REI Co-op Camp Review
Cons: Extremely simple design/use, not particularly warm
Manufacturer: REI Co-op
Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
 This Product
REI Co-op Camp | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Awards |  |  |  | ||
| Price | $80 List Check Price at REI | Check Price at REI Compare at 3 sellers | $51.73 at REI Compare at 2 sellers | $40.13 at Amazon | $25 List |
Overall Score  |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Pros | Good coverage dimensions, impressively light weight for synthetic, decent weather-resistance, sheds most debris | Softer underbelly, weather-resistant, great features, feels warm, easy to clean | Quite warm and puffy, fairly weather-resistant, comfortable, reasonably affordable | Solid insulation, light and packable, compression stuff sack, large size, affordable | Very soft underside, comfortable, simple stuff sack, reasonable size/weight, inexpensive |
| Cons | Extremely simple design/use, not particularly warm | A bit large and bulky | Very large and bulky, a bit slick, not home washable | No cross-stitching, not weatherproof | On the small side, not super warm, not particularly technical |
| Bottom Line | A "life-proof" option for casual outdoor use | Though a bit large, this blanket is seriously cozy and offers solid comfort, warmth, and protection | A warm, cozy blanket for cold days, though a bit too bulky for serious travel | Despite its unconventional look and feel, this blanket is warm, useful, and impressively affordable | A solid, comfortable blanket for just about any casual use |
| Rating Categories | REI Co-op Camp | NEMO Puffin | Wavelength | Snugpak Jungle | Kelty Bestie |
| Comfort (30%) | |||||
| Warmth (25%) | |||||
| Versatility (20%) | |||||
| Packed Size (15%) | |||||
| Features & Design (10%) | |||||
| Specs | REI Co-op Camp | NEMO Puffin | Wavelength | Snugpak Jungle | Kelty Bestie |
| Filling Type | Synthetic | Synthetic | Synthetic | Synthetic | Synthetic |
| Measured Blanket Size | 52" x 68" | 54" x 78" | 51" x 73" | 62" x 74" | 42" x 74" |
| Compressed Size | 3.3 L | 4 L | 11 L | 3.5 L | 3.5 L |
| Weather Resistance | DWR treatment (light water resistance) |
DWR treatment (water resistance) |
water resistant | windproof & MicroDiamond (light water resistance) |
none |
| Weight | 19 oz | 36 oz | 40 oz | 26 oz | 24 oz |
| Stuff Sack | Y - drawstring | Y - zippered | Y - drawstring | Y - compression | Y - drawstring |
| Exterior Material | pertex (nylon) bottom ripstop, top is not |
30D nylon micro-ripstop | 20D nylon | 100% polyester with Paratex antibacterial treatment | 75 D polyester taffeta top 190T polyester pungee bottom |
| Insulation Material | Polyester fibers | 600G Stratofiber (synthetic) | TechLoft Silver (synthetic - resinated polyester fiber) | Travelsoft (synthetic - resinated polyester fiber) | 9.5 oz Cloudloft (synthetic) |
| Manufacturer Temp Rating (F) | Not specified | Not specified | Not specified | 45°F | Not specified |
| No | Yes - 1 zippered near feet | No | No | No | |
| Machine Washable | Yes - front load only | Yes - front load only | No - commercial washer only | Yes - front load only | Yes - front load only |
| Available Sizes | 1-person (tested), 2-person | 1-person (tested), 2-person | One size only | Regular (tested), X-Large | One size only |
| Additional Features | Corner loop to hang, sewn through in horizontal bars | Foot Nook foot box created by three buttons and holes, outwardly curved edges, sewn through in horizontal bars, contrast-colored top edge | Sewn through in horizontal bars | None | Softer bottom layer, sewn through boxes hold insulation in place |
Our Analysis and Test Results
The REI Camp blanket is a synthetic blanket filled with polyester fibers. It comes in numerous colors, patterns, and pictures, and can also be purchased in a larger, two-person size. REI also makes several other types of blankets we didn't test, including flannel options, fleece covers, under quilts, and ponchos.
Performance Comparison
Comfort
With an exterior of Pertex (a synthetic nylon fabric), the REI Camp blanket is an average, slick-feeling blanket. Its underside is a marginally less slick, softer fabric that is fine against your skin, but not a stand-out in comfort. At 52" x 68", this single-person blanket is much more suited as a lap blanket or shoulder throw than an appropriately-sized sleeping option. It's relatively thin, which we think makes it less naturally cozy than a thick, puffy blanket. It can't become a poncho either but is thin enough; you can feasibly use it as a sit-upon blanket if you so choose. All in all, it's functional, but our testers weren't as excited to use it as our award winners.
Warmth
With no listed fill-rating or temperature guidelines, we didn't have lofty expectations from this thin, synthetic blanket. In our laboratory insulation testing, it performed near the bottom of the pack when it comes to holding heat in. Every member of our testing team also remarked that it just doesn't feel overly warm to wear. With this level of warmth, it's best for use during chilly evenings and crisp fall days rather than truly cold winter weather.
Versatility
When it comes to versatility, the REI Camp is a mixed bag. You can't wear it as a poncho or stake it down for groundcover and it isn't the best combination of warmth and size for backpacking. However, it's treated with a DWR coating that repels nearly all water (aside from what soaked into the seams) and protects us against the wind. It also features one side of ripstop material, and it does a pretty bang-up job of shedding sand, dirt, pet hair, and other outside debris. It's a great choice for casual outdoor use but isn't up to particularly tough tasks like winter camping or backpacking.
Packed Size
Weighing just 19 ounces, this synthetic blanket compresses into a moderately sized 3.3 liter package. Synthetic blankets aren't known for their low weight or compressibility, so we're impressed by this characteristic of the REI Camp blanket. However, to reach these low numbers, it sacrifices a bit in the size and insulation department. It does fit easily back into its cinch-top stuff sack and is an excellent option for summer car camping in the mountains.
Features & Design
The Camp blanket is machine washable in a front-loading washer on a gentle cycle. Horizontal stitching helps hold the insulation in place and a single corner loop allows you to hang it up for drying or storage. Other than that, it's a pretty no-frills option.
Value
If you're after a no-nonsense blanket for summer and light spring/fall usage, the REI Camp might be your cup of tea. We've noticed it often has variable pricing through the cycles of seasonal color and pattern changes, that might make the lackluster (but totally adequate) performance more worthwhile. If you're after a better-performing blanket in any category, though, we think there are better options for the money.
Conclusion
The REI Camp blanket is adequate for light outdoor use. It's reasonably protective and durable without being particularly cozy or super warm. When asked to sum up their experience with this blanket, our testing team agrees, "it's fine".
— Maggie Brandenburg