The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of outdoor gear

Columbia Panther Creek - Women's Review

This light and simple shell isn't overly technical, but it does make a great starter jacket at a very nice price.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $85 List | $84.95 at MooseJaw
Compare prices at 2 resellers
Pros:  Excellent mobility, decent breathability, lightweight, great price point
Cons:  Tailoring is a bit awkward, not very warm, hood is a little tight with a helmet
Manufacturer:   Columbia
By Penney Garrett ⋅ Senior Review Editor  ⋅  May 22, 2019
  • Share this article:
70
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#12 of 15
  • Weather Protection - 30% 5
  • Breathability - 30% 7
  • Mobility - 25% 9
  • Weight - 10% 8
  • Versatility - 5% 6

Our Verdict

The Columbia Panther Creek is a simple and relatively lightweight shell that's good for swing season activities. It's not super warm, but it breathes and moves well and has a generous fit that's easy to layer under. The sleeves run short, and the hood gets a little tight with a helmet, but overall this affordable layer is a fine choice if you just need a bit of protection and you don't want to spend a ton of money.

If you want something more technical and tailored toward climbing, our Editors' Choice for Warmer Weather, the Arc'teryx Sigma SL Anorak Pullover is a fantastic layer — though it is about twice the price. Other great options for not that much more than the Panther are our two Best Buy winners, the ultralight Outdoor Research Whirlwind Pullover and the great fitting Rab Borealis.


Compare to Similar Products

Our Analysis and Test Results

The Panther Creek isn't a highly technical piece, but it is very affordable and perfectly adequate for simple, moderate weather outings like hiking and biking.

Performance Comparison


While there are more technically-savvy layers to have  this one is totally decent for a lot of things and the price is fair.
While there are more technically-savvy layers to have, this one is totally decent for a lot of things and the price is fair.

Weather Protection


The Panther repels a bit of water but can't withstand too much for too long. It's also not particularly warm being mostly polyester with no lining or insulation. If the weather is mild and your body is moving all will be well, but this isn't the jacket to get for weathering storms. That being said, the fit is on the baggier side so layering up underneath is super easy.

The Panther is just right on a cloudy cool day in early spring  though if those clouds in the background open up we will be wet and cold.
The Panther is just right on a cloudy cool day in early spring, though if those clouds in the background open up we will be wet and cold.

Breathability


Breathability is just okay in this layer. It's thin enough that you won't be stifled, but the material isn't super technical or high quality. The pockets are mesh-lined though so you can vent if things get clammy.

While this layer isn't the most breathable  it's decent and the mesh-lined pockets help with ventilation.
While this layer isn't the most breathable, it's decent and the mesh-lined pockets help with ventilation.

Mobility


The Panther has great mobility as long as you're not wearing a helmet — the back of the neck gets a bit tight in that scenario. The arms are a bit short, and the fit is on the baggy/boxy side, but we didn't feel impeded or restricted in any way when out and about.

The Panther Creek is thin  generously cut  and easy to move in.
The Panther Creek is thin, generously cut, and easy to move in.

Weight


This jacket weighs 10.8 ounces in a size medium and can pack down quite small, making it suitable for situations where space is at a premium. If you want to add another layer to your arsenal that won't take up much space and is super cheap, the Panther is a good candidate.

This isn't a highly technical layer  but for a bit of extra protection hiking around it does the trick without weighing you down.
This isn't a highly technical layer, but for a bit of extra protection hiking around it does the trick without weighing you down.

Versatility


Versatility is so-so for the Panther. It's decently featured but not in a technically-minded way, the cut is not overly flattering, and it's performance in regards to weather protection and breathability limit what it's good for. However, it is durable, lightweight, easy to layer over or under, and very cheap, making it a solid choice for a beginner outdoorswoman or for someone that just needs a little something extra for hiking or walking the dog.

The Panther has a generous fit except when it comes to arm length. While it's decently versatile within its wheelhouse you will feel limited if you try to get too technical.
The Panther has a generous fit except when it comes to arm length. While it's decently versatile within its wheelhouse you will feel limited if you try to get too technical.

Best Application


With thin material and entry-level features, this layer is good for simple non-technical outings in mild weather. Hiking, biking, camping, and strolling with the pup are all good applications. If you need a jacket for outings that require a helmet or harness, you might be happier with a layer tailored specifically toward your activity of choice.

Chillin' with the pup is perfect for the Panther. Getting wet in a canyon or cold on a rock climb will require a more technical and finely-tuned jacket.
Chillin' with the pup is perfect for the Panther. Getting wet in a canyon or cold on a rock climb will require a more technical and finely-tuned jacket.

Value


This is an affordable layer, currently the cheapest in our review. It's not a highly technical piece, but for the price it's great.

Conclusion


The Panther Creek is a simple entry-level shell at a very affordable price point. It has excellent mobility, doesn't weigh much, and breathability is decent particularly when considering the mesh-lined pockets. It's not very warm, and water resistance is just okay, but if all you need is a cheap layer for non-technical outings this one will surely suffice.

Light  comfy  and affordable - this is a good layer if you don't need something very technical.
Light, comfy, and affordable - this is a good layer if you don't need something very technical.


Penney Garrett