The Corkcicle Canteen Classic is a sleek and aesthetically appealing stainless steel bottle. It scored well in many of our best water bottle testing metrics but fell short in terms of ease of cleaning and versatility. It has an ergonomic shape that allows for easy carrying but lacks a handle. The small diameter of the mouth is great for hydrating with water, but not ideal for hot beverages. Though it scored well in our leak test, we are disappointed to report that the paint scratches off this bottle very readily.Editor's Note: This review was updated on March 25, 2022, with additional product comparisons and recommendations to help with your purchase decisions.
Corkcicle Canteen Classic Review
Cons: Hard to clean, scratches easily, lacks versatility
Compare to Similar Products
Corkcicle Canteen Classic
$34.50 at Amazon
$39.95 at REI
|Check Price at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
$15.95 at REI
|Pros||Unique shape, simple design, reasonable price tag||Well-insulated, great carrying handle, easy to clean, stainless-steel straw||Simple design, inexpensive, lightweight||Light, durable, resists flavors, simple design, wide mouth makes for easy filling||Affordable, insulates well, has interchangeable lids, easily portable|
|Cons||Hard to clean, scratches easily, lacks versatility||Heavy, expensive||Made of plastic, doesn't fit in all cupholders||Diameter too big for cup holders, wide mouth makes it difficult to drink from when walking or driving||Paint chipping after a few months of use, flip cap seemed to lack security|
|Bottom Line||A vacuum insulated bottle with a unique shape and sleek lid that's great for cold drinks||A thoughtfully designed bottle with an impressive feature set that works extremely well||This bottle is recommended because it is simple, lightweight, durable and has a solid feature set||A tried and tested classic, this model is versatile and reasonably priced||This is one of our favorite bottles because it's easy to use, just the right size, lightweight and inexpensive|
|Rating Categories||Corkcicle Canteen C...||Klean Kanteen TKWid...||CamelBak Eddy+ Trit...||Nalgene Wide-Mouth||Simple Modern Summit|
|Ease of Use (40%)|
|Specs||Corkcicle Canteen C...||Klean Kanteen TKWid...||CamelBak Eddy+ Trit...||Nalgene Wide-Mouth||Simple Modern Summit|
|Body Material||18/8 stainless steel||90% post-consumer recycled 18/8 stainless steel||BPA-free plastic||Eastman Tritan co-polyester||18/8 stainless steel|
|Empty Weight||18.4 oz||20.1 oz||7.1 oz||6.4 oz||15.7 oz|
|Volume||25 oz||32 oz||32 oz||34 oz||32 oz|
|Bottle Weight per Fluid oz Capacity||0.74 oz||0.63 oz||0.22 oz||0.19 oz||0.5 oz|
|Mouth Diameter||1.5 in||2.6 in||2.3 in||2.5 in||2.25 in|
|Base Diameter||3 in||3.6 in||3.8 in||3.25 in||3.5 in|
|Height||11.5 in||10.36 in||9.25 in||8.25 in||9 in|
|Free of Materials||BPA, BPS and Phthalate Free||BPA-free||BPA, BPS, BPF free||BPA, BPS and Phthalate Free||BPA-free|
|Cap/Lid Type||Screw cap||Screw cap, twist top||Screw cap, flip top||Loop-top screw cap||Screw Cap, flip top|
|Volume Options||9 oz, 16 oz, 25 oz, 60 oz||12 oz, 16 oz, 20 oz, 32 oz||14 oz, 25 oz, 32 oz||16 oz, 48 oz||14 oz, 18 oz, 22 oz, 32 oz, 40 oz, 64 oz, 84 oz|
Our Analysis and Test Results
This bottle has a unique aesthetic and a sleek, modern feel. The Corkcicle Canteen is great for cold beverages and impressed us with its simplicity. There are some shortcomings in terms of overall function, but the bottle is great for specific uses.
Ease of Use
Here, we assess the performance of each bottle in everyday life. The Corkcicle Canteen performed well in this metric overall. We had a few hangups with small design features, but overall appreciated the simplicity of its design. Since it doesn't have a carrying handle, the Corkcicle has an ergonomic shape that allows for comfortable in-hand carry. The lid is sleek and low-profile and the bottom of the bottle is rubberized to reduce slippage and improve grip. Despite its large size, the bottle fits into a car cupholder, thanks to its tapered design.
In terms of ease of drinking, this bottle works great for cold drinks, but don't be fooled by the vacuum-insulated design — drinking hot beverages from this narrow-mouthed bottle is tough to recommend. It's hard to control the flow of liquid to only get a small sip.
This shiny, metallic copper-colored bottle impresses at first glance, but we were immediately disappointed when we scraped some paint off just trying to remove the bottle from its packaging. Subsequently, the bottle continued to get scratched and dinged as we used it in our everyday lives. This performance limited its ranking in the lineup when it came to durability.
The Corkcicle Canteen passed the drop and leak tests with flying colors. The rubberized bottom helped reduce the impact of a fall on the stainless steel, and the Corkcicle walked away from our drop test with no dents. The lid also performed well when we tested it for leaks. Four layers of threads insert into the bottle to create an impressive seal and an easy-to-clean lid. This is one of our favorite lid designs of the water bottles we've tested to date.
The Corkcicle gets an average score in terms of its overall weight, especially compared to other stainless-steel bottles. Empty, this one weighs in at 18.4 ounces, which lands it in the middle when compared to its stainless-steel, insulated peers. Its slimmed-down feature set cuts back on weight, whereas other stainless bottles with more intricate designs end up weighing more. We like the tiny lid and sleek shape on this bottle — it's a great option for folks who yearn for simplicity.
Honestly, we were hesitant to put anything besides water in the Corkcicle Canteen. The narrow mouth was an immediate red flag in terms of lingering flavors since it is very hard to clean thoroughly. When we conducted our taste test by placing an electrolyte drink mix in the bottle and then washing it and checking for lingering flavors, we tasted faint flavors in Corkcicle, even after two washes. This bottle is challenging to clean, and its stainless-steel design imparts flavors, limiting its performance in this metric.
Should You Buy the Corkcicle Canteen Classic?
This is a sleek and interesting-looking stainless-steel bottle that works great for keeping cold drinks cold. Its ergonomic shape and simple, secure lid are our favorite features. The narrow mouth makes it hard to clean and challenging to drink hot drinks from. It's a fine daily-use bottle if you won't miss the carrying handle and plan on using it primarily for containing cold water.
What Other Water Bottles Should You Consider?
We think this bottle is better suited for urban life than hitting the trail. If you want a bottle for the outdoors, check out the Nalgene Wide-Mouth or for a lightweight insulated and trail-worthy bottle, the GSI Outdoors Microlite 720 Twist. For our all-time favorite bottle, the Yeti Rambler 26 takes the cake for its wide mouth, included Chug Cap, and top-notch durability.
— Jane Jackson
Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.
GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.Learn More