Hands-on Gear Review

The North Face Hedgehog Hike GTX Review

TNF Hedgehog Hike GTX
Price:  $140 List
Pros:  Lightweight, good foot support, all-around traction
Cons:  Durability concerns, break-in period required
Editors' Rating:   
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Measured Weight of Pair, Size 12:  2.2 lbs.
Waterproof Lining:  GORE-TEX
Upper:  Full-grain leather, textile mesh, synthetic overlays
Manufacturer:   The North Face

Our Verdict

The Hedgehog Hike GTX is No Longer Available as of 2017
The new North Face Hedgehog Hike GTX delivers good rough terrain performance and carries light and medium loads well. Quite light among the shoes we tested, we like it for both dayhiking and short backpacking trips. The full leather toe is a nod to durability for rocky terrain, but the mostly mesh upper keeps the weight low and breathes well.

Compared to our Editors' Choice winner The North Face Ultra 110 GTX, the Hedgehog Hike takes longer to break in, has a little more foot support, and has a higher volume fit. While we love the Ultra 109 for its do-everything versatility, the Hedgehog Hike may be a better choice for backpacking over rough terrain.

Our Best Buy winner the Keen Targhee 2 is a more comfortable shoe for most hikers. Meanwhile the La Sportiva FC Eco 2.0, our Top Pick for Backpacking, is a good bit heavier, but also delivers more foot support. For folks with wide feet, the ECO might be a bit narrow.



RELATED REVIEW: Best Hiking Shoes For Men of 2018

Our Analysis and Test Results

Review by:
Brandon Lampley

Last Updated:
Friday
November 11, 2016

Share:

Hands-On Review


The North Face Hedgehog Hike GTX scores well for support and traction, and is one of the lightest hiking shoes we tested. However, for a lightweight product, this model takes a little while to break in. The full leather toe and large protective rubber rand led to flexpoints that caused top of foot discomfort for our lead tester at first.

Performance Comparison


The Hedgehog is well-matched to steep rocky trails. In addition to the foot support provided by the full TPU plate  we appreciate the protection from pointy rocks underfoot too.
The Hedgehog is well-matched to steep rocky trails. In addition to the foot support provided by the full TPU plate, we appreciate the protection from pointy rocks underfoot too.

Comfort


Most super light hiking shoes are comfortable right out of the box, but our lead tester found this product became more comfortable after brief break-in period. It takes a little while for the one-piece leather toe to become supple and mold to your toe and forefoot flex. The lacing system used on the Hedgehog is mostly traditional, but includes the two eyes close together up at the top. Having a choice of using one or both allows you to adjust the ankle collar fit better than you could with a single upper eye. A big plus in the comfort metric for this product is great breathability thanks to the mostly mesh upper and mesh tongue.

This product is relatively stiff and supportive considering its light weight. After a break-in period  these shoes become more comfortable for dayhiking.
This product is relatively stiff and supportive considering its light weight. After a break-in period, these shoes become more comfortable for dayhiking.

Weight


The size 12 model that we evaluated weighed in at 2.2 lbs The Vasque Juxt and Merrell Moab Ventilator are both a couple of ounces lighter, but do not provide as much foot support. This is the lightest product we tested that earned an eight in our foot support metric. The Keen Targhee 2 is a little more supportive, and only a fraction heavier. Overall, however, we found the Targhee 2 a much more comfortable product.

Support


We found that the EVA midsole and full foot TPU plate delivered better-than-average foot support. The La Sportiva FC ECO 2.0 provides much more foot support for backpacking, but is much heavier. All told, we feel the Hedgehog Hike's support is quite good relative to its weight.

Traction


Overall, the Hedgehog Hike earned a good traction score. In dry conditions, it provides good grip on loose gravelly trails and scrambles over talus well enough. It holds its own in a little mud, but its shallow lugs don't dig in as well as higher profile lugs.

Versatility


We did not find this shoe to be appropriate for trail running, not even a little bit. Otherwise, we found it works well for hiking for the variety of terrain we play on, and it has the foot support for carrying light loads. With a bright "The North Face" logo emblazoned on the outside of the toe, you probably won't be wearing them out to dinner or to the office.

Unfortunately  the bright white logos detract from what would be an unassuming everyday and casual shoe.
Unfortunately, the bright white logos detract from what would be an unassuming everyday and casual shoe.

Water Resistance


Our feet stayed perfectly dry in this shoe. The Gore-Tex liner does its job perfectly, but the substantial mesh bit of the upper soaks up more water than other shoes. We also have concerns about the long term durability of the liner at the forefoot flex point.

Durability


We have a few concerns about the durability of this shoe. On our test model, we experienced a couple of delaminations. The rubber toe rand at the inner forefoot flex point was beginning to come loose from the leather toe material; and on the same shoe, the EVA midsole began to come unglued from the leather upper. Although only a few millimeters, we've found over the years that delaminations like this grow as sand and dirt get inside.

Best Applications


While we liked this shoe for dayhiking, especially on warm days where its good breathability helped with comfort. The North Face Hedgehog Hike has the most foot support of the lightest models we tested and we feel its best use is light backpacking trips.

We feel the best applications for the Hedgehog are dayhiking in rough terrain  or light to medium weighted backpacking trips. This shoe received the highest support score among the lightest shoes.
We feel the best applications for the Hedgehog are dayhiking in rough terrain, or light to medium weighted backpacking trips. This shoe received the highest support score among the lightest shoes.

Value


With a full price of $140, we don't feel this shoe is a great value. We found the Hedgehog Hike an average performing shoe with an above average price.

Conclusion


The North Face Hedgehog Hike GTX is a good hiking shoe for folks that want good foot support in a very light shoe.

Brandon Lampley

You Might Also Like

OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews


Most recent review: April 4, 2017
Summary of All Ratings

OutdoorGearLab Editors' Rating:  
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (4.0)
Average Customer Rating:  
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (3.0)

50% of 2 reviewers recommend it
 
Rating Distribution
3 Total Ratings
5 star: 0%  (0)
4 star: 67%  (2)
3 star: 0%  (0)
2 star: 33%  (1)
1 star: 0%  (0)
Kayaker

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
   Apr 4, 2017 - 01:56am
SavoryScot · Kayaker · Austin, TX
I have the mid-size version of these and they're awesome. I wouldn't wear them hiking (trail runners are better IMO) but I got these for hiking and ended up wearing them as non stealtoe work boots for renovating a house.
Now, they're not designed for that but I will say this, working on my feet all day, standing on a ladder for hours at a time, these have excellent ankle support, and out of the box comfort and walking through puddles, dealing with buckets full of water, cleaning brushes, etc my feet stayed dry. The ONLY time they got wet was when I let water get down inside the boot from the top. If water gets in that way, if you're not wearing gaiters or rain pants pulled over the top of the boot/shoe then once the inside is wet then you're gonna have a bad time.

I also had a nail go through the bottom of shoe into my foot, but other than a small sharp finishing nail no rocks or glass or jagged boards bothered me, it was only placing weight directly onto a pointed object that is designed to pierce a hard surface that I had a problem.

For hiking I imagine these are great but you had better be prepared to keep water out of the opening at the top.

Great comfort and great fit right out of the box. Tons of ankle support, there were a few times that my bad ankles tried to buckle but the shoe is so supportive that I only stumbled but my ankle never buckled.

I probably won't buy another pair of these because hiking boots are old school, but if trail running shoes aren't supportive enough, I'd get these, they're nice and lightweight too. I also don't understand the durability concerns, mine have held up great on a construction site, but I imagine as with anything YMMV.



Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this product to a friend.

Backpacker

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
   Jul 5, 2016 - 11:31am
dcader · Backpacker · Hamilton, Ontario

This was my first backpacking trip wearing hiking shoes as compared to traditional hiking boots. I was hoping that these shoes would be a good option for warm weather hiking and backpacking, but unfortunately they didn't stand up very well to the demands of backcountry hiking.

Pros:
  • Good traction, even on whet rocks and logs.

Cons:
  • Ineffective water proofing. Just walking trough wet grass was enough to soak them.
  • Once wet, they take forever to dry out. I had wet feet for most of my 3 day trip.
  • Durability concerns. Found a big puncture in the foam at the side of the shoe on my very first hike.

Also, after the break-in period they seemed to have a much larger fit. I ended up with blisters on my toes from my feet sliding around. Unfortunately, this past weekend will probably be the first and last trip for these shoes.



Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this product to a friend.


Have you used this product?
Don't hold back. Share your viewpoint by posting a review with your thoughts...