Having fallen head-over-heels in love with another Smartwool product, our testing team was excitedly looking forward to testing this new, updated product. It didn't take long, unfortunately, to realize that our expectations were about to fall short with the Smartwool Merino Seamless Bikini. With a thick, itchy material and an uncomfortable, wedgie-inducing fit, we know that this model wouldn't be taking home any awards. While reasonably stretchy and breathable with an average drying time, it wasn't all bad, but the fit was the nail in the coffin for this product. For a more comfortable wool product, we highly recommend the Smartwool Merino 150 Bikini, and for our most breathable, best-fitting model, the Editors' Choice Award-winning ExOfficio Give-n-Go Sport Mesh Hipkini is tough to beat.
Smartwool Merino Seamless Bikini Review
Compare prices at 3 resellers Pros: Uncomfortable material, poor fit, expensive
Cons: Decent drying time, naturally odor-free
Compare to Similar Products
Smartwool Merino Seamless Bikini
|Price||$21.93 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$11.73 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$22.00 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$24.00 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$12.00 at Amazon|
|Pros||Uncomfortable material, poor fit, expensive||Super comfortable, breathable, inexpensive||Breathable, comfortable, inexpensive||Great fit, comfortable material, inexpensive||Inexpensive, soft, quick-drying|
|Cons||Decent drying time, naturally odor-free||Heavier||Tight fit||Slower to dry, thicker material||Annoying fit|
|Bottom Line||Our testers found this pair to be an itchy, ill-fitting bikini with few redeeming qualities.||As kind to your budget as it is to your body, this hipkini is an all-time staff favorite.||The Barely Hipster is a super comfortable and affordable product made to stand the heat.||The Active Hipster is a stand-out product that excels in fit and comfort.||The UA Pure Stretch Hipster is soft, stretchy, and quick to dry, all at an amazing price.|
|Rating Categories||Merino Seamless Bikini||Give-N-Go Sport Mesh Hipkini||Patagonia Barely Hipster||Patagonia Active Hipster||Pure Stretch Hipster|
|Drying Time (30%)|
|Specs||Merino Seamless...||Give-N-Go Sport...||Patagonia Barely...||Patagonia Active...||Pure Stretch Hipster|
|Material||71% Merino Wool, 23% Nylon, 6% Elastane||94% Nylon, 6% Lycra||89% Nylon, 11% Spandex||81% Nylon, 12% Spandex||68% Nylon, 32% Elastane|
|Weight (oz)||1.0 oz||1.1 oz||.8 oz||.9 oz||.7 oz|
Our Analysis and Test Results
While the Smartwool Seamless Bikini is likely better than your average cotton undies, there are many reasons why it didn't take home an award. Its awkward fit was prone to riding up, causing significant annoyance after just a short period of wear. We also found the material to be less comfortable than the soft, silky smooth fabrics of some of its competitors.
After testing the thin, silky smooth Smartwool 150 Merino, we were a bit perplexed by the Seamless. The material is considerably thicker and itchier, which we found disappointing. We found the thick material to be less breathable than the lighter fabric of the ExOfficio Sport Mesh or Patagonia Barely Hipster, also adding to this product's lower score in this metric.
Here, we considered the cut, waistband, stretch, and ability to stay in place. Nothing deters us from a difficult hike or long ski tour like a wedgie, and that's the first thing we noticed about the Seamless. The bikini cut has less coverage than some of its competitors, like the ultra-conservative Patagonia Active Hipster, but we found this to cause significantly less security on the move. The leg openings are both higher and looser than many of this product's competitors, and we found that this led to more wedgies than some of the other products we tested. While tighter leg openings may not sound appealing, a properly stretchy yet form-fitting leg opening helps keep the undies in place. The Seamless was quite disappointing in this category for this reason.
We found the waistband to fit well, and the undies are definitely stretchier than the Merino 150. This made them a potential contender for activities where stretch is paramount, like yoga, exercise classes, or climbing. That being said, there are products in this review that accomplish stretch alongside a secure fit, like the Patagonia Active Hipster.
The ability to stay dry in your base layers is incredibly important to both comfort and safety in the backcountry, as wet layers on our skin keep us colder longer. With travel undies, the ability to dry out quickly is as important to sweat as it is to travel ease. When we're on the road for weeks at a time, the ability to wash our undies in a sink or stream will keep us (and our travel partners) happy, and no one wants to sit around all day waiting for laundry to dry! To test this category, we soaked each pair in water and hung them on a line to dry side-by-side.
Despite the thicker material, we were surprised at how quickly the Seamless dried. While it wasn't as fast as the Under Armour Pure Stretch, these dried in an average amount of time, making them a decent fit for life on the road or trail.
Because these undies are used for life on the move, we considered two criteria for this category: weight and packing size. We weighed each product on our own scale to get the most accurate measurements and then judged their compactness and size next to each other.
The Seamless from Smartwool is on the heavier side of the undies we tested. At exactly 1 ounce, it's lighter than a few other models. If you're looking for a wool model that is lighter, the Smartwool Merino 150 is tied for the lightest product in this review.
Because wool is naturally odor-free, thinking merino is always a good idea if odor control is among your chief reasons for investing in some fancy undies. That being said, the Merino 150 has a higher percentage of wool in its blend and is more comfortable. On the flip side, the Seamless is stretchier, which could be a selling point. We recommend checking this product out in person before buying to make sure that material suits your fancy.
The Seamless is an expensive pair of underwear. At $32, it's on the highest side of the products we tested. It's a bit more expensive than the Merino 150, at $30, which was our favorite wool model, and significantly more expensive than the $24 ExOfficio Sport Mesh which took home our Editors' Choice Award winner.
One of the first things we realized about underwear was that the best products were ones that you could put on and forget about. While we enjoy an outstanding shoe or jacket, we never want to think about our undies until it's time to change. Unfortunately, the Smartwool Merino Seamless left us fidgeting and adjusting constantly. The itchy material and poor fit were deal breakers despite this product's decent drying time and stretch. For a more comfy wool option, we strongly recommend the Merino 150, also from Smartwool.
— Lauren DeLaunay