Western Mountaineering Summerlite Review
Cons: Tight fit, shallow hood, expensive
Manufacturer: Western Mountaineering
Compare to Similar Products
Western Mountaineering Summerlite
|Price||$410 List||$399.00 at Feathered Friends||$300 List||Check Price at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Warmth-to-weight ratio, excellent fabric, best bag with a hood, versatile||Highest scoring ultralight sleeping bag, best features, and most versatile||Very affordable, highly customizable, versatile, lots of features||Truly ultralight, packs down well, good zipper||Very inexpensive, versatile, good feature set|
|Cons||Tight fit, shallow hood, expensive||Not as warm as others (in the version we tested), neck draw cords loosen over time||Long wait for product to be custom made and shipped, foot box draw cord still leaves a little hole, lots of buttons and straps||Not very warm, tight around shoulders||Not as warm as similar quilts, doesn't seal at the bottom very well|
|Bottom Line||A stellar choice for those looking for a warm, lightweight, fully hooded mummy||The highest scorer because of its versatile design that allows it to be a fully opened blanket or a fully zipped hoodless mummy||Offers the versatility of sleeping under it as a blanket or fully wrapped up, with a huge range of customizable options||The Spark is a good fit for warm summer trips or truly ultralight applications. Bikepackers will especially love its tiny packed size||A quilt with good features at an unbeatable price|
|Rating Categories||Summerlite||Flicker 40 UL||Revelation 20||Sea to Summit Spark...||Hammock Gear Burrow...|
|Specs||Summerlite||Flicker 40 UL||Revelation 20||Sea to Summit Spark...||Hammock Gear Burrow...|
|Style||Hooded mummy||Center zip mummy bag or unzipper to be quilt||Quilt||Hooded mummy||Quilt|
|Manufacturer Stated Temperature Rating||32F||40F||20F||40F||20F|
|Measured weight, bag only (ounces)||19 oz||19.1 oz||20.9 oz||12.4 oz||25.0 oz|
|Claimed weight from manufacturer (ounces)||19 oz||20 oz||20.19 oz||12 oz||22.19 oz|
|Stuff Sack Weight (ounces)||1 oz||0.8 oz||0.6 oz||1 oz||0.6 oz|
|Stuffed Size||6" x 12"||7" x 10"||7" x 12"||4" x 7"||6" x 10"|
|Fill Weight||10 oz||8.4 oz||13 oz||6.3 oz||13.18 oz|
|Fill Power||850+ goose down||950+ goose down||850 Downtek||850+ goose down||800 fill duck down|
|Construction||Continuous baffle||Continuous baffles||U shaped baffled quilt||Sewn through baffles||Box baffle consruction|
|Shell Material||100% nylon ripstop||Pertex Endurance UL||10D nylon fabric||70D nylon||20D nylon taffeta|
|Shoulder Girth (inches)||59"||62"||55"||59"||55"|
|Hip Girth (inches)||51"||48"||55"||51"||50"|
|Foot Girth (inches)||38"||39"||55"||35"||45"|
|Zipper Length||Full length||Full length center zip||1/3 length at bottom||1/2 length||1/3 length at bottom|
|Sizes||5'6", 6', and 6'6"||Regular, long, and wide||Short/regular, regular/regular, regular/wide/ long/wide||Regular, long||Short, standard, long, wide-short, wide-standard, wide-long|
|Temp Options (degrees Fahrenheit)||32F||20, 30, 40F||10, 20, 30, 40F||5, 18, 28, 40F||0, 10, 20, 30, 40F|
Our Analysis and Test Results
We felt it was warmer than most of the other bags rated similarly, and could probably push it into the 20°F range if you are feeling lucky. Although you feel the ultralight shape a bit during the night, we think that the warmth-to-weight ratio is excellent, and enough to deserve the Editors' Choice for a mummy-style sleeping bag.
On a spring climbing trip to the Utah Hills, when nights were around freezing, the Summerlite kept our lead tester warm and toasty without supplementing much other clothing, something other ultralight bags and quilts don't often provide. The full zip and hood allow the full burrito option the way any traditional mummy bag would, which will always be at least slightly warmer than a quilt, especially for those who tend to toss and turn at night. Except on the coldest, windiest nights in this bag, we had to keep it at least slightly unzipped to vent the heat. Although Western Mountaineering doesn't do EN ratings, we think that the 32-degree Fahrenheit rating is more accurate than some of the other bags in the review.
Part of the reason the Summerlite is so warm is because of the continuous baffles. Unlike older sleeping bag designs, there's an unbroken four-inch layer of down separating the two nylon shell fabrics. This eliminates cold spots and allows the ten ounces of down to work together, minimizing the need for more fill. The tighter cut also eliminates dead air space in the bag and allows the Summerlite to do more with the ten ounces of 850+ down fill.
For a full zip, hooded mummy bag, the Summerlite does pretty well in this department. It's not the absolute lightest mummy we've reviewed, but it is much warmer than similarly rated bags we've tried, and we think that the extra warmth is worth it for the minimal weight difference.
The weight of the down fill in the Summerlite is 10 ounces, which is just one ounce over half the weight of the entire sleeping bag. The more fill weight there is out of the entire measured weight, generally the warmer the bag. In this case, the fill weight to fabric weight ratio is fairly high, which we see as a good thing, and shows us why this bag is so darn warm.
In the ultralight sleeping bag game, there are three main categories: warmth, weight, and comfort. You get typically two of those categories at the cost of the third. For the Summerlite, Western Mountaineering decided to sacrifice a roomy fit to achieve something with a high warmth to weight ratio, as opposed to removing zippers and hoods like some other bags. The space around the shoulders and head was roomy enough for our 5'8" tester, but the footbox felt especially tight up to the knees. For those, like our main tester, who tend to spread out and roll a lot while sleeping, this wasn't as comfortable. The Summerlite might not be an issue for more still sleepers, but it is a consideration if you plan on keeping things like water bottles or spare clothing in your bag at night.
We do like the fabric, and there isn't anything that was poorly placed, like the drawcords or velcro. This sleeping bag feels the way sleeping bags should; like a big, warm down hug. Although the hood wasn't quite as deep as we liked, the oval shape allowed for side sleepers to roll and not end up trying to breathe through nylon all night.
Like any full zip mummy, the Summerlite is really versatile. You can unzip it when it is hot, or burrow down into it when the temps drop. Also, like most sleeping bags these days, the zipper is also two-way, which allows some selective venting at the feet, or even wearing it around camp with your feet sticking out as the ultimate insulating layer (yes, some super ultralight backpackers actually do this).
The warmth allows this bag to be used early spring or late autumn and could work for an entire thru-hike such as the PCT, especially if you incorporate an appropriate clothing system into the mix. Because it vents so well, our testers are happy to use this bag on warm summer nights as well.
The features of this Western Mountaineering bag are pretty well thought out. We like the full-length, burly #5 YKK zipper, and the small strip of stiffer fabric next to it to avoid being sucked into the teeth, which was nice when we were adjusting it in the middle of the night. We like the offset drawcord of the hood that didn't get in the way, but we did think that the hood was a bit shallow, and didn't allow for as much coverage as some hoods.
The stuff sack is adequate, but it isn't a compression sack or dry bag, which are excellent additions other bags provide. However, we acknowledge that many thru-hikers will leave the included sack, whether it's a stuff or compression type, at home to save weight, preferring to stuff an unwrapped sleeping bag into their packs. Overall, with some small design tweaks, this could have scored a bit higher.
The Summerlite isn't the most expensive bag in our roundup, but it's pretty close. Still, you're paying for quality, and the Summerlite delivers. We like this bag, and other mummy bags in the review are almost as expensive, but if you're looking to save money, a quilt might be a better option. This bag is made of quality materials and should hold up for a long time.
The Western Mountaineering Summerlite does many things well. It keeps you really warm, packs down fairly well, and doesn't add too much to your base weight. To keep the warmth and weight down, the cut is fairly slim, which might impact larger folks or restless sleepers. Still, the Summerlite performed at the top echelon of bags we tested, and if you're looking for a traditional sleeping bag for an ultralight setup, we think the Summerlite is a great option, enough to win the Editors' Choice Award.
— Ethan Newman