Sidi SD15 Review
Cons: Expensive for performance, terrible power transfer, minimal foot protection, thin footbeds
Compare to Similar Products
|Price||$239.99 at Competitive Cyclist||$130.00 at Competitive Cyclist||$169.96 at Competitive Cyclist|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$160.00 at Competitive Cyclist||$149.95 at Competitive Cyclist|
|Pros||Grippy rubber soles, walks well, solid closures||Lightweight, reasonable price, casual style, great blend of pedaling stiffness and walkability||comfortable, versatile, great traction while hiking, boa closures, good style||Lugged //Vibram// sole, versatile fit, stiff but walkable||Good power transfer, comfortable, secure, many features|
|Cons||Expensive for performance, terrible power transfer, minimal foot protection, thin footbeds||Roomy fit in the forefoot, not the best lateral stability||Sometimes too grippy for a clipless focused shoe, heavy||Limited on-the-go adjustments||Minimal protection, not the most durable|
|Bottom Line||High expectations but underwhelming performance from one of the industry's most popular shoe manufacturers||Lightweight with good power transfer and walkability, these are a reasonably priced trail riding shoe with casual styling||Stiff, comfortable, and protective, this shoe is a great choice for the demands of enduro-style riding||A lightweight and sturdy shoe to take on the backcountry||An XC/trail riding shoe that combines high performance with affordability|
|Rating Categories||Sidi SD15||Specialized 2FO Roost Clip||Five Ten Kestrel Pro Boa||Specialized Rime 2.0||Scott MTB Team Boa|
|Power Transfer (20%)|
|Traction Walkability (25%)|
|Specs||Sidi SD15||Specialized 2FO...||Five Ten Kestrel...||Specialized Rime 2.0||Scott MTB Team Boa|
|Closure||Tecno 3 closure system and velcro straps||Laces||Boa dial plus velcro at toe box||L6 Boa and Laces||Boa dials, plus velcro strap|
|Measured Weight (per shoe)||416 grams||375 grams||511 grams||419 grams||405 grams|
|Upper Material||Politex suede effect upper, mesh||Synthetic Leather and Textile||Synthetic||XPEL Hydrophobic Mesh||Micro Fiber, mesh|
|Footbed||Nylon/Polyester||Specialized Body Geometry||OrthoLite||Specialized Body Geometry||ErgoLogic|
|Sole||Politex Suede Effect Upper, mesh||Stiff Lollipop nylon composite plate||Carbon-infused nylon shank||Lollipop Nylon Composite||Composite|
|Outsole||Suola Outdoor, rubber||SlipNot FG||Steatlh C4 rubber||Vibram||StickiRubber|
Our Analysis and Test Results
We have to admit that we were excited when we saw the SD15. It seemed like the Italian bike shoe giant Sidi had finally made a mountain bike shoe with a grippy walkable sole, and we assumed that it would have their signature XC style performance that we have come to know and love. Unfortunately, that was not the case. The SD15 fell short of the bar set by all of the other shoes in our test selection. The SD15 was designed with all-mountain and trail riding in mind, and we found it best suited for that style of riding. Due to the more flexible nature of the soles on the SD15, it works best with pedals that have medium or large platforms to help maximize what little power transfer these shoes provide.
Contrary to our expectations, the SD15 failed to deliver the power transfer that Sidi shoes are typically known for. In fact, the SD15 scored the lowest of all shoes tested in that category. As far as we can tell, there is no shank whatsoever in the shoe, and this is evidenced by the fact that you can fold them in half. The shoes flex under power, and you can feel the pedal through the sole of the shoe. This results in foot fatigue, soreness, and cramping. While riding, you could also feel the sole flex laterally around the cleat. This took us off guard, and it is unclear why a mountain bike shoe with clipless pedal compatibility would be made with such little support in the sole, especially for the price.
Off the bike, the SD15 is a reasonably comfortable shoe. The soft Politex Suede synthetic uppers are supple and conform to your feet within minutes of putting them on. The shoe features one of Sidi's Tecno 3 cable closures that crisscrosses over the upper part of the foot while a simple Velcro strap secures it down by the toes. Unfortunately, these shoes aren't just made for walking around in, because they are comfortable for that purpose. On the bike, these shoes are uncomfortable for several reasons.
There is very minimal padding, mainly the tongue and around the top of the ankle opening, as well as Sidi's signature molded plastic heel cup. Otherwise, the shoe offers little to no protection for the feet, and we felt especially vulnerable in these shoes. Just like the Sidi Trace 2, the footbed of the SD15 is wafer thin and offers little support or cushioning. The Sidi "Outdoor Sole" lacks a stiff shank in the sole which allows it to flex under power. The flex of the sole leads to strain and even cramping of the feet both when pedaling and descending. Walking on rocks - one of this shoe's strong points - is even somewhat uncomfortable since you can feel the points of the rocks through the sole. Sure these shoes fit nicely, but that's about where the comfort ends.
One of the SD15's strongest points is its traction and walkability. We might even go out on a limb and say that this shoe is better for walking than it is for riding. Sidi's "Outdoor Sole" is a full coverage rubber sole with large well-spaced lugs under the heel and the forefoot. The rubber isn't as soft as that found on the Five Ten Hellcat Pro or the Specialized Rime 2.0, but it is still very grippy and offered excellent traction on virtually all surfaces. The wide spacing of the lugs cleared mud, snow, and other debris with ease. The walkability of the SD15 is made even better because the sole offers full flex from toe to heel, much like a pair of running or hiking shoes, so it is not inhibited in any way by a shank or anything similar. The lack of shank in the sole is disconcerting in many ways, and it means that you can feel sharp rocks through the sole when you step on them.
The SD15 weighs 416g per shoe for the size 44 that we tested. It's by no means the lightest shoe out there, but far from the heaviest. The shoes feel light in your hand and also on your feet. That said, the SD15 weighs about the same as several other shoes in our test selection that offer significantly better power transfer and overall performance such as the Shimano ME7 or our top pick for trail riders, the Specialized 2FO Cliplite. Anyone looking for a lighter and less expensive pair of shoes with far superior power transfer need look no further than the Giro Privateer R.
Despite our general lack of enthusiasm for the performance of the SD15 we have to admit that it appears to be a well-made product. So far there are no durability issues to report. The soles look almost brand new. The stitching is all intact, and there is barely a scratch on the uppers. The closures have also worked flawlessly thus far.
We do not feel that the SD15 is a good value due to the poor power transfer and on the bike performance. We are a little surprised by this due to Sidi's long-standing reputation as one of the best shoe manufacturers in the business. For the money, we would recommend something else with similar walkability and far superior on-the-bike performance.
Our expectations for the SD15 were met with a truly underwhelming performance due to inferior power transfer and on-the-bike performance. While we like the concept of a walkable Sidi mountain bike shoe with a grippy rubber sole, they failed to create one that excels at the shoe's primary task, riding a bike. If only they would glue this sole to the bottom of one of their proven high-performance models, then they would be on to something.
— Jeremy Benson