Northbound Train LED Review
Compare to Similar Products
Northbound Train LED
|Price||$45 List||$44.96 at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$21.97 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$29 List||$18.71 at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
|Pros||Simple design and usage||Excellent trail finding and close proximity beam, waterproof, above average battery life||Excellent spot light capability, wide evenly lit flood beam, above average in most ways||Good performance for the price, 94 meter beam throw, easy to use||Super easy to use, inexpensive, solid performance, compact, and reliable|
|Cons||No switch lock, short beam throw||More expensive, heavier than average, claimed battery life is very misleading||Below average battery life, claimed battery life is wildly misleading, single button hard to use, lame waterproofing||Average in most ways||Good but not great spot beam for trail finding, slightly below average flood beam optics|
|Bottom Line||At a similar price-point to higher scoring headlamps, the Northbound Train LED is more appealing for household use than as an outdoor tool||A durable light that will last for years with a bright high-quality beam, slightly higher in cost and weight||A quality, durable, and bright light that hits the sweet spot for most people's needs, despite dubious marketing claims||The Yalumi is a good light, at a good price, that provides basic functionality||For $20, the Tikkina offers impressive performance at a great price, that will meet most people's needs|
|Rating Categories||Northbound Train LED||Black Diamond Storm||Black Diamond Spot||Yalumi LED 140-Lumen||Petzl Tikkina|
|Trail Finding (35%)|
|Close Proximity (20%)|
|Battery Life (15%)|
|Ease of Use (15%)|
|Specs||Northbound Train LED||Black Diamond Storm||Black Diamond Spot||Yalumi LED 140-Lumen||Petzl Tikkina|
|Measured Beam Distance||34 m||91 m||94 m||94 m||62 m|
|Claimed Distance||30 m||85 m||80 m||90 m||55 m|
|Measured High Mode Run-time (ANSI)||13.8 hrs||5 hrs||2.9 hrs||4.3 hrs||3.5 hrs|
|Claimed High Mode Run-time||40 hrs||30 hrs||Not specified||60 hrs|
|Measured Low Mode Run-time||107 hrs||42 hrs||9.7 hrs||47 hrs||223 hrs|
|Claimed Low Mode Run-time||120 hrs||175 hrs||100 hrs||220 hrs|
|Measured Weight||3.1 oz, 87 g||4 oz, 112 g||3.1 oz, 89 g||2.7 oz, 77 g||2.9 oz, 83 g|
|Battery Type||3 AAA||4 AAA||3 AAA||3 AAA||3 AAA|
|Water Resistance||IPX4 splash proof||IP67 waterproof to one meter and dustproof||Splash proof (dubious IPX8 claim)||IPX4 splash proof||IPX4 splash proof|
|Manuf Claimed Lumens||90 lumens||350 lumens||300 lumens||140 lumens||150 lumens|
|Red Light||yes||yes, red/green/blue night-vision modes||yes||yes||no|
|On Switch Lock||no||yes||yes||no||no|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Northbound Train LED light is a product that appears to be made and packaged in the same facility or facilities as some of the best performing products in our test. It is also priced like a better performing product. However, our experience with the Northbound Train indicated substandard performance.
As you can see in the beam comparison below the Northbound Train light isn't even in the same league as the Editors' Choice winning Coast HL7. For fewer dollars on the Coast, you get what looks and feels like truly high-end optics and beam throw. We are somewhat perplexed by the Northbound's performance and price, to be honest.
With a relatively clean lens arrangement and wide spreading beam, the close proximity lighting of the Northbound Train LED is its most competitive attribute. With a score of seven out of ten, the LED light sits solidly average among our tested products. As compared, however, to the beam of something like the Nitecore HC50, the beam is clearly rough and spotty.
Battery life on the Northbound LED as deduced from just our coffin test wasn't actually all that poor. Burning 4.2 hours on high mode is a respectable score, falls just above the middle of our test roster, and is pretty close to the similarly priced but otherwise much higher scoring Black Diamond Spot. As compared, however, to our Editors' Choice Black Diamond ReVolt, the Northbound's light-coffin score is clearly less. Additionally, overall battery life in actual usage is dependent on other variables. Lights with the brightest bulbs can be used in much lower modes, while our testing was only in high beam mode. We bumped the Northbound's battery life score down because of its lesser beam. You'll use the high-beam mode a greater percentage of the time, burning the batteries faster. Also, we bumped the score down again because the Northbound lacks a locking switch.
Throwing a beam just 27 meters puts the Northbound only one spot away from the bottom of our test roster. Only the Black Diamond Gizmo casts light less far. Even the diminutive Top Pick winner Petzl e+LITE pushes usable light 30m. In a refreshing move, Northbound does indeed report their brightness pretty accurately. They claim the LED light shines 30m.
The LED light from Northbound Train weighs 94 grams. In that category, it sits solidly in the middle of our test. The much higher scoring Black Diamond Cosmo is the same weight.
Ease of Use
The switch on this headlamp is easy to use and clicks through just a couple brightness modes. We had no complaints about the usability of the Northbound lamp.
This is only an acceptable light for casual camping or for keeping in your car. Any one of our Best Buy lights (this year's winner, the Petzl Tikkina, or the ultra inexpensive Energizer 3 LED) would be a better choice, however, in this application.
Given the low performance and narrow distribution of the Northbound light, one is likely to find it on sale. If the sale price approaches or drops below that of the aforementioned best buy lights, it could be considered as a value option.
While we generally choose lights to test that offer the promise of above average performance, the Northbound is an outlier. It should be telling that we are unlikely to choose to include this particular product, unless it is changed in design, in future OutdoorGearLab reviews.
Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.
GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.Learn More