, relatively comfortable|
|Cons||Mediocre close focus range, mediocre field of view||Stiff middle hinge, slightly on the heavy side for an 8x42||Finicky focus knob||Average construction quality, mediocre low-light performance||Poor low-light performance|
|Bottom Line||The best pair of binoculars for the price, these offer a smooth focus knob and decent brightness and clarity||A great pair, but some other models in the same price range have slightly better brightness||A good choice if your budget is around $300||The most budget-friendly option we've found that offers a good introduction to birdwatching||An inexpensive, small, and packable model that offers surprisingly good optics|
|Rating Categories||Nikon Monarch 5 8x42||Vortex Diamondback...||Athlon Midas 8x42||Celestron Nature DX...||Vortex Diamondback...|
|Ease Of Adjustment (15%)|
|Construction Quality (15%)|
|Close Focus Range (7.5%)|
|Field Of View (7.5%)|
|Specs||Nikon Monarch 5 8x42||Vortex Diamondback...||Athlon Midas 8x42||Celestron Nature DX...||Vortex Diamondback...|
|Multi - Coating||FMC||FMC||FMC||FMC||FMC|
|Field of View ft/yards||330/1000||420/1000||426/1000||388/1000||332/1000|
|Size (length x width)||5.7 x 5.1 in||5.9 x 5.6 in||5.8 x 4.4 in||5.3 x 4.9 in||4.6 x 4.5 in|
|Weight||20.8 oz||25.2 oz||25 oz||22.2 oz||14 oz|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Nikon Monarch 5 8x42 provides the best overall image we've seen in a sub $300 pair of bins. If that is your budget you should definitely be considering these bins.
The Nikon Monarch 5 8x42 earned a high overall score in our testing, besting every other model in its price range and even rivaling some models that cost considerably more.
The Monarch 5 is exceptionally clear, earning it a high score o. It's able to produce a crisp and striking image that really pops. In our testing we were easily able to pick out inconspicuous identification marks on small birds, and could even count individual pine needles at 100 feet. The Monarch 5 lost out on a higher score because it does present just a bit of blurring around the extreme edges of the image, which makes it just slightly less immersive than the images produced by the top tier models. However, this feels like a very small sacrifice considering how much less expensive these bins are.
When compared to other binoculars in this price range, the Monarch 5 is just as clear or clearer. For example, it is equally as clear as the $270 Vortex Diamondback 8x42 and has much less edge blurring than the Athlon Midas 8x42.
This is where the Monarch 5 really separates itself from other binoculars in the same price range. The Monarch 5's impressive brightness earned a score of 8 out of 10, outpacing its main competitors like the Vortex Diamondback 8x42 and Athlon Midas 8x42, both of which scored 7 out of 10.
We think the Monarch 5 is the cheapest pair of bins you'll find that can still produce truly good images at dawn on an overcast day. To get any better you're going to have to spend a lot more money on something like the Vortex Viper.
Ease of Adjustment
Here again the Monarch 5 was towards the top of the scoreboard with an 8 out of 10.
The focus knob of the Monarch 5 is solid yet smooth, allowing for easy adjustment and the ability to quickly lock in on the perfect focus once you find it. The diopter knob is small and stiff, so it's very unlikely that you could move it inadvertently. However when you do need to make a diopter adjustment is moves smoothly after overcoming a bit of initial inertia. The eyecups twist in and out and have 4 distinct stopping points (1 more than most models), so you'll easily be able to get the eyecups even and at an acceptable distance from the lenses. Overall the Monarch 5 checks pretty much all of the boxes in the ease of adjustment category, as do most models in this price range. The only thing that could make them better would be a locking diopter and possibly more eyecup settings.
The Monarch 5 binoculars feel very comfortable in hand, which earned them a high score of 9 out of
The comfort of the Monarch 5 mostly boils down to the rubber coating. This rubber is tacky enough that the grip feels very secure, but not so tacky that your hands are left feeling stick when using the bins on a hot day. The rubber coating also gets thinner on the bottom of the barrels, providing some extra space for your thumbs. To boot the Monarch 5 comes with a padded, neoprene neck strap that has a non-slip coating on the inside.
Overall the Monarch 5 is slightly more comfortable to hold than its main, similarly priced competitors. The small thumb indents on the Vortex Diamondback 8x42 can't match teh Monarch's ergonomic feel, and the Athlon Midas feels a bit too small for those with larger hands.
The Monarch 5 is generally well constructed, earning an 8 out of 10 in this metric. The rubber coating is clearly high quality, and the hinge and all moving pieces fell solid and smooth. The materials do feel of a slightly lesser quality than some of the more expensive models, but we certainly don't have any long term durability concerns for these bins.
Close Focus Range
This is one area where the Monarch 5 8x42 is slightly below average. The close focus range of 7.8 feet, doesn't feel particularly limiting in day to day use, but it might cost you a fantastic look at an interesting bug that happens to land near you. It also doesn't quite live up the close focus ranges of the Vortex Diamondback 8x42 and the Athlon Midas 8x42, which boast 4.5 and 6.5 feet, respectively.
Field of View
Here again the Monarch 5 is slightly behind the competition. Its field of view at 1000 yards is 330 feet, well short of the 420 and 426 foot fields of view on the Vortex Diamondback 8x42 and the Athlon Midas 8x42. However, while these differences are noticeable when looking at a far away landscapes, they're almost indiscernible when looking at something a couple of hundred feet away.
The full sized Nikon Monarch 5 8x42s work best for dedicated wildlife viewing trips, whether that be hiking to find some interesting species or hanging out in a bird blind. At 20.8 oz these bins are light enough to wear around your neck while hiking for multiple miles, but are probably too heavy to make it into your pack on longer excursions (unless that longer excursion's purpose is to find a rare migrant species).
The Nikon Monarch 5 8x42 is the best pair of bins we've found in the sub $300 range. If you have $280 to spend on a nice pair of bins, the Monarch 5 will provide you with years of super crisp images, whether the sun is shining or not. The $270 Vortex Diamondback 8x42 comes somewhat close in term of performance, but we think the superior brightness of the Monarch 5 makes these bins a better value.
$300 is a common budget for those looking to make an investment in a good pair of bins, and we think the Nikon Monarch 5 8x42 is the best way to spend that budget. Combining good construction, a nice focus knob, high quality glass and great low light performance, the Monarch 5 will be able to keep up no matter where your adventures take you.
— Max Mutter and Steven Tata