Trango Antidote Review
Cons: Outer nylon not as heavy duty as other bags
Compare to Similar Products
|Price||$37 List||$59.95 at Amazon||$70 List||$47 List||$39.95 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Large tarp, plenty of space within the bag to pack extras, tarp window||Large removable tarp, comfortable backpack straps, useful compression straps||Large carrying capacity, comfortable backpack straps, padded back panel||Works as a cragging pack, padded shoulder straps are suprisingly comfortable, big tarp, nice zippered pocket||Easy to roll up rope, big tarp, compressible|
|Cons||Outer nylon not as heavy duty as other bags||Thin fabric, not as durable as other models||Awkward to pack with too little or too much gear, lacks adjustability||Packability||No smaller pockets, not as nice to carry for long distances|
|Bottom Line||The Antidote has some great standard features and is a decent mid-range model||Excellent rope bag for cragging and long approaches||The Crag is a well-padded bag with plenty of space for a full day of cragging||The Speedster does its job as a rope bag well, while also functioning as a basic small cragging pack||An improved version of an older version of a rope bag, with a much larger tarp|
|Rating Categories||Trango Antidote||DMM Classic||Mammut Crag||Metolius Speedster||Metolius Ropemaster HC|
|Carrying Comfort (25%)|
|Rope Protection (25%)|
|Ease Of Use (20%)|
|Specs||Trango Antidote||DMM Classic||Mammut Crag||Metolius Speedster||Metolius...|
|Tarp size (inches)||48" x 60"||43" x 51"||60" x 48"||52" x 58"||52" x 58"|
|# of shoulder straps||2||2||2||2||1|
|Metal or plastic buckles||Metal||Plastic||Plastic||None||Metal|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Trango Antidote packs much like any other standard burrito style rope bag on the market. Once the tarp is rolled and stuffed into the bag, an elastic cord is cinched around the opening of the bag, and then finally secured with two compression straps. The Antidote can be packed into a larger backpack if it doesn't have enough space for all of the gear that you'd like to bring. Although it might require some shoving, it packs relatively easily and two compression straps help to reduce extra volume.
The Antidote features two adjustable backpack style straps that can either be worn sling-style or as a backpack. It also features a single reinforced grab handle on one end of the bag for shorter moves. Thanks to the backpack style straps, the Trango Antidote is great for both long (25-30 minutes) and short (<5 minutes) distance approaches. For any kind of approach over 30 minutes, we preferred to pack the Antidote into a larger pack.
With a large rectangular 48" x 60" tarp, the Antidote had no problem keeping our rope out of the dirt. Although not as large as some of the other rope bags we tested, we did not find it to be detrimental to the overall usage of the bag. The design of the tarp is rectangular in nature, and the longest comparative to the width of all the bags we tested, which didn't impact the performance either positively or negatively.
Ease of Use
The Trango Antidote features an outer zippered pocket for your small items, metal buckles on its compression straps, and a tarp window to see what cord you have stored inside. The fabric used to construct the Antidote is not as burly as some of the competing models, but our testers found that the Antidote held up just fine to regular wear and tear. Although tarp windows may seem a bit odd, we found it extremely useful when looking through our gear closets to try and find a specific rope.
The Antidote is standard burrito style rope bag. It has some basic extra features such as a zippered outer pocket and tarp window, but nothing groundbreaking. At a comparable price to the other burrito-style options, it serves its purpose as a solid choice for anyone looking for a basic rope bag.
The Trango Antidote is a great choice for climbers seeking a solid, dependable rope bag. It has a large tarp that does a great job keeping the rope clean and an easy burrito style system to load the rope into. It has a grab handle on one end for short moves, and two padded shoulder straps for carrying over longer distances. A rope window and zippered outer pocket make for great, functional features.
— Graham Williams and Steven Tata