Comfort & Fit
When considering comfort, we compared the level of cushion, the amount of compression paneling, relative fit, and overall coziness. The testing was simple. We tried each on, slept with them, hiked in them, and compared their properties. We even wore different socks on each foot to compare the relative cushioning and hiking capabilities of each contender.
Warmth was measured using two micro-metrics; wet warmth and dry warmth. For wet warmth, we soaked each sock in water, put them on, and walked around in the cold to evaluate if the model held its warm. For dry warmth, we made sure each sock was dry and stood around on cold winterish nights to determine relative warmth. We also wore different socks on each foot to get a specific comparison.
Breathability & Wicking Capabilities
To test breathability and wicking capabilities, we wore each pair while performing high and low-intensity activities. Trail running in each sock in warm weather was the best tell-tale sign of wicking and breathability. Wearing different socks allowed us to see which foot felt hotter or less comfortable. We trail ran through the high Peruvian Andes, the jagged Colorado Rocky Mountains, and lonely, hot desert trails. We also took each contender skiing to determine how it wicked away moisture in cold environments.
To test durability, we looked at relative wear and tear over roughly 60 miles of testing. This includes packing out of cushioning, holes, pilling, misshapen fabrics, etc. We noted the quality of fabric before and after this testing period. Products that demonstrated little to no wear scored high, while those without scored low.
Our drying tests were two-fold. First, we took each sock into the field and got it soaked. We then put them on rocks to dry out. This provided us with real-field based data that yielded decent results, but not objective ones. So we confirmed our outdoor tests with a much more objective in-lab test. This was the dryer test where each sock was soaked, put into a dryer, and weighed every ten minutes to determine the relative amount of moisture in the sock. This allowed us to determine which socks dried fastest, which held the most water, and which dried the slowest.
- Step One: Weigh (in grams) each sock when dry. This is our control weight.
- Step Two: Dunk each sock under water and squish around for one minute.
- Step Three: Wring each sock out as best we can until no more drops of water come from the fabric.
- Step Four: Weigh each sock when wet (this is time = zero minutes)
- Step Five: Put into dryer and set temperature for 'normal'.
- Step Six: At every ten minute interval, weigh each sock and record the weight in grams. Continue until the sock is back to its dry weight. Record dry time for each sock.
- Step Seven: Evaluate and analyse data.
After all these tests we've been able to produce what we think is the best comparative hiking sock review out there! We hope it helps you in your search.