Plum Guide XS Stopper Review
Cons: Outdated and complicated transitions, limited customer service
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Plum Guide XS is an all-metal interpretation of the classic tech style binding. Construction is robust, and the online following is fanatic. The forums are full of fans of the Plum Guide bindings. How do they stack up in a thorough OutdoorGearLab comparison? In short, they are functional, but not flashy. There are lighter bindings, bindings that are easier to use, and bindings that better ski downhill. That being said, the Guide may be just the binding for you.
All around products score well in our reviews. The Guide is an all-around ski binding for backcountry use. It has all the major features, good construction, and puts it together at a reasonable weight. When we crunch the numbers, the scores bear this out. The Guide is near the top of the heap, overall.
We dig touring with the Plum Guide. The pivot is easy and clean. The heel lifters are well spaced and cover all the elevations beginner and intermediate skinners will want. Our one issue with the touring performance of the Plum Guide is that the toe piece, in tour mode, is a little more flexible, laterally, than other options.
Touring with the Plum Guide is pretty similar, overall, to benchmark products like the Best Buy Dynafit Speed Turn and the Editors Choice Atomic Backland Tour. It tours better than both Top Pick winners. It has more heel lifters than the Plum Tech Race 150 and offers a more rigid connection in tour mode than the Fritschi Tecton. Let us talk more about the rigidity of toe piece connection. When skinning on firm surfaces, especially sidehilling, a good rigid connection helps. The complicated toe piece of the Fritschi Tecton is flexible and sloppy, compared to the others. The machined aluminum construction of the Plum Guide is more rigid than that, but not as rigid as the cast aluminum of the Speed Turn and Dynafit TLT Speed.
That we have nothing notable to say about the downhill performance of the Plum Guide is endorsement enough. We want our backcountry bindings to hold our skis to our feet, and maybe release if needed. As long as we don't ski super hard or fast, we don't need sophisticated downhill performance. The Plum Guide works well, but isn't flashy. The one caveat that very sensitive skiers may note with the Plum Guide is that the "binding delta" is greater than average. In fact, this elevation difference between toe and heel is about twice the average. Your heel is a lot higher in the Plum Guide, relative to the toe, than in the Fritschi Tecton or G3 Ion LT. The binding delta of the Plum Guide is the exact same (by our measurements), as that of the Best Buy Dynafit Speed Turn.
Ease of Use
The overall design, as it pertains to usability, is pretty "standard". Some attributes are a little outdated, but largely the usability is on par. Notably, other bindings in this weight class have heel lifters that can be moved with a pole basket. The Plum Guide requires a rotation from ski to tour and between the three different touring elevations. This is the same as the original tech binding designs, but most users have come to value the flip-style heel lifters of something like the Editors Choice Atomic Backland Tour or the very usable G3 Ion LT.
Your experience with your backcountry bindings will certainly be tied to the way they transition. Let's look at the major transitions. To switch the Plum Guide from ski to tour mode requires removing the ski from your foot, stowing the brake (a two-handed process), putting on your skins, turning the binding heel, and stepping back in. The brake stowing is the major variable that distinguishes bindings during this transition. The bindings without brakes, like the Top Pick Black Diamond Helio 180 and the Best Buy Dynafit Speed Turn don't require this step at all. The other bindings we tested with brakes are configured such that the brake stowage during a ski to tour transition is either a one-handed operation (like on the Atomic Backland Tour) or is initiated while changing the heel piece and completed when the user steps in, as in the Marker KingPin and Top Pick Fritschi Tecton.
In short, the brakes of the Plum Guide XS are the toughest to stow of any of the bindings we tested. To transition from tour to ski requires, at the bare minimum, turning the heel, redeploying the brakes (also a two-handed process), stripping skins, and unlocking the toe piece. With a two-handed task in there, doing these things while the ski is still on your foot is pretty complicated. Some remove their skis for every transition. For them, this won't be a big deal. If you like to, or want to, change from tour to ski with your skis on, the Guide XS makes that a challenge. Finally, switching heel elevations requires rotating the heel. This is the same as on the venerable Best Buy Dynafit Speed Turn and works fine for lots of people. However, flip-style heel lifters work better for most. In the end, transitions on the Plum Guide are trickier than on most of the other bindings we assessed.
The only other ease of use comment we'd make on the Plum Guide is that the mechanism that locks the ski brakes out of the way while touring sometimes fails. Whether it is icing, pressure, or just randomness, we don't know. We do know, though, that the brakes seem to deploy, while touring, every few hours. Fixing this requires removing the skinned ski, clearing some ice and snow, locking away the brakes, and putting the ski back on.
At 2.1 lbs per pair, the Plum Guide is right in the middle of our tested bindings, in terms of weight. For the features, this is an ok weight. This weight is exactly tied with the G3 Ion LT, but the Plum includes ski brakes that the G3 doesn't. Of the major binding features we look for (brakes, adjustable length, three touring elevations, adjustable release value), the Plum has them all at a reasonable weight. We granted our Editors Choice award to the Atomic Backland Tour binding because it has all the features we seek, just like the Plum Guide but weighs a third of a pound less.
The all-metal construction of the Plum Guide certainly inspires confidence. Other reviews cite this attribute as something very favorable. When superficially compared to other bindings -bindings that extensively use plastic- it seems as though the Plum Guide should be much more durable. Fact is, in decades of ski touring and ski mountaineering, we have had very few issues with the durability of tech style bindings. As compared to other ultralight categories of gear, tech bindings, in general, are very durable. Needless to say, we had basically no issues with the Plum Guide and durability. The one minor thing we experienced was the loss of one of the plastic tips on the ski brakes. It doesn't affect function or safety, but the plastic tip seems to snag on clothing and packs less than the bare metal wire tip that is left exposed now.
These are simple, clean ski touring and ski mountaineering bindings for most users. Given the ease of use limitations, we'd recommend other options for beginning backcountry skiers.
Provided the durability continues to hold up, these should last a long time at a relatively reasonable price. While we had no troubles with the Plum Guide, it is worth noting that we had a fairly major failure of the cousin Plum Race 150. It is only worth noting here because our Plum customer service (in the US) following that issue was very slow and problematic. If our experience is any indication, getting good customer service for your Plum bindings is difficult.
Plum bindings have a loyal following. Their flagship Guide bindings are widely proven and have years now of use in the field. They are a little trickier to use than others, and you have to hope you don't need spare parts on short notice, but overall you should be happy with them.
— Jediah Porter
Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.
GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.Learn More