Ultralight Adventure Equipment Circuit Review
Cons: Mesh attracts dirt and pine needles, somewhat bulky
Manufacturer: Ultralight Adventure Equipment
Compare to Similar Products
Ultralight Adventure Equipment Circuit
|Price||$255 List||$270 List||$260 List||$225 List||$145 List|
|Pros||Durable, large external pocket, roll-top closure, adjustable, compatible with bear can||Durable, comfortable, well-designed pockets, carries light and heavy loads well||Lightweight, carries light and medium loads well, adaptable, perfect feature set, more durable than most||Carries both light and heavier loads in comfort, large side pockets, very durable construction||Simple design, inexpensive, durable|
|Cons||Mesh attracts dirt and pine needles, somewhat bulky||Large capacity makes it less versatile||A little small for a bear canister||Relatively heavy, delicate carbon frame rods||Foam pad falls out easily, shoulder straps lack support|
|Bottom Line||This lightweight, comfortable pack has a simple, yet thoughtful design, and is a great pack for heavy loads or winter trips||As an all around great pack, it can carry large and light loads with ease, has plenty of external storage options, and is super comfortable||One of our top picks and scored highly in all metrics, it's comfortable, versatile, and has just enough features||This pack is a popular ultralight pack for good reason; it has plenty of outside storage, is made of durable fabrics, and carries both 15 and 30 pound loads with ease||Combines simplicity, a reasonable price tag, and a good feature set|
|Rating Categories||Circuit||Gossamer Gear Mariposa||Gossamer Gear Gorilla||Ultralight Adventure Equipme...||Ultralight Adventure Equipme...|
|Weight To Volume Ratio (35%)|
|Comfort To Carry (25%)|
|Specs||Circuit||Gossamer Gear...||Gossamer Gear...||Ultralight...||Ultralight...|
|Measured Weight||40 oz||30.5 oz||31.5 oz||31.4 oz||24 oz|
|Stripped Weight||37.5 oz||30.5 oz||27.5 oz||20.4 oz||23 oz|
|Claimed Volume||68 L||60 L||40 L||63 L||54 L|
|Measured Main Pack Volume||46 L||48 L||38 L||41 L||45 L|
|Measured Volume Total (minus hip belt and shoulder strap pockets)||64 L||64 L||53 L||48 L||53 L|
|Measured Volume Stripped (minus hip belt, shoulder pockets, and removable lids)||64 L||59 L||48 L||48 L||53 L|
|Average Weight-to-Volume Ratio (grams/Liter)||17.5 g/L||14 g/L||13.5 g/L||14.5 g/L||12.8 g/L|
|Carrying Comfort 15 pounds||Good||Great||Great||Great||Great|
|Carrying Comfort 30 pounds||Great||Great||Great||Great||Poor|
|Frame Type||Simple frame- 1.2 oz carbon fiber/delrin active suspension frame loop||Foam pad/ removable stay||Foam pad/removable stay||Simple Frame - 1.2 oz carbon fiber / Delrin active suspension hoop||Removable foam pad|
|Fabric||ULA 210 Robic nylon||70 & 100 denier Robic nylon||70 & 100 denier robic nylon||ULA 210 Robic nylon||210 Robic nylon, 400d Robic Bottom Panel|
|Main Pack Pockets||3||4||3||3||3|
|Hip Belt Pockets||2||2||2||Two||2|
|Single Hip Belt Pocket Capacity||2||4||4 cliff bars||8 Clif Bars||2 cliff bars|
|Shoulder Strap Pockets||No||No||No||No||No|
|Whistle on Sternum Strap||No||No||Yes||No||No|
|Internal Hydration Sleeve||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Bag Sizes/Torso Lengths Available||S, M, L, XL||S, M, L||S, M, L||S, M, L, XL||S, M, L, XL|
|Mix and Match Hip Belt Sizes||XS, S, M, L, XL||S, M, L||S, M, L||S, M, L, XL||S, M, L, XL|
|Can Easily Strip Off Frame and Hip Belt||Yes||Good||Good||Yes||No|
|BearVault BV500 Compatibility||Yes||Good||Ok||Just OK||Ok|
|Lid (aka Brain)||No||No||Yes||No||No|
Our Analysis and Test Results
With high scores in weight to volume, comfort, and durability, the ULA Circuit is a great all-around performer. The Circuit is a great all-around pack that can be used in a variety of situations, from ultralight backpacking to wintertime trips into the backcountry.
ULA packs can be difficult to find at major retailers, and we've found it's best to order directly from the small manufacturer. Do note that ULA packs can be found in some small backpacking stores, such as Sage to Summit in Bishop, CA, or the Georgia-based Mountain Crossings on the Appalachian Trail.
Get it online at: ULA-Equipment.com.
Weight to Volume
The ULA Circuit receives an average score in this metric for a few reasons. The first being that the difference between its total weight and stripped weight is minimal, making the average weight of the pack higher than packs that can be stripped down quite a bit. Though the Circuit gets a lower score in the weight to volume metric, it is still a pack that feels light because of its simple design.
Total weight with all modular components = 2 lbs 8 oz
Pack striped of components =2 lbs 5.5 oz
Lid = NA
The Circuit weighs 40 ounces total and can carry up to 64 liters. For a large capacity pack, we were impressed by the Circuit's ability to feel lightweight, without sacrificing comfort.
Total Volume = 64 L
Main Bag = 46 L
Pockets = 15 L
Lid = NA
When it comes to comfort, the ULA Circuit performs very well in our field tests. Our qualitative impressions of the pack from multiple days in the Yosemite backcountry lines up with ULA's claims that this pack is designed with comfort in mind. The pack has a 1.2 ounce carbon fiber and Delrin suspension hoop in conjunction with a solid internal foam frame and a single aluminum stay. This frame design gives good back support, load control, and rigidity without sacrificing weight or limiting the range of movement with the pack on.
The straps and waist belt are also designed with comfort in mind. The shoulder straps didn't rub uncomfortably and seemed to be equally comfortable on male and female hikers. The waist belt is comfortable and widely adjustable as well. This pack is up there with our award winners as a pack that earned a "great" in our comfort ratings.
In general, the ULA Circuit has most everything we wanted in an ultralight backpacking pack, with a few small flaws. We found that the two side pockets were constructed with an opening that is set at a steep angle, which made for wasted space and excess fabric. The side pockets were only useful for storing water bottles, which works great, but lacks the versatility of other packs that have many different sized pockets. The Circuit does have a large mesh pocket common in ultralight pack design, which was great for drying out wet items throughout the day.
The roll-top closure system was a feature that took some getting used to, but in the end, we liked the simplicity of the system and the flexibility it provided.
Since it is a large pack, the Circuit scored lower in this metric. The pack performs optimally when loaded with 15 to 25 pounds. It does work with more weight, but we found it began to feel more uncomfortable on the shoulder straps. The roll-top closure is a nice feature since you can synch down the pack when carrying less volume, while still having the capability to fill the pack to its full capacity.
The ULA Circuit received high scores in durability, mostly due to the fabrics used in its construction. After three months of use and abuse on the trail, we found no signs of wear and tear on the pack. The ULA 210 Robic fabric used for the main body of the pack is incredibly abrasion resistant, as is the Robic fabric used for the side pockets. ULA also received lots of feedback on the large mesh pocket and have recently changed the fabric to a tighter-knit, less see-through mesh that is much more durable.
The ULA Circuit falls in the middle of the road regarding price. Since ULA is a small, Utah based company, you know you are getting a good product when you buy from them. The owners of the company are backpacking enthusiasts and are receptive to input and feedback from customers. Also, they use incredibly durable fabrics in their construction, so you can be assured the Circuit will last a number of years.
The ULA Circuit scored highly in almost all metric categories and performed great on the ground day after day. In terms of weight to volume, the pack is almost unmatched. Comfort-wise, the ULA is up there with the two Gossamer Gear packs as the most comfortable ultralight packs we tested. The only negative feedback we got was in a few of the design features, mainly the size and positioning of the pockets. The pack is versatile; in fact, it seems that its best application would be as a one-pack- quiver, as it is a pack that can perform in a variety of situations.
— Jane Jackson