Kamik Olivia Review
Cons: Stiffness, no insulation
Compare to Similar Products
$44.95 at Amazon
|$110.00 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
$34.10 at Amazon
|$50.93 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
$37.71 at Amazon
|Pros||Inexpensive, stylish, great weather protection||Trendy, comfortable, extra warm||Mid-height shaft, fashionable, substantial traction||Durable, trendy, lightweight||Inexpensive, quirky style, dependable traction|
|Cons||Stiffness, no insulation||Shorter flood height than shaft height, not as affordable||Basic foot support, no insulation||Low weather protection, narrow footbed||Blister potential, no lining|
|Bottom Line||A simple yet stylish boot that's both practical and affordable||A cute hybrid boot that offers extra warmth and style in addition to rain protection||A very straightforward, elegant boot that is highly affordable and good looking enough to go from the garden to the coffee shop||This ankle-height boot is trendy and practical despite its short shaft||An inexpensive and fairly lightweight boot with fun patterns and aggressive tread|
|Rating Categories||Kamik Olivia||Bogs Amanda Plush I...||Kamik Heidi||Bogs SweetPea||Sloggers Rain and G...|
|Weather Protection (30%)|
|Specs||Kamik Olivia||Bogs Amanda Plush I...||Kamik Heidi||Bogs SweetPea||Sloggers Rain and G...|
|Weight per Pair||3.6 lbs (size 8)||3.0 lbs (size 8)||2.7 lbs (size 8)||1.6 lbs (size 8)||2.6 lbs (size 8)|
|Flood Height (inches from bottom of sole to lowest point of shaft)||14 in||7.50 in||12 in||4.75 in||10.5 in|
|Mouth Circumference||15 in||12-14 in||13.75 in||10 in||14 in|
|Upper Material||Rubber||Rubber||Phthalate-free Synthetic Rubber||Textured rubber||Rubber|
|Outsole Material||Rubber||Rubber||Synthetic Rubber Blend||Rubber||Rubber|
|Insole||Breathable mesh||Max-Wick insole||Removeable Kamik(R) Comfort Footbed||Max-Wick insole||Removable insole|
|Unique Features||Recyclable||BLOOM algae-based EVA footbed, DuraFresh odor control, comfort rating of "-13F"||Recyclable||Anti-odor lining||50% Recycled materials, made in USA|
|Sizing info||True to size||True to size||True to size||True to size||True to size|
Our Analysis and Test Results
With a removable, mesh-lined insole, the Kamik Olivia is an EcoLogic rubber boot with recyclable soles. EcoLogic is a plant-based, 100% recyclable rubber that provides durability and a sustainable option for the market. The Olivia is a fairly simple, yet versatile contender with ample traction to keep you steady and dry.
Measuring 14 inches from the ground, the Olivia isn't the tallest in this review. But, with a shaft that hits the top of the calf, weather protection is high. With a mouth circumference of 15 inches at this height, the shaft is narrow enough to help prevent rain from sneaking in. That said, this snug circumference was deemed uncomfortable for reviewers with larger calves.
The biggest drawback of the Olivia is in their relative stiffness. Being taller and thicker than some of the others we've tested, they are simply not as flexible. This means that driving and general all-day wear is a tad more cumbersome — but only slightly. They are still a comfortable pair to walk around in, to put on and take off, and lug around. As is common, heel slippage did occur, and the front of the shaft press into the shin slightly on inclines. Many of these particular drawbacks are to be expected, however, in boots with tall shafts. For our lead tester, who usually wears as 7.5, the foot box was just roomy enough for her foot and thick socks at the size 8 we tested.
With a pronounced tread, the soles of the Olivia perform incredibly well across flat surfaces, with above-average scores in the snow and on grassy inclines. Overall, however, they did not fare as well as some of the more flexible and sensitive boots in the group. This means that the more rugged or icy the conditions, the worse our confidence became in our ability to stay upright.
The thicker rubber of this competitor helps maintain heat quite well. They even held up when we walked across snow, but only for a short period of time. Not meant for winter, the thin lining is all you get. Best for temperatures fluctuating between 40 and 70 degrees Fahrenheit, it's easy to adapt sock thickness to your preferred comforts. Keep in mind, however, that higher warmth ratings mean sweatier feet if your environment is consistently warmer or if you plan to do a lot of activity.
With a matte, sleek look, the Olivia blends traditional with modern. The molded accents, coupled with the buckle, give off a horseback riding boot vibe, but not so much that versatility is limited. Wear them with skinny jeans, leggings, or long socks and a dress. The only catch is that, since the circumference is narrow relative to its height, it is more difficult to wear pants without them bulging or looking baggy around the top of the shaft.
Kamik offers whole sizes from 6-11 and runs true to size. If you wear a half-size shoe, it is recommended to size up. The fit is generous enough to wear thicker socks, but not so much that your feet swim when wearing thinner ones. Again, the main gripe is the circumference of the boot opening. Being at the height that it is, the opening is right in line with the widest part of the calf (at least it was for us). This can be very uncomfortable or even unwearable for people with calves any wider than 14 inches in circumference. The buckles are non-functional and do not adjust anything, so make sure you know your calf measurements when considering this boot.
Designed and manufactured in Canada, this model is cheap without skimping on quality and performance. We think this is a great value for rainwear, especially due to the sustainable practices of the brand, a celebrated company whose recycling practices are nearly unmatched in this market.
If only this pair was either a tad taller or a tad shorter to hit that sweet spot for its circumference, we'd be a lot more in love. The Olivia is an exceptional boot that provides ample weather protection, traction, and warmth. Cute for all your across town needs, they are durable and dependable for all your rainy day ventures.
— Sara Aranda
Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.
GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.Learn More