Gossamer Gear Murmur Review
Cons: Designed for a specific use, lacks versatility, lacks durability
Manufacturer: Gossamer Gear
Compare to Similar Products
Gossamer Gear Murmur
|Price||$160 List||$145 List||$139.95 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$199.95 at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
|Pros||Very lightweight, relatively inexpensive, thoughtful design||Simple design, inexpensive, durable||Very light, large volume, versatile compression system||Great for medium loads, inexpensive, thoughtful set of features, external storage and lashing options||Lightweight, useful pockets, comfortable for medium-sized loads|
|Cons||Designed for a specific use, lacks versatility, lacks durability||Foam pad falls out easily, shoulder straps lack support||No frame, poor comfort for medium loads||Heavy, less durable than others||Lacks durability of other models, lacks versatility because of small capacity|
|Bottom Line||Designed for the lightest travelers on the trail, with minimal features and lightweight materials||A lightweight, simplified version of our favorite pack from this same company, making a durable, well-designed option||For the ultimate lightweight pack, this pack steals the show with its entirely frameless design and streamlined set of features||This incredible pack has tons of features, carries medium-sized loads well, and is comfortable to boot||This small capacity, lightweight pack is great for mega lightweight overnight excursions|
|Rating Categories||Gossamer Gear Murmur||Adventure Equipment...||Granite Gear Virga 2||Osprey Exos 48||Gossamer Gear Kumo 36|
|Weight To Volume Ratio (35%)|
|Comfort To Carry (25%)|
|Specs||Gossamer Gear Murmur||Adventure Equipment...||Granite Gear Virga 2||Osprey Exos 48||Gossamer Gear Kumo 36|
|Measured Weight||12.5 oz||24 oz||18.5 oz||37.6 oz||21 oz|
|Stripped Weight||9 oz||23 oz||18.5 oz||33.9 oz||15.2 oz|
|Claimed Volume||36 L||54 L||50-58 L||48 L||36 L|
|Measured Main Pack Volume||29L||45 L||41 L||40 L||28 L|
|Measured Volume Total (minus hip belt and shoulder strap pockets)||40L||53 L||49 L||59 L||38 L|
|Measured Volume Stripped (minus hip belt, shoulder pockets, and removable lids)||40L||53 L||49 L||53 L||38 L|
|Average Weight-to-Volume Ratio (grams/Liter)||7.6 g/L||12.8 g/L||10 g/L||18.9 g/L||13.5 g/L|
|Carrying Comfort 15 pounds||Great||Great||Good||Good||Great|
|Carrying Comfort 30 pounds||Poor||Poor||Poor||Great||Poor|
|Frame Type||Removable foam pad||Removable foam pad||None (foam pad)||Tensioned Frame - AirSpeed SL Suspension||Foam pad|
|Fabric||30 & 70D rombic nylon||210 Robic nylon, 400d Robic Bottom Panel||Cordura||100D high tenacity nylon, 100D high tenacity ripstop nylon||100D Robic double diamond rip stop|
|Main Pack Pockets||3||3||3||3||3|
|Hip Belt Pockets||2||2||None||None||2|
|Single Hip Belt Pocket Capacity||2 cliff bars||2 cliff bars||N/a||N/a||1 clif bar|
|Shoulder Strap Pockets||No||No||No||No||2|
|Whistle on Sternum Strap||Yes||No||None||Yes||Yes|
|Internal Hydration Sleeve||No||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Bag Sizes/Torso Lengths Available||One Size||S, M, L, XL||Long, short, regular||S, M, L||One size|
|Mix and Match Hip Belt Sizes||No||S, M, L, XL||No||No||No|
|Can Easily Strip Off Frame and Hip Belt||Yes||No||No||No||Yes|
|BearVault BV500 Compatibility||No||Ok||Ok||Just OK||No|
|Lid (aka Brain)||No||No||No||Yes, Removable||No|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Gossamer Gear Murmur is the lightest pack in this review. It is also one of the smallest we've reviewed.
This highly specific, technical pack is designed for the experienced ultralight backpacker. The quote that we come across time and time again among ultralight companies is you are unsure if this pack is for you, then it probably isn't. This applies to the Murmur as well, as the pack requires a meager base weight, which typically can only be achieved after plenty of experience and trail time to refine one's kit.
It is in this category that the Murmur shines. The pack is by far the lightest we have reviewed, weighing in at 12.5 ounces or a mere 9 ounces stripped.
The main body of the Murmur has about a 30-liter capacity. This makes it a small pack overall, and only useful for expert backpackers when used as a multi-day backpacking pack. There are three external storage pockets on the outside made of stretchy mesh material, which are great for layers and snacks that you may want access to throughout the day. Other packs have this design while providing more storage and support.
Load Carrying Comfort
The Murmur is designed in a similar style to the Mariposa. Both Gossamer Gear packs have a foam back pad that is removable as well as very lightly padded shoulder straps. The Murmur also has a removable, lightly padded waist belt that provides a bit of extra support. The removable foam pad is the best part of this suspension system; we found it easy to take off as a seat to avoid sitting on the pack itself. It's not comfortable when carrying loads over 20 pounds, which is fairly obvious when looking at the minimalist suspension system and lightweight materials used in its construction.
When it comes to features, the Murmur is a very simple pack. It has a waist belt, with pockets, a sternum strap, and as we mentioned above, a foam back pad to provide some structure. As far as storage goes, the Murmur follows the same template as many packs in this review with its three external storage pockets. Unlike the majority of packs we have reviewed, the Murmur does not come with side compression straps, though these can be added later.
The water bottle holders on the sides are tall and narrow, a shape we preferred since it easily held our bottles in place. This pack lacks a lid and instead has a roll-top closure system. The top is reinforced with plastic to make it stiffer and thus easier to roll, which is a nice feature. Though opening and closing a roll-top pack can be a pain, we preferred this seal to a drawstring closure that some of the packs we've reviewed tote.
Some features that can be removed to reduce the weight of this pack even more (the foam back panel and the waist belt). This makes the pack extremely light and reduces the minimal support even more. That said, this makes the Murmur a great daypack for short hikes from a base camp. The Murmur scored low in this metric because its use is so specific; it's not designed for base weights over 10 pounds, which requires specific, compressible ultralight gear.
The Murmur falls short in this metric, as the material is very lightweight and easily damaged by wear and tear on the trail. The pack is made up of a combination of 30 and 70 denier Robic nylon and the pockets are made of an ultralight micro-mesh material. The Murmur should be treated lightly since it is designed with weight efficiency, as opposed to durability in mind.
The Murmur is relatively inexpensive at first glance. Compared to larger-capacity options from other ultralight-specific brands, the Murmur comes at a fair price. That said, the pack is so specific and small (and not particularly designed with longevity in mind), that it ends up being a fairly expensive product. If you are certain that this pack is for you, the price is manageable, but otherwise, could seem like a lot of money for a specific piece of gear.
The Gossamer Gear Murmur is a niche pack designed for expert ultralighters willing to cut down their base weight to the bare minimum. The pack is made of very light nylon and mesh and has a fairly simple design. The main body has a capacity of only 30 liters, making it one of the smallest packs we have tested in this review. If you are looking for a very lightweight, small capacity pack, then this is a good option. But, if you are not sure, there are many other options out there that are more versatile and designed with a wider range of uses in mind.
— Jane Jackson