While we might not choose to take the MSR Pro Bivy out as our go-to bivy for all conditions, it does have some fantastic specialist characteristics that earn it our Top Pick for ultralight adventures. The durable weatherproof shell combined with the extremely low weight of this bivy makes it very attractive to those looking to shed weight while not being hung out to dry if temperatures drop, the wind kicks up, or rain sets in unexpectedly. As the bivy itself doesn't have a zipper or drawstring, if you're using this for a long term trip or thru-hike, it's probably best combined with a tarp or other shelter solution.If you're on the hunt for a more standalone shelter that doesn't require a tarp for comprehensive weather protection, the Outdoor Research Helium is a great solution. Additionally if the hefty price-tag of the MSR Pro is outside your budget, the SOL Escape offers some excellent characteristics for the same weight, at a fraction of the price.
MSR Pro Bivy Review
Cons: Expensive, no zipper
Compare to Similar Products
MSR Pro Bivy
|Price||$200 List||Check Price at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$159.95 at Amazon||$55.99 at Amazon|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$24.97 at Amazon|
|Pros||Extremely lightweight, packable||Lightweight, weatherproof, roomy, ease of use, bug screen, and on and on||Lightweight, versatile, stows easily, price is right||Light, durable, warm, affordable||Weight, packed size|
|Cons||Expensive, no zipper||Stuff sack too large||Leaky zippers||Not waterproof, tight fit for 5'11"+ individuals||Durability, no zipper/cinch|
|Bottom Line||An effective and lightweight bivy that far outperforms other emergency or minimalist shelters||This very well may be the new standard in what we expect from a top notch bivy sack||This model boasts an enticing weight, comfort, and versatility ratio||The Escape is an excellent lightweight choice for cold dry climates or emergency situations||The TACT is an ultra lightweight reusable emergency bivy best suited for very occasional use|
|Rating Categories||MSR Pro Bivy||Outdoor Research He...||Sierra Designs Back...||SOL Escape Bivvy||Survival Frog TACT...|
|Weather Resistance (25%)|
|Packed Size (15%)|
|Specs||MSR Pro Bivy||Outdoor Research He...||Sierra Designs Back...||SOL Escape Bivvy||Survival Frog TACT...|
|Measured Weight (oz.)||8.9 oz||16.3 oz||13.6 oz||8.36 oz||4.6 oz|
|Packed Size (in.)||8" x 3.5"||4" x 12.5"||3" x 9.5"||4" x 7.5"||2" x 4.5"|
|Waterproof?||Yes||Yes||Yes||Water-resistant fabric with waterproof seams||Yes|
|Open Length (in.)||88"||82"||80"||84"||84"|
|Shoulder Width (in.)||36"||26"||36"||31"||36"|
|Material (top/bottom)||20D ripstop nylon 2 ply breathable 1000mm||Top: Pertex Shield 2.5L 100% nylon Bottom: 100% 40D nylon||Top: 20D Nylon Ripstop
Bottom: 30D Nylon Ripstop
|Metalized Spun-bonded Olefin||Polyester Film|
|Sleeping Bag or Pad Attachments?||No||Yes||No||No||No|
|Poles?||No||Yes, one overhead shockcorded Delrin pole||No||No||No|
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Pro Bivy knocked the ever-popular SOL Escape out of the top position for emergency bivys for 2019. While we still love the SOL Escape, the Pro offers similar warmth but with added wind and weather protection. In addition, the MSR Pro actually stuffs down into a smaller area than the SOL Escape, making it a bit more packable which we find increases the chances that one will actually take the emergency piece of equipment along.
While the Pro isn't an ultra-protective bivy, it does have its place in our gear closet. We found the material of the MSR Pro to be waterproof even after about an hour of constant rain. There were some weak points in the MSR's armor, however. The closure system is simply a flap of material, which does indeed save a lot of weight but also allows wind and water to blow right in. We found that we had to be extremely careful, especially when water would pool on the surface of the bivy. Coaxing these pools off the bivy without draining them into the bivy was, at times, a challenge. Yes, you could keep yourself warm and dry in a downpour, but it would take some effort on your part.
Looking at the Pro Bivy alongside the SOL Escape helps to highlight the benefits. We were able to stay drier longer in the MSR since the SOL material isn't completely waterproof. The MSR is roomier both lengthwise and widthwise, which lets you get comfortable and help the bivy shed water in a way that keeps you dry. The bottom line is if we were told it was going to rain all day and we had to choose between being bagged up in either the SOL Escape or the MSR Pro, we would take the MSR every time. If it was just going to be cold outside with no precipitation, the choice would be a toss-up as both models offered increased warmth.
Saving weight is what this bivy is all about. MSR took away all of the creature comforts and slimmed this bivy down to the essentials. What is left is a bivy that offers decent wind, weather, and cold protection without being noticeable in your bag. At 8.9 oz (296 grams), it is barely heavier than our previous top pick for emergency bivys the SOL Escape and offers a larger footprint which equates to more space to move around and adjust inside.
Typically, emergency bivys are far from comfortable. They are more comfortable than being left out in the elements, but that's a pretty low bar to hurdle. The MSR Pro's ample footprint and length made it pretty bearable for multiple nights while out bikepacking in the cold. It is big enough to fit a regular length inflatable sleeping pad, 30-degree Western Mountaineering sleeping bag, and a 175-lb person with room to spare. One of our biggest complaints from the SOL Bivy was how constricted we felt inside, even when we left the sleeping pad on the outside.
There is also an important factor regarding comfort that must be mentioned. If you're into fast and light ascents, ultralight backpacking, or bikepacking, this bivy can offer a significant comfort factor at a minimal weight penalty. If you're pinned down in an unexpected storm or get benighted on a remote ridge, the added warmth, wind resistance, and weather protection offered by the MSR Pro will significantly boost your comfort level. Yes, the same could be said of all bivys we tested, but keep in mind the MSR is minimalist and light.
Ventilation and Breathing
As it is with every bivy we have tested over the years, it was common to have some condensation form inside the bag, especially on colder nights. This was kept to an extreme minimum in the MSR Pro and was actually pretty rare that you could even see the moisture collected or deposited on our sleeping bag. This is in part to the large open vent at the head of the bivy and also in part to the breathable 20d fabric which comprises the shell.
When stacked up against the SOL Bivy the two bags are fairly comparable regarding ventilation and breathing. They both utilize breathable fabrics and have an opening at the top, which can't be completely closed. The SOL has a bit of an advantage in this department, however, as it has a cinch at the top and a zipper down the side. These closures give you some options for added ventilation, a feature the MSR Pro doesn't have.
The MSR Pro has the smallest packed size of all re-usable bivys tested. The only bivy tested that has a smaller packed footprint was the Frog Tact bivy, which will only last for a few uses as it isn't designed for extended, everyday use. Despite weighing slightly more than the SOL Escape the MSR was able to pack down into a smaller container, and we even found we could still pack it even tighter.
Looking at the MSR Pro and the SOL Escape side by side reveals the differences in packed size. Pretty incredible, considering the unpacked size of the MSR Pro is significantly larger and more comfortable than the SOL Escape
It's difficult to pigeon hole the MSR Pro into a single category. It was a fantastic compliment to our Western Mountaineering HighLite during the Pinyons and Pines Ultra Bikepacking Race. Its lightweight and extremely packable design made it perfect for some added insurance out in the wilderness. If you're going to be on an extended journey like a through hike on the Pacific Crest Trail, this bivy might not provide enough storm protection. However, if you're going ultralight and don't mind the prospect of being a little uncomfortable from time to time, the MSR Pro would certainly get the job done. At its heart, this model is an ultralight emergency bivy but provides enough weather protection and warmth we wouldn't hesitate to take it on a longer journey with the knowledge that we might be a bit uncomfortable in a raging storm.
Is this ultralight bivy worth the price tag? Maybe. If we ignore the price and look at the MSR Pro alongside the SOL Escape we would have the MSR Pro. Bring dollar bills into the equation and the answer might be different. With such strong competition at reasonable prices, shelling out those two crisp Franklins would be difficult. The issue isn't that the MSR Pro itself isn't worth the money, it's that you could purchase the Outdoor Research Helium and the SOL Escape for only $40.00 more, and that's retail pricing. As with most niche products, this ultralight product has great value if it fits your needs specifically. Otherwise, your money is likely spent elsewhere.
The MSR Pro Bivy is a fantastic product. It is extremely lightweight and the most packable bivy we have tested. It is a bit on the pricy side, but in our experience, these highly technical pieces are worth the investment. While there are other options for those on a budget, the MSR Pro fills a gap between basic emergency bivys such as the SOL Escape and heavier-duty bivys such as the OR Helium.
— Brian Martin