Reviews You Can Rely On

Sorel Madson II Chukka Review

These rain boots are a stylish choice if your main priority is staying dry in the city
Sorel Madson II Chukka
Photo: Sorel
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $175 List | $174.95 at Backcountry
Compare prices at 2 resellers
Pros:  Lightweight, very stylish, comfortable
Cons:  Flood height is a low 2.75", slightly narrow for standard width feet, expensive
Manufacturer:   Sorel
By Richard Forbes ⋅ Review Editor  ⋅  May 12, 2021
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
50
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#13 of 14
  • Weather Protection - 30% 2
  • Comfort - 25% 6
  • Traction - 20% 6
  • Warmth - 15% 5
  • Style - 10% 9

Our Verdict

The Sorel Madson II Chukka boots take the 80-year-old chukka design and modernize it with waterproofed suede and a new and improved chunky outsole. While their lack of a waterproof gusset means that they're not the most weatherproof boots in our test, they were more than enough for rainy day chores around town. If you're in the market for a pair of casually dressy waterproof shoes, and you're planning to wear them year-round in rain or shine, these stylish kicks are a great choice.

Compare to Similar Products

 
Awards  Editors' Choice Award Top Pick Award  Best Buy Award 
Price $174.95 at Backcountry
Compare at 2 sellers
$164.95 at Amazon$145.00 at Amazon$64.99 at Amazon$55.00 at Amazon
Overall Score Sort Icon
50
82
74
67
65
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Lightweight, very stylish, comfortableExtremely weatherproof, decently lightweight, great tractionExtremely warm, grippyAffordable, well-insulated, great tractionHighly waterproof, stiff construction for rough terrain, great traction
Cons Flood height is a low 2.75", slightly narrow for standard width feet, expensivePretty pricey, thin-feeling underfootToo warm for most uses, too tight to easily slip on and offNot as comfortable as other modelsLooser fit, lacks insulation
Bottom Line These rain boots are a stylish choice if your main priority is staying dry in the cityThese boots performed highly in every test we threw at them, and we're confident they'll keep you dry and happyThis impressive boot will keep you toasty when all else fails, though they'll be far too warm for normal conditionsWhile we love many of the innovative aspects of these boots, we wish they could provide more support underfootThis workhorse boasts a very fair price for such a rugged boot
Rating Categories Sorel Madson II Chukka The Original Muck B... The Original Muck B... Kamik Icebreaker Baffin Enduro
Weather Protection (30%)
2.0
9.0
9.0
6.0
8.0
Comfort (25%)
6.0
8.0
4.0
6.0
6.0
Traction (20%)
6.0
8.0
9.0
8.0
8.0
Warmth (15%)
5.0
9.0
10.0
7.0
3.0
Style (10%)
9.0
5.0
4.0
7.0
5.0
Specs Sorel Madson II Chukka The Original Muck B... The Original Muck B... Kamik Icebreaker Baffin Enduro
Weight per Pair (size 13) 2.4 lbs 4.72 lbs 5.74 lbs 4.58 lbs 5.49 lbs
Flood Height (inches from bottom of sole to lowest point at top of shaft) 2.75" 18" 17.6" 14.3 in 16.3"
Mouth Circumference (inches) 14.5" 18.75" 15.25" 16.5" 17.5"
Lining/Insulation Synthetic and textile 5 mm neoprene Fleece Moisture wicking removable Zylex liner Synthetic
Upper Material Waterproof suede Rubber Rubber Rubber with waterproof adjustable nylon collar Rubber
Outsole Material Molded rubber Rubber MS-1 molded outsole TRACKER synthetic Rubber Rubber
Insole EVA EVA EVA molded midsole with contoured footbed and 2mm thermal foam underlay 11mm Zylex insole Gel-Flex shock-absorbing heels and midsoles
Unique Features Seam-sealed waterproof suede construction Breathable air mesh lining Neoprene shaft, thick insulation, and aggressive outsole Drawstring, Zylex liner Aggressive outsole
Width Options Regular Regular Regular Regular Regular
Sizing info Order next size up Order next size up Order next size up Order next size up Order your true size

Our Analysis and Test Results

The Madson II Chukka fits into Sorel's "Madson" lineup — a series of waterproof boots that are designed to look good and be comfortable. This lineup is not designed to be super-waterproof, and as a result, the Chukka have a pretty low flood height. Still, they're pretty practical boots, as they're dressy enough to be worn in the city without attracting any weird looks. We found them to be perfect for comfortably kicking around town, but we wouldn't recommend them for anyone who plans to spend a lot of time in the mud.

Performance Comparison


The wind kicked up while we were doing this photoshoot!
The wind kicked up while we were doing this photoshoot!
Photo: Richard Forbes

Weather Protection


We tested the Madson Moc Toe back in 2019, and the Chukka has the same major issues. The gussets (the folds between the tongue and the boot proper) aren't waterproof, and as a result, the flood height of the boot is only 2.75". This means that even small puddles can get your feet wet, especially if you don't tie the laces tightly. We found that these were waterproof enough for most rainy situations, but they really aren't that protective. If only the boots had waterproof gussets, their flood height would double (to ~ 5"). But alas, Sorel didn't want to go to the extra trouble.

If you look closely at the left boot, you'll see that this is as...
If you look closely at the left boot, you'll see that this is as deep as they can go (the water's right at the bottom of the gusset).
Photo: Richard Forbes

Taking a closer look at the leaky gussets (those leather folds...
Taking a closer look at the leaky gussets (those leather folds alongside the tongue).
Photo: Richard Forbes

Comfort


The Chukka is the lightest in our test, weighing in at only 2.4 lbs, and as a result, you'll barely notice you're wearing them, especially compared to some of the 5+ lb clunkers in our test. We love lighter boots like these because they let us forget how long we've been up and on our feet.

Our biggest issue with these boots is that they're narrower than any others in our test, though we realize this narrower cut is part of the aesthetic. This didn't feel great with our slightly wider feet, but we'll get into this more in the "Fit" section below. We also wish the insole was a bit thicker, but the midsoles are cushioned enough to make these comfortable for full days on your feet.

If this insole were any thicker, we would have had issues getting...
If this insole were any thicker, we would have had issues getting these low-volume shoes on.
Photo: Richard Forbes

Traction


The new outsole is the best part of the upgrades from the 2019 Madson to this newer Madson II. We were relatively unimpressed by the outsole on the 2019 Madson — it just had a series of semi-lugged ridges. This new outsole is a lot more solid, with deeper lugs, more lateral traction, and the rubber compound feels stickier.

As a result, the outsole on the Chukka feels significantly grippier on pretty much all the surfaces we tested, from wet grass to muck. If you'll be on the slickest of surfaces, you'll want a heavier-duty boot with more studs, but for most conditions, you should feel confident with these boots.

The outsole on this model is a big improvement from previous...
The outsole on this model is a big improvement from previous iterations in the Madson line.
Photo: Richard Forbes

Warmth


Since the Chukka is made of suede (leather), it does a better job of insulating your feet than similarly insulated rubber. As a result, these boots kept our feet comfortable for a solid five minutes in the ice bath test (compared to the 30 seconds we were getting from similar rubber boots). At the same time, leather also breathes better than solid rubber, and so we found that these boots are also pretty comfortable in warmer conditions.

These boots aren't the best choice if you're planning to spend a lot of time in chilly conditions, and with their narrower fit, you won't be able to easily wear thicker socks. However, if you're not planning to stand around in the cold, these will be perfectly comfortable as long as you're in 20+ degree temps.

Our ice bath test is tricky in boots with only a 2.75" flood height.
Our ice bath test is tricky in boots with only a 2.75" flood height.
Photo: Richard Forbes

Style


If nothing else, these boots are stylish. The chukka design has been around and popular since the 1940s. According to Wikipedia, chukkas can be worn with suits or with jeans, so feel to wear these to a wedding! You definitely can't say that about any of the other boots in our test. Our style consultants all agreed — these boots look great, and everyone around will be admiring your style.

These are some stylish boots!
These are some stylish boots!
Photo: Richard Forbes

Fit


These boots felt a bit small for our D-width feet, but we think that's because they run pretty narrow. After breaking the leather in over a few weeks, they got more comfortable, but they still didn't fit perfectly. So if you've got wider feet, we'd recommend steering clear of the Chukka. Otherwise, we were wearing size 13 boots on our size 12 feet, and that gave us just enough toe wiggle room to feel good.

These run narrow, so may be best to avoid if you have especially...
These run narrow, so may be best to avoid if you have especially wide feet. At the very least, size up.
Photo: Richard Forbes

Value


It's tricky to talk about the value when it comes to these boots because they're definitely expensive. However, they're much more versatile than most of the rubber rain boots in our test, as they can also double as casual around-town shoes. You can probably even get away with using them as dress boots. And since they're made of high-quality suede, they're both breathable and warm enough for most weather conditions you'll find. However, if you're just looking for a good pair of rain boots, you can find a lot more water resistance for a lot less money if you look elsewhere in our test.

The Sorel Madson II Chukka boots gently bobbing in Puget Sound.
The Sorel Madson II Chukka boots gently bobbing in Puget Sound.
Photo: Richard Forbes

Conclusion


Overall, these Chukka boots do a great job at being a lightweight dressy boot for rainy days. If you get them because you need something heavy-duty for working outdoors, you'll be disappointed. But if you want a pair of comfortable city boots that will keep your feet dry in most types of weather (but not puddles or deeper water), we recommend them.

Richard Forbes