Hands-on Gear Review

Compare ski jackets for women ratings side-by-side >

Columbia Whirlibird Interchange - Women's Review

   
Best Buy Award

Ski Jackets - Women's

  • Currently 4.0/5
Overall avg rating 4.0 of 5 based on 1 review. Most recent review: February 11, 2014
Street Price:   Varies from $180 - $220 | Compare prices at 4 resellers
Pros:  Comfortable, warm, looks good, inner layer is good for around town
Cons:  Two layers do not work well together: snow skirt doesn’t work with inner layer, no access to interior pockets, thin hood material
Best Uses:  Resort skiing and snowboarding, short back country ski trips
User Rating:       (0.0 of 5) based on 0 reviews
Manufacturer:   Columbia
Review by: Jessica Haist ⋅ Review Editor, OutdoorGearLab ⋅ February 11, 2014  
Overview
The Columbia Whirlibird jacket is our favorite of the three-in-one type jackets we tested since it is the most comfortable and stylish. It is very similar in function to the Columbia Bugaboo Interchange - Women's, but we think the Whirlibird fits better and is more flattering. This jacket has three different wear options: the outer layer can be worn alone on warm days when you only need a wind layer, the interior insulation layer can be worn by itself around town to keep you warm, and both can be worn together for the especially cold and windy days on the slopes. We really like how the layers perform individually, but found that they don't work in combination quite as well. When the two layers are zipped together we can't use some of the important ski features like the powder skirt and goggle pocket. The interior jacket is our favorite to wear around town and for après-ski happy hours.

This jacket won our Best Buy award due to its style, versatility, multiple wear options, and it is also one of the least expensive jackets in this review, making it a great value.

We took this jacket on an overnight ski tour to test its versatility and found that it worked relatively well. The exterior jacket was adequate as a shell when we were working hard, although it was still heavier than a regular hard shell – see our Buying Advice for more about this.

Compare top rated competitors side-by-side >

  • Photos
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge


OutdoorGearLab Editors' Hands-on Review

A three-in-one jacket, this piece allows for more versatile layering options than a stand alone jacket, which in turn makes it a great deal, and earns it our Best Buy Award.

Performance Comparison

Click to enlarge
Jessica and McKenzie in Columbia's Whirlibird and Bugaboo jackets. We thought the Whirlibird was had a slightly better fit and style than the Bugaboo, but the Bugaboo seemed a bit more waterproof and durable.
Credit: Julie Perumal

Warmth
The Whirlibird has a removable interior synthetic jacket that uses Columbia's unique Omni-Heat technology to keep you warm. We were skeptical at first because because it looks like a flashy gimmick– but it seems to work. The inner jacket is made from a warm synthetic material, and is lined with tiny aluminum dots that are designed to reflect your own body heat back in towards you, similar in function to a foil space blanket. Heat loss through radiation is not the major method of heat loss when skiing - convection through wind and conduction through sitting on a chilly chair lift are the ways most likely to steal heat. That being said, we are not sure if it was those reflective dots that kept us warm, or if it was the combination of the thick synthetic insulation and wind resistant outer shell, but we stayed toasty. We are not sold on the durability of the liner material, and are afraid that the little silver dots will wear off eventually, but in our testing so far they have held up.

Water Resistance
We found this jacket to be relatively water resistant during our test. Columbia uses their multi-layer Omni-Tech system to keep you dry. We found the Columbia Bugaboo jacket material seemed slightly more water resistant and a little more durable, but neither tested as well as the Patagonia Primo Down Jacket - Women's jacket for water resistance.

Ventilation
The Whirlibird is somewhat breathable, although we still worked up a sweat occasionally in it. It has pit-zips for extra venting – although you cannot vent the interior jacket – but the Omni-Heat system's tiny dots do allow moisture to move out between them for breathability. (So slightly more breathable than an actual space blanket!)

Ski Features
The Whirlibird has several great ski features. The most notable were the thin, comfortable wrist gaiters and large goggle pockets on this jacket. We also think that its individual layers work really well separately. The shell is a great wind and water resistant layer to wear on a warm day, and the interior layer is a warm and cute layer to wear around town for après-ski, but together they make the jacket less functional. When the interior layer is zipped in it makes the powder skirt less functional and awkward to use and the interior pockets of the exterior shell are not accessible. The Whirlibird and Bugaboo both had this issue. This problem can be easily solved if you zip each layer to itself and do not attach them together, although Columbia did not intend for you to wear them this way. We also wish that the hood was made out of a thicker material or lined like the Primo Down, because it was pretty thin material.

Click to enlarge
For all of the "3-in-1" jackets we tested in this review we found that the individual pieces worked better on their own than when they were worn together. We like the Columbia Whirlibird's layers best and wore the inner layer around town frequently.
Credit: Ian McEleney
Click to enlarge
We found we couldn't access the inside pockets when the layers were zipped together, so we would just wear them zipped separately when skiing.
Credit: Ian McEleney

Style
This jacket was the most stylish of the three-in-one jackets. We thought that both the interior and exterior jackets looked and functioned great individually, and especially liked wearing the cozy interior jacket around because it was warm, fit well, and had nice wrist gaiters. We like the colors it comes in more than the Bugaboo jacket, but think the plaid pattern could be more pronounced.

Click to enlarge
This jacket was the most stylish of three in one jackets. We like the colors it comes in but think the plaid pattern could be less subtle.
Credit: Jessica Haist

Comfort and Fit
The Whirlibird is the most comfortable of the three-in-one jackets we tested. It allows for good mobility while carving turns on the ski hill. Columbia's sizing is more relaxed, and our medium testers fall well within the medium specs. You should be able to order the jacket in your usual size if your measurements fall in the right category, with room to spare for extra mid-layers.

Best Application
This jacket is meant for skiing at the resort in all different types of climates. On a warm day leave the inner layer in the car (to change into for après ski), on a colder day wear them both together.

Value
The Whirlibird is the best value of the jackets in this review. It is two separate jackets (that can be worn tougher) for the price of one, and works well on the ski hill to keep you warm and looking good. The Orage LouLou is also a good value if you are looking for a single layer ski jacket.

Conclusion
For a versatile and inexpensive ski jacket, the Whirlibird will serve you well. For half the price of our Editors' Choice winner, the Patagonia Primo Down Jacket- Women's, the Whirlibird will still get you out on the hill and keep you warm and dry, which is why we give it our Best Buy Award.

Other Versions
The Columbia Whirlibird Interchange 3-in-1 is the men's version of this jacket. It is very similar in function to the Columbia Bugaboo Interchange - Women's or Bugaboo Interchange, but we think the Whirlibird fits better and is more flattering.

Jessica Haist

Compare this product side-by-side to top competitors >

Where to Buy?


Thinking about buying some gear we've reviewed? Help OutdoorGearLab out if you do. Just click on any of the above seller links and if you make any purchase, the seller will contribute a portion of the sale to help support this site. It won't cost you anything extra, and it's a simple way to help us fund our gear reviews. Thanks!

*Most retailers free shipping offers apply only to lower 48 US states using ground/economy shipping. See retailer's website for details.


OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews


Most recent review: February 11, 2014
Summary of All Ratings

OutdoorGearLab Editors' Rating:   
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (4.0)
Average Customer Rating:     (0.0)
Rating Distribution
1 Total Ratings
5 star: 0%  (0)
4 star: 100%  (1)
3 star: 0%  (0)
2 star: 0%  (0)
1 star: 0%  (0)


Have you used the Columbia Whirlibird Interchange - Women's?
Don't hold back. Share your viewpoint by posting a review with your thoughts...

Write a Review on this Gear
Click to enlarge
Columbia Whirlibird Interchange
Credit: Columbia
Where's the Best Price?
Seller Price
Amazon $179.90  -  28% off!
Backcountry $179.95  -  28% off!
REI $200.00  -  20% off!
Compare prices at 4 sellers >

*Help support OutdoorGearLab. If you click on one of the seller links and make a purchase, a portion of the sale helps support this site
Related Best-in-Class Review
The Best Ski Jacket for Women Review

The Best Ski Jacket for Women Review

We tested several top-of-the-line insulated ski jackets and evaluated their features and weather protections to help you find one that’s right for you.
Video video review
Helpful Buying Tips
Get More OutdoorGearLab
Follow us on Twitter, be a fan on Facebook!
Subscribe to our Newsletter