As one of our past top performers in cold weather climates, we had high hopes for this jacket. While it did perform well in very cold temperatures the Marmot DriClime jacket actually turned out to be our go-to jacket for casual excursions around town. We found ourselves constantly picking this jacket out of the lineup for a quick jaunt to the grocery store on colder mornings. While the insulation layer aided in cutting through the early morning chill it made running performance dependent on having very cold temperatures. It was too easy to overheat in this bulky running layer to make it a dedicated running jacket. Compared to the rest of the field the DriClime had a very narrow temperature window where it performed adequately. Unlike the rest of the field, this model had an extra layer built in, reducing our options for gradually stepping down the amount of warmth retention. Overall, the DriClime is best suited to be a warm, stylish, casual jacket for around town and reserved for running with on cold days below 35 degrees.
Marmot DriClime Windshirt Review
Compare prices at 2 resellers Pros: Warm, breathable, good wind resistance
Cons: Heavy, no reflective material, less water resistant
Compare to Similar Products
Marmot DriClime Windshirt
|Price||$49.98 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$126.98 at Amazon|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$94.98 at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$125.00 at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$89.29 at Amazon|
|Pros||Warm, breathable, good wind resistance||Lightweight, packs into pocket, superior weather resistance||Incredibly breathable, comfortable||Great ventilation, easy to layer over||Lightweight, good weather protection|
|Cons||Heavy, no reflective material, less water resistant||Pricey||Pullover design, weather resistance||No hem or hood drawcords, a bit pricey, not extremely wind resistant||Portability|
|Bottom Line||This is an insulated running layer best suited for cold dry climates.||An excellent jacket for all running occasions.||The Airshed is an incredibly breathable and comfortable running layer.||An interesting and unique combination of fabrics that performed about average.||The Better than Naked jacket took on some big changes from the last version; it has increased weather resistance but decreased breathability and venting.|
|Rating Categories||Marmot DriClime Windshirt||Arc'teryx Incendo Hoody||Patagonia Airshed||PhD Ultra Light Sport Hoody||Flight Better than Naked|
|Weather Resistance (20%)|
|Comfort And Mobility (20%)|
|Specs||Marmot DriClime...||Arc'teryx Incendo...||Patagonia Airshed||PhD Ultra Light...||Flight Better than...|
|OGL Weight (ounces)||8.4oz||4.7oz||3.6oz||4.9 oz||2.8oz|
|Number of pockets||1||1||1||1||1|
|Main Material||100% Polyester Ripstop DWR 1.5 oz/yd||Lumin 100% nylon 20D Ripstop fabric||20D 100% nylon mechanical stretch ripstop with a DWR finish||[shell] nylon with DWR finish, [inserts] 54% merino wool, 46% polyester||29 g/m² 100% nylon|
|Unique Features||Insulation Layer||Media Pocket||Packs into pocket with clip in loop||Packs into pocket with clip in loop, hole in pocket for headphone cords||Quiet nylon, no rustling sound|
|Vent Type||Mesh pit vents||Mesh panels under arm||Quarter zip||Mesh panels under arm, vents on sholders||On back, chest and side panels|
|Reflective material?||No||Logo and blazes||Yes||Yes, logo||Yes|
|Hood Available?||No||Hooded version available||No||Yes||No|
Our Analysis and Test Results
As last year's top pick for cold climates, we wanted to try and stretch the DriClime's legs and see what else it could do. By the end of our arduous testing period, we found out that, indeed, the Marmot is best suited for cold climates and not much else. If you're looking for jackets that are better suited for all-around climates check out the Arc'teryx Incendo, which allows layering underneath and give you a much wider range of climate control than does the DriClime Windshirt. If we were banished to a frozen wasteland and had to choose one jacket to shield us from the cold weather runs, this might be the one that we take with us.
In the previous OutdoorGearLab running jacket review, the Driclime Windshirt was tested in a much colder environment in the north east and it performed well. This go around, we tested this jacket in temperatures ranging from 35-45 degrees Fahrenheit and didn't have the same success as in the much colder temperatures.
When we hit the hills, even on very cold days, the DriClime was just too warm. We felt comfortable right out of the door even before we had warmed up, even on days in the mid 30's. Many of the jackets we tested allow for more layering than the Marmot, simply because the Marmot has a built-in insulation layer. As soon as we warmed up, the jacket couldn't handle the extra heat and moisture. Because of its extra, built-in layer, we found layering to be uncomfortable and make the jacket feel too restrictive.
Though the coldest we ran in this jacket was about 35 degrees, we feel that it might be best suited and come into its own in an even colder environment. As it stands, we found adequate warmth and protection from most of the single layer jackets in our review, especially when we could add a layer which was removable to dial into our comfort level. The DriClime does have underarm mesh for venting but we didn't find it to be adequate compared to how much insulation the jacket provided. The insulation layer doesn't mirror the vents and traps a tremendous amount of warmth.
In very cold temperatures, the mesh allows air to disperse excess body heat and regulate body temperature. The inner lining captures body heat remarkably well, so it's important to think carefully about how many layers you put on underneath the DriClime before you head out — wear too many layers and you'll be sweating so much it doesn't matter how breathable this piece is designed to be.
Bottom line: at sub-freezing temperatures, the mesh panels in the armpits helped tremendously, but when we tested this piece at temperatures of 45 degrees or more, we just started roasting. In these warmer temperatures with little or no wind, our body heat couldn't disperse quickly enough and we could feel moisture building up inside the piece. A five-mile run in mild 40-degree weather was tolerable, but we definitely wouldn't recommend the DriClime in temperatures above 40 degrees.
While we found the DriClime to be a more than adequate shield from the wind, its water resistance was poor. The material itself seemed very resistant to water but as water drained down the jacket, it would encounter seams that channeled water into the jacket.
As water permeated the jacket, it saturated the insulation layer inside the jacket. The two runs we went on one in light rain and the other in moderate rain resulted in incredibly uncomfortable results. The inner insulation layer becomes saturated and heavy and doesn't dry. Once the inner layer is wet, the only real solution was to put the jacket in the drier. The positive side of having the insulation layer was comfort around town and a feeling of superior wind protection. The wind that did permeate the jacket was less impactful because of the extra buffer created with the inner layer of polyester.
The DriClime's ability to repel water is based on a DWR chemical finish. We found that in a light rain this piece effectively repelled water; however, on a moderately rainy day, this layer quickly felt heavy with water, and close to wetting out. Although the inner liner will slow down the water from penetrating entirely through, the DriClime is not the first running jacket we'd reach for on a rainy day. For running on rainy days, read up on the Arc'teryx Incendo.
Comfort and Mobility
The inner layering of the DriClime offered a soft comfortable feel, especially when just hanging out or on casual outings. The fit of the jacket was comfortable overall and didn't feel restrictive when we had a technical t-shirt layer underneath. We did have some issues with the lining of the jacket bunching up when we put on the garment. It was nearly impossible to keep the lining from emerging from the wrist cuffs every time we put on the jacket demanding that we stuff it back inside the jacket. This was more of an annoyance than a comfort issue.
Aside from the little annoyances, there is plenty of room for any range of motion you could think of. The sleeve lengths are also great. Additionally, the material in the back is slightly longer than the front, reaching past the hips, which is a benefit if you're intending to use this piece for cycling.
At 8.4 ounces, the DriClime is one of the heavier models in this review. This is primarily due to the inner lining of moisture-wicking insulation. This added layer, though thick and heavy, is what makes this piece so well suited for cold weather running, so we think is a very acceptable trade-off.
As you can see from the picture, the Marmot is able to pack into its own pocket, but it is a tight fit. We felt that the zipper would have a significantly reduced life due to the strain it had to endure as we closed the stuff pouch.
Day and Night Visibility
The DriClime we tested this year was forest green and had no reflective material. We feel that visibility has always been and is increasingly important. Drivers today are more distracted than ever and thus our jackets need to be more visible than ever. It isn't discussed much but urban running can be quite dangerous if the proper precautions aren't taken. One important piece of that puzzle is a visible jacket.
Perhaps our biggest issue with the DriClime is that it completely ignores runner safety but omitting reflective accents and offering colors that equate to urban camouflage. If you decide that you want a DriClime, make sure you buy one of the high visibility colors that they do offer.
Thanks to the DriClime's insulated lining, you can use this piece in a wide variety of cold temperatures. We found that it performed well in below-freezing temperatures. Even in temperatures up to 50 degrees (depending on how much energy you are expending), the insulated lining wicked away moisture well enough to keep us feeling dry. This running jacket also holds up well against the wind; however, it is a little baggy, which is a concern if you're trail running on a path with seriously encroaching vegetation, since it can easily get caught on stray branches, thorns, etc. In the end, we found the Marmot to be a cold weather specialist and also a comfortable piece for simply hanging out around the grill on a cool evening.
At $95, the DriClime is a great value. Though it lacks some of the bells and whistles the other contenders have, it makes up for it in performance. And since you'll be able to use it for the better part of three full seasons (if you live in a cold climate), you'll get a lot bang for your buck, which is always a plus!
The Marmot DriClime Windshirt is a mid-weight running jacket designed for insulation and wind resistance. This warm piece also offers decent breathability, which means you'll require fewer layers for running in cold conditions. Additionally, the DriClime features a breast pocket for storage as well as elastic cuffs to help trap heat and stifle the wind.
— Brian Martin