We love the consistent excellence of the Tarmac AWD. It scored at or near the top of the field in each performance metric, except style, and earned our appreciation and Editors' Choice Award. This bag rolls easily on a variety of surfaces, can handle a week's worth of clothes and expand to fit more, and is loaded with handy features. This bag is built to last, with quality construction and durable materials. There is no internal suiter or any way to keep your fancy clothes wrinkle-free, so we'd opt for the Briggs and Riley Baseline over this model for business travelers. And it does have a more relaxed look to it — it's somewhere between a rolling duffel and a traditional carry-on. But if you like to show your outdoorsy side in your luggage and want something that has a place for everything, the Tarmac is the way to go. For a more affordable option, the Swiss Gear 7208 Expandable Liteweight Spinner, our Best Buy winner, is also an excellent choice.
Eagle Creek Tarmac AWD Carry-On Review
Cons: "Technical" styling not for everyone.
Manufacturer: Eagle Creek
#1 of 11
Compare to Similar Products
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Tarmac AWD is a unique hybrid hard-sided/soft-sided bag. It has a polycarbonate shell on the back to protect the handle and add durability and structure to the bag, while the front coated polyester gives you more options for storage and packing. This bag weighs 8 lbs 2 oz and is 22 x 13 x 9 inches. Current color options are Asphalt Black, Highland Green, and Slate Blue.
Ease of Transport
This ranked at the top of the luggage pile for Ease of Transport. This was often a difficult metric to score, because what made one bag more maneuverable on polished surfaces (namely four spinner wheels), usually made it more difficult to handle on rough terrain. Conversely, a bag with large wheels like the Osprey Ozone Wheeled 22 worked great in a gravel parking lot, but had a large turning radius and was more challenging to navigate down tight airplane aisles.
The Tarmac straddled the middle of these two lines and offered great maneuverability in most conditions. The four-spinner wheels are highly maneuverable through tight airports and plane aisles and never locked up on us. When switching to rough surfaces and dragging it behind us, it pulled well and was not prone to tipping over like the Ozone. This bag is also available in a two-wheeled version if you still prefer that style, and from previous testing, we can assure you that it is still easy to travel with. If you want to know more about the differences between two and four-wheeled bags and the pros and cons of each, head over to our Buying Advice article where we break that down for you.
The extra features on this bag also make this model a breeze to travel with. The "Coat-Keeper" attachment keeps your arms less cluttered when you're already juggling your phone and ID through long security lines, and the extra pockets on the outside are great for stashing your tablet or boarding passes. The bag itself is also not too heavy, and there are several carrying handles for those occasions where you need to haul it up or down a flight of stairs.
You can pack a lot of clothes into the Eagle Creek Tarmac AWD Carry-On, even though it is slightly smaller than some of the two-wheeled bags in our review. The following chart illustrates how the Tarmac AWD ranked in our lineup for the Storage metric.
This bag held everything in our "Pack for a Week in Winter" challenge, including two pairs of pants, four shirts/sweaters, workout clothes, running shoes, fancy shoes, toiletries, and socks/underwear. Then you can unzip the expander, which adds an additional 2 inches to the width of the bag, allowing you to squeeze even more things in there. With the bag expander unzipped you might not be able to carry it on the plane anymore, as that takes it over the legal carry-on dimensions, but it's a good option for people who like to acquire a lot of souvenirs on their travels. Carry your bag on the plane on the way there (just in case it gets lost), and then check it on the way home.
There is an interior pocket that runs the length of the bag that you could fold up a suit or nice clothes, but that section is on the fabric side of the bag as opposed to the shell side. It doesn't have the same structure to it as a thick nylon or a hard-sided bag, so don't be too surprised if they end up a little wrinkled. For business travel, something like the Briggs and Riley Baseline Domestic or the Platinum Magna 2, with their integrated suiters, are the way to go.
This bag ranked a perfect 10 in our Features category! Check out the chart below to see where the other bags in our review ranked in comparison to this feature-packed carry-on.
This bag has almost too many features to list. If you've thought of it at some point, it's probably on this bag. Some way to stash your coat or neck pillow so you are not walking through the airport with it on your neck? Check. Padded laptop sleeve? Check. Lockable zippers with easy pull tabs, add-a-bag strap, and a key ring? Check, check, and check! They must have a team of hard-core travelers at Eagle Creek who were tasked with thinking about any and every little thing that could make traveling easier, and then they put it on this bag. Is it too much? We don't think so. Instead, it's like a little surprise every time you use this bag — you'll find yourself repeatedly saying, "Oooh, I didn't know it could do this!"
Our testers were impressed with the solid construction on the Eagle Creek Tarmac AWD Carry-On. The handle pulls out smoothly every time and doesn't feel too wobbly, unlike some lower-end bags like the Rockland Melbourne 20. The polycarbonate back provides extra structure and durability, and the wheels are solidly built. The "Bi-Tech Armor" fabric is a coated polyester for abrasion and weather resistance. While not completely waterproof, water will bead up and roll off it, which is great for rainy environments. There's also a skid plate on the bottom for extra protection.
This bag rated similarly to The North Face Rolling Thunder 22 for durability, as we felt that both bags were built to last. A thorough read of online user reviews also revealed few complaints about durability. If something does go wrong, this bag is covered by Eagle Creek's "No Matter What" guarantee, which covers "repair and replacement due to product failure during the product lifetime, regardless of the cause."
While not as lightweight as the Osprey Ozone Wheeled 22 (4 lbs 10 oz), at just a little over 8 lbs, the Tarmac is still lighter than the 9 lbs 3 oz Briggs and Riley Baseline Domestic. That makes hauling it up a flight of stairs or lifting it into the overhead bin a little easier. Also, the spinner wheels help take some of the load off your arms, as it is easier on your shoulders to push a heavy bag rather than pull it.
While we weren't the biggest fan of the look of the older version of this bag, the newer one is a little chicer. The updated fabric is more mat than gloss, and the hard-sided back makes it look less light a rolling duffel bag.
Eagle Creek is known for their functional and outdoorsy-styled luggage, and they delivered more of the same with this bag. Does it look like every other rollaboard coming off the conveyor belt? No, and that's a good thing. But, the styling and the color choices are a little on the plain side. This bag doesn't look like something you'd take on a business trip to Europe — more like an eco-tourism vacation in Costa Rica. We preferred the sleek look of the Samsonite Inova, with its brushed hardshell surface and minimalist design. Once you start attaching coats and bags to the Tarmac AWD it starts to look like a Christmas tree, which is handy, but not too chic.
As we just mentioned, we wouldn't hesitate to pick this bag for adventure traveling, heading on safari, or even just going back home for the holidays. It can hold a lot of clothes and expand to hold even more when needed. The only thing we wouldn't recommend it for is business travel due to the casual styling and lack of an integrated suite/dress compartment.
This bag retails for $339, which is more expensive than the many other quasi-rolling duffels in this review. We do see the extra expense as worth it though, as you get many traveler-friendly features with this bag that you don't with the other two. If you are looking to save a few dollars though and still want a quality piece of luggage, then something like the Swiss Gear 7208 Expandable Liteweight Spinner is a great option.
The Eagle Creek Tarmac AWD won our Editors' Choice award for being one of the easiest to use and most versatile pieces of luggage we've tested. It comes loaded with handy features that make traveling that much easier, and it should withstand thousands of miles flown.
OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews
Most recent review: March 29, 2018
0% of 1 reviewers recommend it
I purchased this bag based primarily on Outdoor Gear Lab's review. There is one big fault with this bag that should disqualify it from being recommended by OGL or anyone else. The zippers on the bag are VERY sticky. They do not zip or unzip smoothly at all. I had to really work to get the main zipper around the corners of the bag, and the zippers on the various pockets and compartments were also very tough to open and close. I wondered whether perhaps it was just the particular bag I received and considered ordering a replacement to see if the zippers improved, but read reviews elsewhere and saw that many people had the same issue. Eagle Creek itself acknowledges the stickyness of the zippers and says that they will not loosen up over time. I buy a piece of luggage to last for many years and to make travel as easy as possible. This bag was not going to meet either of those requirements, so back it goes.
Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this product to a friend.
Have you used this product?
Don't hold back. Share your viewpoint by posting a review with your thoughts...