Potable Aqua Purification Tablets Review
Compare prices at 2 resellers Pros: Easy to use, lightweight, packable
Cons: Not safe to use long-term, lower value than other chemical treatments, poor taste
Manufacturer: Potable Aqua
Compare to Similar Products
Potable Aqua Purification Tablets
|Price||$7.76 at Amazon|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$37.06 at Amazon|
Compare at 2 sellers
Check Price at Backcountry
|$14.95 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$9.95 at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|Pros||Easy to use, lightweight, packable||Easy to use, fast flow rate, collapsible, lightweight||Lightweight, great price, durable design, fast flow, high volume filtration, use for cold weather||Lightweight, inexpensive, kills all pathogens (including crypto), reliable||Easy to use, super packable, lightweight, cheap in comparison to other filters|
|Cons||Not safe to use long-term, lower value than other chemical treatments, poor taste||Lacks durability and reliability||Doesn't filter out viruses, no additional storage reservoir||Takes a long time to kill crypto, slight taste to the water, chemical treatment||More expensive then other chemical treatment, chlorinated taste, does not kill Crypto|
|Bottom Line||This can be used as an emergency treatment system, but not much else||Our favorite lightweight on-the-go filtration system||A convenient and easy-to-use gravity filter at a great price||These drops are a reliable and lightweight option to carry all over the world||This is the lightest chemical treatment option out there|
|Rating Categories||Purification Tablets||Katadyn BeFree||Katadyn Gravity Cam...||Water Treatment Drops||MSR Aquatabs|
|Water Quality (20%)|
|Durability & Maintenance (20%)|
|Treatment Time (15%)|
|Weight & Packability (15%)|
|Ease Of Set Up (15%)|
|Ease Of Filtration (15%)|
|Specs||Purification Tablets||Katadyn BeFree||Katadyn Gravity Cam...||Water Treatment Drops||MSR Aquatabs|
|Type of filter/purifier||Chemical treatment||Squeeze & on-the-go||Gravity filter||Chemical treatment||Chemical treatment|
|Time to treat one liter (timed test)||33 minutes||immediate||64 seconds||Clear Water - 20 min
Turbid Water - 35 min
|Measured weight (entire kit, oz)||2.3 oz||2.1 oz||11.7 oz||3.0 oz||0.1 oz|
|Total cost per 100 L ($)||$52.00||$4.00||$6.00||$13.16||$16.67|
|Replacement cartridge cost per 100 L ($)||$52.00||$2.50||$2.67||$13.16||$16.67|
|# of liters (L)/gallons (gal) per lifetime||25 L/6.6 gal||1000 L/264 gal||1,500 L/396 gal||114 L/30 gal per package||60 L/16 gal (30 tabs)|
|Filter media or active ingredient||Iodine & Tetraglycine Hydroperiodide||Hollow Fiber||Pleated glassfiber||Chlorine Dioxide||Sodium dichloroisocyanurate|
|Effective against bacteria?||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Effective against protozoa? (Cryptosporidium, Giardia)||Yes (Gardia = yes; Crypto = no)||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes (Gardia = yes; Crypto = no)|
|Effective against viruses?||Yes||No||No||Yes||Yes|
|Effective against chemicals?||No||No||No||No||No|
|Effective against heavy metals?||No||No||No||No||No|
|Removes Particulates (sediment, microplastics)?||No||Yes||Yes||No||No|
|Filter pore size||N/A||0.1 micron||0.2 microns||N/A||N/A|
|Advertised flow rate||N/A||2.11 L per min||2 L/min||N/A||N/A|
|Dimensions||N/A||9.05 in x 2.73 in||10 x 6 x 2.4 in||N/A||N/A|
|Storage capacity (L)||0||0.6 L||6 L||0||0|
Our Analysis and Test Results
Potable Agua is an Iodine-based chemical treatment that has functionality as an emergency back-up method. It should not be a primary treatment method as it's not deemed safe for long-term ingestion. While it does leave a bad taste in the water, it's not as bad as some competitors. The price is low, but for the number of tablets you get per package, other emergency back-up methods offer better value. While we love this product, there are better alternatives out there.
Potable Agua uses Iodine & Tetraglycine Hydroperiodide as its primary active ingredient, which has been shown to eliminate bacteria, viruses, and protozoa like Giardia, but does not protect against hard-shelled cysts that are resistant. It also treats effectively in everything from clear to cloudy water. If you plan on traveling in areas that have these as a concern, we'd recommend using drops that protect from viruses or these hard shelled cysts.
The taste of Iodine is one that some people hate and others can't detect at all. For those that can recognize it, you'll notice a strong metallic taste that becomes nauseating to ingest in large quantities. There are neutralizing tablets that are meant to dissipate the nasty taste, but these only lessen the effect.
If you plan on taking water from a source with lots of sediment, expect to drink sediment as these chemical treatments don't filter out particulates. You can easily pre-filter with a buff or handkerchief if you happen to come across a sandy source.
Overall, water quality isn't the best when using Iodine tablets. It's also essential to make sure you don't plan on using them as your primary source of purification. According to Potable Aqua , this can be bad for your health. As a result, we recommend other chemical treatments or use this for emergency purposes only.
Durability & Maintenance
The jars are heavy duty. Even though they are glass, it's thick and would be hard to break if dropped on a hard surface. This type of treatment has no durability issues or maintenance. One jar has about 50 tablets, treating a total of 25L per jar. There is no expiration date on these tablets. In addition, you can simply put some into a baggie and carry them with you on the trail.
In total, the two-step treatment takes about 33 minutes. The first step is the Iodine tablet, which takes about 30 minutes to kick in. The second step is the neutralizing tablet that you need to wait 3 minutes for after the 30 minutes is over. You can also choose to use this system without the neutralizing tablet if the taste doesn't both you too much.
Weight & Packability
These tablets are kept in two small glass jars, weighing only 2.25 oz together. They are cylindrical and very packable.
If you wish to eliminate weight further, you can store the tablets separately in two different snack-size ziplock bags, which cuts down on the weight of the jars. Or you can carry step one, cutting the weight in half. Given how lightweight and packable they are, they are a great emergency option if you want to bring along a back-up system. We've also used them for trail running in case we drink more water than anticipated and need an emergency fill-up.
Ease of Set-Up
Set-up is easy. Get two tablets per liter out of the jar and drop them into the vessel that needs treatment. You will need first to collect your water, so select a storage vessel that can access both small and large water sources. If your water source is silty or full or sediment, be sure to either filter through a piece of fabric before or after treatment.
Ease of Filtration
This part is easy. Wait thirty minutes. After that time, add in two neutralizing tabs per 1-L of water. These part two tablets eliminate Iodine, so it's important that you wait for the full 30-min before adding them. If you do this too soon, the Iodine may not kill all the water-borne pathogens that could exist in your source, which can be dangerous. After 33-minutes, it's easy to drink.
Given that one jar only treats about 25L, it's not the best value product when it comes to chemical treatment. That works out to about $0.44 per liter filtered, which isn't the best-valued chemical treatment product, even though the price looks low.
Iodine is a classic chemical treatment method that is best as an emergency method. It is lightweight and easy to use. That said, it's not as good as other options out there. Iodine is not a safe option to use long term, and its relative value doesn't stack up to the competition.
— Amber King