The world's most in-depth and scientific reviews of outdoor gear

Patagonia Dirt Roamer - Women's Review

One of the best fitting shorts we have ever tested, the Dirt Roamer is comfortable and super lightweight.
Top Pick Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:  $99 List | $39.99 at MooseJaw
Compare prices at 3 resellers
Pros:  Lightweight, four-way stretch, excellent fit, breathable, super comfortable
Cons:  Not as protective for burly terrain
Manufacturer:   Patagonia
By Laurel Hunter ⋅ Review Editor  ⋅  May 20, 2019
  • Share this article:
90
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#2 of 11
  • Fit and Comfort - 30% 10
  • Pedal Friendliness - 30% 10
  • Protection - 20% 7
  • Pockets - 10% 8
  • Style - 10% 8

Our Verdict

The Patagonia Dirt Roamer is a super minimalist short, in both look and weight. Made of lightweight (and recycled) polyester, with welded seams, the appearance is sleek or plain, depending on your style. However, it is thoughtfully designed and provides amazing comfort on the bike, with lightweight fabric, four-way stretch, and a super dialed-in fit. It easily earns our Top Pick for Comfort.

Though the very lightweight fabric is not as burly as we like for tackling technical terrain, the inseam is long enough to pair with low-profile kneepads. And it even has one perfectly sized zippered pocket. Nice.


Compare to Similar Products

Our Analysis and Test Results

When we think of Patagonia brand clothing a lot of us think of fleece and puffy jackets, but their roots are in technical clothing and the Dirt Roamer quickly won us over with its welded seams, super lightweight material, and excellent fit. These shorts are made for long days on the bike, making them our Top Pick for Comfort.

Hands-On Review of the Dirt Roamer


Just one ride in the Dirt Roamer and we were impressed. Putting it to the test won us over. Lightweight, breathable, comfortable and a perfect fit, it features an extremely minimal aesthetic and design that puts shorts in the back of your mind and biking at the front.

This is a super minimal short that is lightweight  comfortable  and performs well. We are fans.
This is a super minimal short that is lightweight, comfortable, and performs well. We are fans.

Fit and Comfort


We have never had a mountain bike short that we forgot we were wearing before testing the Patagonia Dirt Roamer. This short is so lightweight, so stretchy, and so functional, we quickly knew it was one of the most comfortable shorts we had worn.

The Dirt Roamer comes in numbered sizes from 0-18, about twice the number of sizes offered from most other brands. This makes for a much better fit for more ladies. While many manufacturers count on the waist adjuster to dial in a good fit, this short is cut to fit, and the minimal waist adjustment system is only required for tweaking the waistline. The size 4 we tested fit as expected and we barely needed to adjust the waist, meaning no added bulky fabric to soak up sweat.


We barely needed the clever waist adjustment system of this short  but it helped tweak the waist.
We barely needed the clever waist adjustment system of this short, but it helped tweak the waist.

We do want to give a shout-out the waist adjustment system, however. Called "OppoSet" it uses the button at the top of the fly to leverage a webbing strap that is hidden in the waistline. It is super simple to use, even with gloves and adds almost no additional weight to the short.

The nearly 12-inch inseam provides excellent coverage from sun, wind, and weather. The asymmetrical cut means that they offer full coverage on top of the leg when seated on the bike without fabric bunching up behind the knee.

The asymmetrical cut on the legs provides extra coverage on the top of the leg without bunching up behind the knee.
The asymmetrical cut on the legs provides extra coverage on the top of the leg without bunching up behind the knee.

Pedal Friendliness


This is where the Dirt Roamer really shines. It is made with four-way stretch (from recycled polyester and spandex), for just the right amount of movement while pedaling and descending. It flexed and moved without slipping or bunching up, no matter how steep the climb.


We rode in all kinds of weather and the Dirt Roamer proved to be both breathable in warm temps and protective from wind and rain on blustery days. We have said this before but if we hadn't been testing and taking notes, we would have forgotten about this short altogether, which is a rare and high compliment to the fit, design, and technology that Patagonia put into it. These are simply the most pedal-friendly shorts we've tried, earning a perfect score in this metric.

Protection


We measured the inseam of the Dirt Roamer to be a hair under 12 inches, long enough to pair with kneepads. But the lightweight nature of the short doesn't scream protection, and indeed one tester acquired an impressively long scratch from a bitterbrush bush while riding down a social trail in these shorts. While the fabric of the short was impressively unmarred by the encounter, it reminded us that we prefer burly material when we are tackling technical terrain.

Additionally, the tapered leg means that only very lightweight kneepads are compatible with the Dirt Roamer. However, for sun and wind protection these are a favorite, with lots of coverage at a barely-there weight. The DWR finish worked like a charm to repel water when we encountered unexpected rain.


If you are looking for more protection in a short, take a look at the Editor's Choice winner, Yeti's updated Norrie 2.0 or the burlier and longer 100% Airmatic, both of which held off grabby branches with ease and work well with substantial kneepads.

These shorts feature only one pocket  but it is zippered and big enough to hold a phone.
These shorts feature only one pocket, but it is zippered and big enough to hold a phone.

Pockets


As you might expect from a super minimal short, the Dirt Roamer has only one pocket. But what a pocket it is! Welded onto the leg, it adds almost no bulk to the shorts when not in use. It is zippered and located just where we want it, on the side of the leg. It is also big enough to hold a phone, snacks, micro-trash, or keys.


As with most pockets that are not mesh, we did see some condensation build up on the phone screen, though not to the degree of some of the burlier shorts we tested. If you like more pockets, may we suggest the Yeti Norrie 2.0? It has two zippered pockets and two casual hand pockets.

Welded seams make for an extra clean look (and no chafing!)
Welded seams make for an extra clean look (and no chafing!)

Style


The super clean and minimal look of the Dirt Roamer may not be for everyone. The zipper pull is black, but otherwise, you are looking at a very monotone piece of clothing — even the button is the same color! Because the seams are almost all welded, there isn't any stitching to create contrast or texture. However, there are really lovely details that add feminine touches, including the asymmetrical taper on the legs and the overall flattering cut of the shorts. These shorts are all business, with no extras, and they look it.


If you dig a more playful and maximal look, check out the Shredly MTB short which comes in a kaleidoscope of colors and patterns, and is pretty much the opposite of the Dirt Roamer's sleek aesthetic.

This understated short excels at comfort and breathability.
This understated short excels at comfort and breathability.

Best Applications


No doubt about it, the Dirt Roamer is made for big, long days on the bike. It will handle shorter rides with ease, but the lightweight fabric, stretch, water repellency, and breathability made us dream of tackling our next big mountain loop adventure ride. While it can handle more technical terrain, this short doesn't offer up as much protection as we like when branches and rocks are involved, so we feel it is best for more open, less burly terrain.

Value


The $100 you have to pay for the Dirt Roamer is a lot of dough for a pair of shorts. But the details and quality are fully evident from the first ride. Being comfortable on the bike is priceless, so if you don't need a lot of protection, these are worth their weight in gold (which isn't the best metaphor since they weigh almost nothing).

Conclusion


We were surprised how much we enjoyed riding in the Patagonia Dirt Roamer. They are light, stretchy, well-made, and breathable. They are not the most protective short, but the fit is so perfect we hardly noticed that we had them on. All of the details are just right and that is why it is our Top Pick For Comfort.


Laurel Hunter