Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
![]() This Product
Patagonia Stormshadow | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Awards | Best Overall Men's Winter Jacket | Best for 3-Season Wear | Best Warm Daily Wear on a Budget | Best Value for Sloppy Wet Winters | |
| Price | $899 List Check Price at Patagonia | $535 List Check Price at REI | $699 List Check Price at Backcountry | $220 List Check Backcountry (on sale!) | $299 List Check Price at REI |
Overall Score ![]() |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Bottom Line | An excellent option that employs both recycled down and fabrics to keep you toasty and dry | A stylish, durable parka that is well-equipped for extended exposure to snow, wind, rain, and cold | Three jackets combine to provide excellent versatility and style in a protective winter jacket | One of our favorite everyday jackets, because it's warm, affordable, well-built, versatile, and stylish | A versatile and high-performance winter jacket with plenty of warmth and weather protection at a great price |
| Rating Categories | Patagonia Stormshadow | Fjallraven Nuuk Parka | Patagonia Tres 3-in-... | Columbia Landroamer II | REI Co-op Stormhenge... |
| Warmth (30%) | |||||
| Weather Resistance (25%) | |||||
| Comfort (25%) | |||||
| Versatility and Style (10%) | |||||
| Construction Quality (10%) | |||||
| Specifications | Patagonia Stormshadow | Fjallraven Nuuk Parka | Patagonia Tres 3-in-... | Columbia Landroamer II | REI Co-op Stormhenge... |
| Insulation and Fill Power | 700-fill down | 100% recycled polyester | 700-fill down | Synthetic | 850-fill goose down, 180 g polyester fill (98% recycled) in hem and cuffs, 80 g polyester fill in hood, sleeves, and side panels |
| Fill Weight | Not specified | 250 grams/ sq meter | Not specified | 200 grams | Down: 180 grams, polyester: 80 grams |
| Removable Hood | No | No | Yes | Yes | No |
| Hood Adjustments | 2 side drawcords, 1 rear drawcord | 2 side drawcords, 1 rear velcro tab | 2 side drawcords, 1 rear drawcord | 2 side drawcords, 1 topside adjustment strap | 2 side drawcords, 1 rear drawcord |
| Shell Fabric | 100% recycled polyester | Polyamide | H2No performance: 2-layer, 100% recycled polyester herringbone | 100% polyester | HydroWall 2L |
| Measured Interior Temperature | 76.4 °F | 80.2 °F | 76.3 °F | 75 °F | 73.5 °F |
| Pockets | 1 zippered mid section, 1 interior zippered chest, 1 interior stash drop-in | 2 zippered breast pockets; 2 buttoned breast pockets; 2 top-loading bellow pockets; 2 fleece-lined handwarmer pockets; 1 media pocket on sleeve, 2 internal zippered chest pockets, 2 internal mesh stash drop-in pockets | 6 (exterior jacket: 1 zippered chest, 2 top-entry zippered waist with flap; interior jacket: 2 zippered waist, 1 zippered interior media pocket | 2 exterior top-loading chest, 2 exterior top-loading waist, 1 zippered chest, 2 zippered waist, | 2 exterior zippered waist, 1 exterior zippered chest, 1 zippered interior media pocket, 2 stash drop-in |
| Weight | 2.6 lb (XL) | 4.6 lb (2XL) | 3.4 lb (2XL) | 3.2 lb (XLT) | 1.9 lb (2XL) |
| 2-Way Front Zipper | Yes | Yes | Yes - on outer jacket only | No | Yes |
| Weather Resistant Features | GORE-TEX ePE waterproof shell, drawstring hood, main zipper storm flap, drawstring waist, elastic cuffs, adjustable cuffs, insulated hood | Faux fur lined hood, cinchable hood and waist, adjustable cuffs, heavy exterior shell, rugged front zipper flap, water-resistant shell, | Full-length design, H2No Performance standard waterproof membrane, cinchable hood and hem, adjustable cuffs | Drawstring hood and hem, main zipper storm flap, adjustable cuffs, sealed seams, Omni-Heat Infinity lining, | Cinchable hood and hem, water-resistant shell, spandex cuffs |
| Available Sizes | XS - 3 XL | XS - 3XL | XS - 3XL | S - 3XL | XS - 3XL |
| Social or Environmental Certifications | 100% recycled down, 100% recyccled shell, PFAS-free DWR finish,, | Shell, lining, and filling made from 100% recycled polyester | Produced in a Made in a Fair Trade certified factory, 100% reclaimed and recycled duck and goose down, shell and lining of outer and inner jacket are 100% recycled polyester | None specified | Produced in a Fair Trade certified factory, contains recycled that meet the Bluesign criteria, Climate Neutral brand certified |
Our Analysis and Test Results
Likes
We loved this jacket's quality construction. Immediately after unboxing, we could see that the Patagonia Stormshadow was crafted from top-tier fabrics and components, giving it great functionality and durability.
In addition to superb construction features, we also loved that both the shell and the 700-down fill are composed of 100-percent recycled materials. The fact that the down is repurposed from other down products made us super happy.
The Stormshadow is warm, there's no doubt about it. We wore ours for several weeks in December, and it even kept us warm in areas of Eastern Europe where the humid cold tends to bite through clothing.
Its down fill is generous and dense, and it extends from the hood to the hem, leaving no gaps in insulation and providing a noticeable increase in warmth. Interior baffles keep the insulation evenly distributed, and a near-seamless exterior prevents wind and moisture from entering through the shell. We also loved its gathered elastic wrist openings and easy-to-use drawstring waist that can be accessed through the front pockets, a game-changer when it's so cold you don't want to unzip your jacket just to pull the cinch cord tight. All of these extra features go a long way toward trapping body heat.
When it comes to weather-resistance, the Stormshadow excels in every way. In wind, rain, or snow, this jacket can battle the elements as well as any jacket in our lineup.
Waterproof zippers, an extended chin guard, an insulated neck baffle, a massive storm flap that snaps shut over the two-way zipper, and sealed seams give this jacket an edge when exposed to more extreme weather. We also loved its large insulated hood, which we could either cinch down around the face, or leave loose so we could fit a beanie underneath.
The thing we loved the most is this jacket's GORE-TEX ePE lined shell. When combined with the DWR finish, it takes weather resistance to a whole different level. It breathes well, blocks wind and rain, and keeps the down insulation dry.
Dislikes
After weeks of use, we found the Stormshadow to be comfortable and versatile, but we didn't absolutely love its overall fit. Its generous layer of down, although warm, is expansive and puffy. The jacket feels slightly oversized and bulky compared to others like the Patagonia Tres. It lacks the refinement we would want for a nice restaurant or a date night in the city. That said, it doesn't have bulky cargo style pockets, and will fly under the radar in most situation.
We also didn't love its cropped cut. Some of our testers would have preferred the hem to be a little longer for additional warmth.
What Other Winter Jackets Should You Consider?
The Marmot Oslo is very similar to the Stormshadow, for a much lower cost. It's GORE-TEX lined and has 700-fill down insulation, but it isn't quite as warm. The REI Co-op Stormhenge Down Hybrid Parka also offers a similar design at a reasonable price. We also loved the Patagonia Jackson Glacier, which is equally weatherproof and has a sleeker fitting style. It has a slightly more cropped cut that fits in well for casual wear around town but doesn't provide as much coverage.











