Throughout the testing process, we had mixed feelings about the Survival Frog TACT Bivvy 2.0. On one hand, it's insanely inexpensive and lightweight; on the other, many facets were sacrificed to achieve this featherweight piece of gear. There wasn't another bivy in the review close enough in attributes to compare to the Frog TACT. In reality, this bivy was more like a mylar emergency blanket than a bivy. Adding to its appeal as an emergency product rather than a regular use one is the whistle attached to the stuff sack. In the end, we decided this piece could become useful for adventures when you don't plan to bivy, but there is a chance one could be injured, or have to spend an emergency night out. Because of its low price and lightweight, we recommend taking one on any pretty much any adventure where getting stuck out after dark is even a remote possibility. It would also be great to have in a first aid kit.If you're looking for a bivy that offers excellent emergency protection but is more re-usable check out the SOL Escape Bivy. It is more expensive but the massive increase in durability is worth it.
Survival Frog TACT Bivvy 2.0 Review
Cons: Durability, no zipper/cinch
Manufacturer: Survival Frog
Compare to Similar Products
Survival Frog TACT Bivvy 2.0
|Price||$24.97 at Amazon||$179.00 at REI||$249.95 at Backcountry|
Compare at 3 sellers
|$139.95 at Amazon||$199.95 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Weight, packed size||Lightweight, weatherproof, roomy, ease of use, bug screen, and on and on||Durable, lots of head room, completely weatherproof||Lightweight, versatile, stows easily, price is right||Extremely lightweight, packable|
|Cons||Durability, no zipper/cinch||Stuff sack too large||Overkill for milder climates, heavier||Leaky zippers||Expensive, no zipper|
|Bottom Line||We found the TACT to be best suited for very occasional emergency use||We searched high and low looking for some drawback with the OR Helium Bivy and found none||The Alpine is ultra capable in cold and wet environments; a true four-season bivy||A functional, lightweight bivy with several features to keep you comfortable and a few bucks in your wallet||A lightweight and simple model that helps protect against unforeseen wind, weather, and cold|
|Rating Categories||Survival Frog TACT Bivvy 2.0||Outdoor Research Helium Bivy||Outdoor Research Alpine Bivy||Backcountry Bivy||MSR Pro Bivy|
|Weather Resistance (25%)|
|Packed Size (15%)|
|Specs||Survival Frog TACT...||Outdoor Research...||Outdoor Research...||Backcountry Bivy||MSR Pro Bivy|
|Measured Weight (oz.)||4.6 oz||16.3 oz||20.7 oz||13.6 oz||8.9 oz|
|Packed Size (in.)||2" x 4.5"||4" x 12.5"||4" x 15.5"||3" x 9.5"||8" x 3.5"|
|Open Length (in.)||84"||82"||84"||80"||88"|
|Shoulder Width (in.)||36"||26"||26"||36"||36"|
|Material (top/bottom)||Polyester Film||Top: Pertex Shield 2.5L 100% nylon Bottom: 100% 40D nylon||Top: 3-layer Gore-Tex Respiration Positive fabric
Bottom: Waterproof Hydroseal coated nylon
|Top: 20D Nylon Ripstop
Bottom: 30D Nylon Ripstop
|20D ripstop nylon 2 ply breathable 1000mm|
|Sleeping Bag or Pad Attachments?||No||Yes||Sleeping pad straps||No||No|
|Poles?||No||Yes, one overhead shockcorded Delrin pole||Yes, one overhead shockcorded Delrin pole||No||No|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The TACT 2.0 bivy is essentially a more functional and protective emergency blanket. When emergency blankets are challenging to use, refold, and cover your entire body, the Frog TACT has been cut and taped into the shape of a bivy sack. There are many redeeming features of this bivy but shouldn't be considered equals to other emergency bivys such as the SOL Escape Bivy as it is durable enough to be considered reusable. The Frog TACT has the potential to be destroyed from just one use, depending on the environment. The polyester film was easily stretched or punctured by twigs/rocks.
When it came to precipitation, the Frog TACT did a pretty good job of keeping us dry. The material itself, a reflective polyester film, was indeed waterproof. The only times we felt that precipitation was making it inside the bag is when we would wake to the entrance/exit opening flapping in the wind. There wasn't a way to secure it or cinch it closed except for just rolling it up. Maybe bring some chip clips to keep the Doritos bag sealed? When compared to the other ultralight emergency bivy we tested, the SOL Escape, we did find the Frog Tact to be a bit more water-tight, but with some big drawbacks.
While the SOL Escape didn't completely close, it was much easier to manage when the wind kicked up and a storm was brewing. It was also much quieter than the Frog Tact.
While it must be said that the ventilation and breathability of all models we tested left something to be desired, the Frog Tact was especially uncomfortable in this aspect. While the polyester film that comprises the shell was sufficiently waterproof, it didn't allow for water vapor to pass from inside the bivy out. This left us damp from condensation and ultimately feeling very uncomfortable.
If you're looking for a night of plush comfort and relaxation, check out the Outdoor Research Helium or Alpine. Compared to the Frog Tact, you will feel as if nothing could touch you. The Frog Tact is for the intrepid few. It collected more condensation than any other model, it didn't have a closure system, and it was very loud and crinkly in high wind. All of these things cut into our night of sleep. There is no hiding the fact that this is an extreme minimalist bivy, but that it is better than not having anything at all. It kept the rain off our back, and while it made a fair amount of noise in the wind and rain, it was a sufficient shield from the elements.
This was absolutely the lightest bivy we tested. The creators of this bag seem to want a bivy that was made to be the lightest it could be with nothing added extra. It is as simple as they come at 128 grams or 0.28 pounds. What do you get for that minuscule weight? It comes with a durable stuff sack and a plain polyester film bivy. There is no closure system such as a zipper or drawstring, and frankly, the material isn't durable enough to necessitate any of those extras.
In all likelihood, you will tear/poke holes through this bivy within the first few nights you use it. We had durability issues on the first night we used the bag as a tiny sharp twig poked a hole in the bottom. If you want this bivy to last, we would suggest using some sort of ground cloth, which that would add to the weight of your entire sleeping system.
The 2019 Frog Tact saw the addition of a little whistle on the drawstring of the stuff pouch. While it obviously doesn't add anything to the performance of the bivy (which didn't change at all) it does add a couple of grams and the ability to help rescuers find you!
If you remember the miniature 7.5 oz cans of Coke, you have a good idea of the size of this bivy when its rolled and packed in its stuff sack. It is insanely small! We felt that given this item uses much more material than a standard emergency blanket, it's miraculous that it packs down into such a tiny stuff sack. We also liked that it wasn't a chore to stuff it down to size.
It folds and rolls up into the stuff pouch with minimal effort. The measured size of the packed bivy was about 2 inches wide by 4.5 inches long. It would even be reasonable to throw this thing in your ultrarunning backpack for trail emergencies and unplanned bivys. You probably won't even remember it's in your pack.
The Tact is best suited for emergency situations. After spending several nights out in this bivy, it became apparent that it isn't made for prolonged use. If you're undertaking a long single day adventure and feel more comfortable having some sort of emergency shelter, the Frog Tact is an excellent choice. In addition to being very waterproof, the bivy weights next to nothing and packs down to the size of half a La Croix can.
The TACT is by far the cheapest bivy we tested at $25, often retailing for less. This seems like a drop in the bucket compared to some of the expedition bivies such as the Outdoor Research Alpine Bivy or the Black Diamond Bivy. While the Frog is quite cheap, consider its durability when you're buying it. If you really only need something to throw in the bottom of your pack for unforeseen circumstances, it is a great value. If you're looking for a bivy to spend night after night in, this bag will fall apart necessitating you to buy several more. Because it won't stand up to the abuse of daily usage, it might be wise to have one bivy for heavy use such as the Sierra Designs Backcountry Bivy and a backup Frog TACT for shorter adventure with the off chance of a bivy.
The Survival Frog TACT Bivvy 2.0 to be a great option for shelter and emergency weather protection in a tiny lightweight package. Durability restricts this bivy to very few uses before it starts to show the wear but if you're very careful with it, it could last. While being similar to an emergency blanket, the TACT is more durable and better designed to keep you warm and dry as it is formed into a sleeping bag shape and doesn't require you to hold it wrapped around your body.
— Brian Martin