Reviews You Can Rely On

Shimano S-Phyre SH-RC903 Review

Previously focused purely on performance, this top-level shoe now offers comfort to match
gearlab tested logo
Shimano S-Phyre SH-RC903 Review (The Shimano S-Phyre SH-RC903 is light, stiff, and very blue.)
The Shimano S-Phyre SH-RC903 is light, stiff, and very blue.
Credit: Arthur Richardson
Price:  $450 List
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Manufacturer:   Shimano
By Arthur Richardson ⋅ Review Editor  ⋅  Aug 29, 2024
86
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#1 of 14
  • Comfort - 35% 9.0
  • Power Transfer - 30% 9.0
  • Durability - 20% 8.0
  • Weight - 15% 7.5

Our Verdict

The Shimano S-Phyre RC903 is our absolute favorite high-performance cycling shoe. Its stiff construction offers excellent power transfer and unparalleled heel retention, perfect for riders who want to push all of the watts to their pedals. This is the shoe you'll see worn by many in professional pelotons and on the feet of riders in your local fast group. Its updated wrap-around upper offers all-day comfort, making it just as suitable for a casual Saturday century. Of course, all of this performance comes with a premium price tag. If you want to wear the best of the best, look no further than the RC903. But if you're looking for a more reasonably priced option, check out our review of other top-ranked cycling shoes.
REASONS TO BUY
Stiff yet comfortable
Lightweight
Wide range of adjustability
Locked-in heel cup
REASONS TO AVOID
Expensive
Putting on and off is a two-handed operation
Heel and outsole cover show wear easily

Compare to Similar Products

 
Awards Editors' Choice Award
Best Overall Cycling Shoes
Top Pick Award
Best for All-Day Comfort
Best Buy Award
Great Value for All-Around Performance
  
Price $396.75 at Amazon
Compare at 2 sellers
$200 List
$200.00 at REI
$149.95 at Backcountry
Compare at 2 sellers
Check Price at Amazon$60 List
Overall Score Sort Icon
86
61
57
53
48
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Bottom Line Shimano added more comfort to this proven platform, offering performance that's a cut above the restThis shoe excels on rides when comfort is the priorityConsistency across all of our testing metrics make this shoe an excellent value propositionIf comfort is paramount, this lightweight shoe is an affordable optionAn inexpensive and serviceable cycling shoe for a fraction of the price
Rating Categories Shimano S-Phyre SH-... Quoc Escape Road Giro Cadet Shimano SH-RC100 Venzo SPD-SL
Comfort (35%)
9.0
8.0
6.0
7.0
7.0
Power Transfer (30%)
9.0
4.0
6.0
3.0
4.0
Durability (20%)
8.0
7.0
6.0
5.0
2.0
Weight (15%)
7.5
4.4
4.0
6.6
4.7
Specs Shimano S-Phyre SH-... Quoc Escape Road Giro Cadet Shimano SH-RC100 Venzo SPD-SL
Closures BOA Li2 (two) Quoc Dial (one) BOA L6 (one), Hook and Loop (one) Hook and loop (three) Hook and loop (three)
Width Options Regular, Wide Regular Regular Regular Regular
Sole Stiffness (millimeter deflection at 25 lbs) 1.39 12.1 7.18 13.74 7.93
Measured Weight (Pair) 16.72 oz (size 42.5) 18.45 oz (size 42) 18.66 oz (size 42) 17.21 oz (size 43) 18.27 oz (size 43)
Size Tested (EU) 42.5 42 42 43 43
Outsole Carbon fiber Carbon-reinforced nylon Carbon-reinforced nylon Fiberglass-reinforced nylon Nylon
Outsole Ventilation Toe and heel Toe None Toe None
Upper Material Microfiber synthetic leather PU synthetic leather Synchwire synthetic PU synthetic leather Mesh, synthetic leather
Reflective Hits None Upper Heel None Heel
Cleat Adjustment +/- 5 mm +/- 1.5 mm 3-Bolt: none; 2-Bolt: 2 cm +/- 5 mm None
Replaceable Toe/Heel Pads Heel Heel None None None

Our Analysis and Test Results

The updated S-Phyre RC903 features a revised fit, new routing for the front BOA cable, and slightly reduced weight. It is a leader in comfort and power transfer, excelling in all aspects of our in-depth testing. Below, we dig into what design and performance attributes make the RC903 such a great shoe.

Performance Comparison


shimano s-phyre sh-rc903 - although the s-phyre rc903 is designed specifically as a road...
Although the S-Phyre RC903 is designed specifically as a road cycling shoe, it isn't afraid of a little hard riding off of the pavement, either.
Credit: Adam Bridier

Comfort


Ergonomic design, excellent adjustability, and top-end materials establish the RC903 as the leader of the pack when it comes to comfort. Previous iterations were single-mindedly focused on performance, and with a number of stage wins at cycling's Grand Tours, that recipe paid off. But with the RC903 edition of the S-Phyre line, comfort considerations no longer come in second.


The two halves of the upper are held together with two BOA Li2 dials. This top-of-the-line BOA system is easy to micro-adjust while riding and easily releases all tension when it comes time to slip the shoe off. Putting the shoe on, however, can be a little bit fussy, as the rear BOA cable readily snags on the front dial. Having the rear BOA dial mounted to the instep strap means that the strap flops around a bit while putting the shoes on, which is more annoying than inconvenient.

The older Shimano S-Phyre RC902 used plastic guides to route the...
The older Shimano S-Phyre RC902 used plastic guides to route the forward cable.
The updated RC903 instead uses cloth guides to route the forward...
The updated RC903 instead uses cloth guides to route the forward cable, and adds another criss-cross to distribute pressure more evenly.

Gone are the plastic guides for the front BOA system, replaced with cloth guides that don't impinge on the toe box at all. Re-routing the cable also added another criss-cross, spreading the force of the closure over a larger portion of the toe box, allowing for more adjustment in the toes. Want to cinch the shoe down for an all-out effort? Just turn that front dial a bit to all but eliminate movement in the toe box. Want to cruise the next 40 miles home nice and easy? Dial the BOA back and enjoy stability without the pressure points.

shimano s-phyre sh-rc903 - if sized correctly, the rc903 is just as stable and much more...
If sized correctly, the RC903 is just as stable and much more comfortable with the BOA system loosened, especially on more casual rides.
Credit: Erin Grant

Instead of having the two sides of the upper fold over each other, Shimano uses a tongue-less design on their shoes that allows for greater adjustability and helps spread forces from the BOA closure system more evenly across the top of the foot. The RC903 is also available in a wide version, which uses a wider carbon outsole, not just a higher volume upper. That said, it is still a performance-focused shoe with a narrow-fitting toe box. Even though this shoe is surprisingly adjustable for its last, there are other shoes in our lineup that will better accommodate higher volume feet.

shimano s-phyre sh-rc903 - the tongueless design that shimano uses on all of its shoes helps...
The tongueless design that Shimano uses on all of its shoes helps evenly distribute pressure across the top of your foot.
Credit: Arthur Richardson


Power Transfer


This is an area in which the RC903 truly excels. The carbon fiber outsole is one of the stiffest that we tested, the heel retention is tight, and the upper feels totally locked in. Shimano gives the RC903 their stiffest sole rating – a score of 12. Unfortunately, they don't say what that stiffness rating of '12' means in the real world. So we developed a sole deflection test to objectively rank outsole stiffness.


Our test involves bolting the shoe to a jig, setting up a linear deflection gauge, placing a heel block inside the shoe, clamping a U-bolt around the sole, and hanging a 25-pound weight from the U-bolt. The heel block locates the U-bolt over the ankle opening of the shoe, so that force is applied in the same plane as it would be by a foot. Measurements were taken three times, and the results were averaged to give us one sole deflection value.

The Shimano S-Phyre RC903 had the stiffest sole in our testing, deflecting only 1.39 millimeters.
Credit: Arthur Richardson

The RC903 sole deflected only 1.39 millimeters, less than many other shoes we tested. This sole stiffness is just as apparent out on the road, translating to a very secure connection to the pedals. While a sole this stiff pushes nearly every watt to the pedals, it also can cause some foot fatigue. We noticed the soles of our feet starting to ache after a number of hours of riding with the shoes snug. Loosening the closure can alleviate that feeling a bit, but it's still more noticeable than some of the softer shoes we tested.


Shimano also remodeled the heel cup on the RC903 with this update. They eliminated the rubber heel retention pads from the RC902 and lined the collar with a rubberized, synthetic fabric that extends down into the heel cup. The heel cup is very stiff, with padding in all the right places around the Achilles tendon to lock your heel in place. The result is an extremely secure fit – we never noticed our heels slipping during hard efforts or even while walking around. This fit encourages you to engage your hamstrings and pull through for a more even pedaling stroke. The additional heel support also seemed to help keep our knees aligned, reducing how much our feet would twist in the shoes.

The RC902 (front) uses a rubber strip and narrower neck than the...
The RC902 (front) uses a rubber strip and narrower neck than the RC900 (rear).
The RC903 forgoes the rubber patch from the RC902 and replaces it...
The RC903 forgoes the rubber patch from the RC902 and replaces it with a rubberized synthetic cover for maximum heel retention.

The revamped RC903 now uses a one-piece upper made from microfiber synthetic leather. While supple and foot-conforming, the upper doesn't stretch or flex during hard efforts, nor does it crumple or wrinkle when tightened down.

shimano s-phyre sh-rc903 - the plastic heel cup and padding around the collar really lock your...
The plastic heel cup and padding around the collar really lock your heel in place.
Credit: Adam Bridier

Durability


The S-Phyre RC903 has all of the right ingredients to make it a long-lasting shoe. Designers opted for durable materials, and the shoe incorporates replaceable parts in certain high-wear areas. The heel is fully enclosed in a plastic cap, the front part of the carbon outsole is surrounded by a plastic ring, and there is a raised toe pad that protects the front tip of the sole. Perhaps the only downside is that it might not look as sleek after all of those years of service.


The microfiber synthetic leather upper is tough and unlikely to tear from regular use while riding. However, the upper wraps fully around to meet itself under the sole, which exposes it to scrapes from walking around. The plastic heel cup also scratches easily, and the black color of the underlying plastic shows through the blue heel cup paint. Functionally, there aren't problems. But it's important to point out that the otherwise durable RC903 shows cosmetic damage more quickly than other shoes we tested.

shimano s-phyre sh-rc903 - the upper wraps around to cover the outsole, which inevitably gets...
The upper wraps around to cover the outsole, which inevitably gets beat up when you're walking around.
Credit: Arthur Richardson

High-use components like the BOA dials and heel pad are replaceable, which is very important for the longevity of a premium shoe like the RC903. The dials are also covered by BOA's lifetime guarantee – you can replace them at no charge, with only a few questions asked. If you'd rather avoid the questions, you can also purchase replacement dials, which are super easy to install. The same goes for the rubber heel pad, which is sure to wear out after years of starting and stopping and walking around at cafes. It's held in place by only one bolt, making it an easy fix.

shimano s-phyre sh-rc903 - the heel cup on the rc903 is also prone to cosmetic damage.
The heel cup on the RC903 is also prone to cosmetic damage.
Credit: Arthur Richardson

We wish that the RC903 featured a replaceable front toe pad, which is an area that wears down from pushing off to start riding. Not many brands offer this as a replaceable pad, so it's understandable that Shimano also does not. But it's a feature that we'd love to see them add to future shoes in the S-Phyre line.

shimano s-phyre sh-rc903 - even dedicated performance road shoes find themselves on off-road...
Even dedicated performance road shoes find themselves on off-road adventures occasionally.
Credit: Adam Bridier

Weight


As you would expect from a high-performance road cycling shoe, the RC903 is superlight, coming in at 16.72 ounces (474 grams per pair, or 237 grams per shoe) for a pair of EU size 42.5. Although it is still a lightweight shoe, the main goal of the RC903 is certainly not shaving grams.


The one-piece upper has very thin padding on the inner layer and mostly bonded connections between materials. The RC903 also does away with two plastic cable guides of the R902 and features a lighter outsole. There are lighter shoes on the market, but the RC903 still manages to include an external plastic heel cup and plenty of rubber protection on the outsole to ensure proper foot support and durability.

shimano s-phyre sh-rc903 - we weighed every shoe with their stock insole and no cleats or...
We weighed every shoe with their stock insole and no cleats or hardware.
Credit: Arthur Richardson

Should You Buy the Shimano S-Phyre SH-RC903?


The S-Phyre SH-RC903 is one of the stiffest and most performance-oriented road shoes out there. It provides unparalleled heel retention and power transfer, making it the perfect companion for riders looking to maximize their performance during hard efforts. The toe box is on the narrow side, but if that works for your foot, then it is just as well suited to all-day rides. We don't deny that it's expensive, but if you're looking for a premium cycling shoe that is built to last, the RC903 is worth the investment.

What Other Cycling Shoes Should You Consider?


If you're looking for a high-performance cycling shoe with a slightly more generous fit, the Specialized S-Works Torch is light, stiff, and more accommodating with a slightly wider toe box. If you're aiming to maximize performance but minimize expense, the Shimano SH-RC502 includes many of the same features as the RC903, but costs significantly less.

Arthur Richardson