Sea to Summit Comfort Plus SI - Women's Review
Compare prices at 3 resellers Pros: Comfortable, durable
Cons: Heavy, bulky, expensive
Manufacturer: Sea to Summit
Compare to Similar Products
Sea to Summit Comfort Plus SI - Women's
|Price||Check Price at REI|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$141.89 at Amazon|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$188.95 at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$148.95 at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
$69.89 at REI
|Pros||Comfortable, durable||Very light, super compact, comfortable, versatile, warmer than normal XLite||Comfortable, quiet, lightweight||Lightweight, small packed size, included pump sack||Comfortable, good valve system, warm|
|Cons||Heavy, bulky, expensive||Noisy, expensive, delicate materials||Expensive, heavier than the NeoAir XLite||Not as comfortable as Ether Light and same weight, thin||Heavy and bulky|
|Bottom Line||This comfortable car camping mat is the heaviest and bulkiest of the bunch||This super light and compact sleeping pad is a great choice for someone looking to go fast, light, and warm||A versatile sleeping pad that is incredibly comfortable||This lightweight sleeping pad is relatively comfortable, but a Jack-of-all-trades and master-of-none||A comfortable, warm sleeping pad with unique "rails" that will cradle you when you sleep|
|Rating Categories||Sea to Summit Comfo...||Therm-a-Rest NeoAir...||Sea to Summit Ether...||Sea to Summit Ultra...||REI Co-op AirRail Plus|
|Packed Size (15%)|
|Specs||Sea to Summit Comfo...||Therm-a-Rest NeoAir...||Sea to Summit Ether...||Sea to Summit Ultra...||REI Co-op AirRail Plus|
|Measured Weight||34.4 oz||12 oz||15 oz||14.6||25 oz|
|ASTM R Value||5.1||5.4||3.5||3.5||3.7|
|Thickness||3 in||2.5 in||4 in||2 in||1.5 in|
|Width||21 in||20 in||21.5 in||21.5 in||23 in|
|Packed Size||7.25 x 10.75 in||9 in x 4.1 in||11 x 4.5 in||4 x 9 in||9.84 x 5.51 in|
|Tested Length||67 in||66 in||66 in||72 in||66 in|
|Bottom Material||30D knitted polyester||30D rip HT Nylon||40D nylon||40D nylon||75D polyester|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Women's Comfort Plus Self-Inflating Sleeping Mat, not to be confused with the Sea To Summit Comfort Plus Insulated Short, is comfortable, but also heavy and bulky. We like its multi-function valve and stuff sack pump system, which allow for easy inflation and immediate deflation when it's time to pack up.
Along with the REI Air Rail Plus, the Comfort Plus has the highest R-Value and is the warmest bag in this women's review. It has thick foam insulation in it that will shield you from the cold ground. For this reason, you could stretch this mat into 4 season camping territory.
This pad is very comfortable, thanks to the thoughtfulness that Sea to Summit has put into the creation and shape of their women's pads. They are an oval shape, whereas the men's products are more of a triangle, tapered shape. This means that the Comfort Plus is wider at the hips than the shoulders which work really well with most women's dimensions. For this reason and the fact that this pad is thick and cushy, we think it's pretty darn comfy. We like the squishy stretchy feel of its upper knitted polyester material; it feels more yielding than other thick pads like the Big Agnes Q Core SLX that are just plastic and air, with no padding.
Because of the amount of foam in this mat, even if it sprung a leak, it would still insulate you from the ground more than a less-durable pad with no foam. The materials seem relatively durable and abrasion resistant, although 30 Denier material is not as durable as the Air Rail's 75D.
Here's where things start going downhill in the metrics for the Comfort Plus, although this is not meant to be an ultralight pad in the first place. Weighing in at a hefty 34.4 ounces, it's the heaviest mat in this review. We would not carry this with us over long distances; instead, we'd let our vehicle do the heavy lifting on car-camping trips.
Due to the huge amount of foam that the Comfort Plus contains, it's quite bulky. It's also challenging to get back into its stuff sack. There is meant to be a feature where you can twist a piece of the valve to stop the self-inflating part of the pad while you roll it up, but we couldn't figure it out and couldn't find instructions online. It is one of the bulkiest pads in this review.
The Comfort Plus is a great choice for a car camping pad. It is comfortable and warm for chilly nights in the campground, but heavy and bulky so we would not take it backpacking.
Retailing for $140 we do not think that the Comfort Plus Self-Inflating Sleeping Mat is an incredible value for a car-camping sleeping pad. Other similar products are much cheaper like the Air Rail and the Therm-a-Rest Trail Lite Women's, which are also lighter and more packable for short backpacking trips.
We applaud Sea to Summit for their new thoughtful women's products, but we think that the Comfort Plus is overpriced for what it is (a comfortable and warm car camping pad). We would reach for the less-expensive models with comparable comfort and warmth over the Comfort Plus.
— Jessica Haist
Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.
GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.Learn More