Hands-on Gear Review
Compare winter boots for women ratings side-by-side >
Street Price: $220 | Compare prices at 2 resellers
Pros: Incredibly cozy and comfortable
Cons: Expensive, A little more techy looking
Best Uses: Light hiking, Around town, General winter use
We reviewed some amazing footwear in our women's winter boot review and the competition for Editor's Choice was steep. In the end, the UGG Australia Adirondack II Leather Boot came out on top, earning stellar marks in comfort and coziness as well as high scores in water resistance, warmth, and traction. The Adirondack II performed while shoveling snow during big storms and on light winter hikes, but our favorite thing about this boot was its sheepskin lining. This plush, touchable insulation lined the entire boot, including the removable insole.
These UGGs are also designed with a cuffable suede shaft: roll it down to expose a fluffy sheepskin cuff or roll it up for extra protection against the elements. We liked the built-in versatility that this feature offered as well as the unique style that it added. Although some women loved the look of these boots and would definitely wear them with casual outfits, others thought they were decidedly less stylish. If you like the look of these full-grain leather boots and are looking for high quality footwear that will perform outdoors, then the UGG Australia Adirondack IIs may be just what you're looking for. At $240, they are a bit of an investment – in fact, they were significantly more than any of its competitors – but the Adirondack IIs will to meet your winter boot needs for years to come.
Experiencing some price shock? For a more stylish boot, consider our $150 Top Pick Award winner, the Sorel Tofino. Our Best Buy Award winner, the Sorel Joan of Arctic is also a priced at $150; this stylish model provides more warmth than any of its competitors. Finally, the Vasque Pow Pow and the Ahnu Northridge boots are both affordable options for winter hiking. That said, don't let the $240 price tag on the Adirondack IIs scare you away. We put a lot of thought into why these deserve our Editor's Choice award. Read on to learn more!
Compare top rated competitors side-by-side >
OutdoorGearLab Editors' Hands-on Review
At first we loved the UGG Australia Adirondack IIs for their cozy sheepskin lining and comfortable, supportive footbed. Then we started using them outdoors and noticed that we could ford puddles, cruise over boulders, and employ the roll-up cuff for extra protection from the snow. A little more rugged looking than boots like our Top Pick Award winner, the Sorel Tofino or The North Face Janey II, the Adirondack IIs still feature such luxurious materials as buttery full-grain leather. In this article, we'll discuss all the reasons that we loved our Editor's Choice Award winner (and the few categories where it didn't quite meet our expectations).
We also wanted to take a moment here to discuss UGG Australia's approach to animal ethics. Many of the boots in this review have some type of leather, whether it is full-grain leather, suede, or nubuck; however, the UGG Australia Adirondack II Boot is the only piece that uses leather and sheepskin. Some consumers and animal rights activists are careful not to purchase products that contain animal byproducts like leather. If that is the case for you, we would like to direct you to boots like the Tecnica Moon Boot and the Columbia Minx Mid. On the other hand, some of us don't mind purchasing leather products, but we may get a little hesitant when manufacturers start talking about sheepskin.
If you feel this way, we've got you covered. We did some research and found out that UGG is owned by Deckers Outdoor Corporation. This company does not raise sheep itself, but it is committed to ethically sourcing sheepskin solely from farmers and organizations that are raising the animals for their meat. UGG only believes in using this material when it is a byproduct of the meat industry and never purchases sheepskin from organizations that raise animals solely for their pelts. Additionally, UGG has openly released statements denouncing the inhumane practice of mulesing. The fur for this specific boot comes exclusively from Australia, the European Union, or the United States. We really appreciate UGG's commitment to animal ethics and the transparency that Deckers demonstrates by posting its policies on its website.
The UGG Adirondack II is lined with 17 millimeters of table grade sheepskin, which did a fairly good job of keeping our toes warm and cozy. In our final warmth tests, we stood still for five minutes in 4-degree temperatures with feet buried in the snow. After comparing every piece, we decided to give the UGG Adirondack IIs a seven in our warmth metric. We found that the Vibram sole provided plenty of insulation along the bottom of the boot but we noticed that cold slowly started permeating the toe box.
Although our Editor's Choice winner was not the warmest boot that we tested, it's important to remember that it was also one of the shorter pieces in the review. Even with its cuff rolled up, this model was shorter than six of its competitors, which makes surprisingly difference in calf and foot warmth. That said, then when we started moving in the UGG Adirondack IIs, even in single digit temperatures, our feet quickly warmed up. These boots are also fairly breathable, which keeps your feet from sweating profusely and then getting cold from the moisture.
Comfort & Coziness
Slipping into the UGG Adirondack II Boot for the first time felt like what you would imagine putting your foot into a cloud shoe might feel like if clouds were made of super plush, fluffy sheepskin. Unlike many of the boots in this review that have faux fur cuffs that reach an inch or two down into the boot, the sheepskin lining on the Adirondack II continues throughout the entire shoe. UGG has even fitted the Adirondack II with a removable insole that is coated in sheepskin. Although we noticed that the sheepskin around the footbed started to become a little compressed through our testing process, it still feels super cozy against the foot (with or without socks!) and continues to provide warmth.
Not only is the lining of this boot amazingly touchable, the footbed is extremely comfortable and supportive. The Adirondack II doesn't provide quite as much ankle support as the Vasque Pow Pow UltraDry, but it provides significantly more than boots like the Columbia Minx Slip-On. As we mentioned above, this boot is also relatively breathable. This not only plays a role in warmth, but also in comfort, as very few people we know think that slimy, sweaty feet are very comfortable. Finally, we found this boot to be cozy whether we wore it with the cuff rolled up or down.
With their full-grain leather uppers and waterproof rubber outsoles, the UGG Adirondack IIs are ready to take on rain, snow, and slush in style. These boots will keep your feet dry in puddles up to 5.5 inches deep and its cuff does a great job of keeping out snow. When you wear these boots with the cuffs rolled up, they provide extra protection from deep snow on the backs and sides; however, the tongue doesn't come up flush with the top of the rolled-up cuff, so there is a little gap in the front where deeper snow could potentially get you wet. The Adirondack IIs are also fitted with mud guards around the front of the toes and at the heel.
Style & Fit
The UGG Australia Adirondack II Boot – Leather scored right on par in style with such boots as the Sorel Tivoli and the Ahnu Womens Northridge. We polled more than a dozen women ranging in age from 20 to 60 and their opinions averaged out to 6.1 out of 10. The Adirondack II is definitely a more techy looking boot, but we like to think of it as "rugged-chic." This boot's full-grain leather toe box and upper are rich and buttery, especially in the "Otter" color that we reviewed. While one of our testers constantly wore the UGG Adirondack IIs with the sheepskin cuff rolled down, another almost exclusively wore it rolled up. We liked this versatile feature not only from a practicality perspective, but also from a style perspective. The cuff just gives you more options to switch things up. The one thing that we didn't love about wearing the cuff rolled up was that the tongue isn't flush with the top lip of the boot, which isn't the most natural look.
The roll-down sheepskin cuff is certainly not everyone's style, but we liked the interest that it added, as well as its versatility. The techiest aspect of the Adirondack II Boot is definitely its abrasion-resistant mud guard that comes up around the front of the toe box and lines the back of the heel. Moreover, the boot's Vibram sole wraps up just a bit in front of the toes to add a little extra protection. If you don't mind the techy look and are seeking a boot that is even more geared to outdoor performance and winter hiking, be sure to check out the Vasque Pow Pow UltraDry boots. On the other hand, if you want a more stylish boot, our Top Pick award winner, the Sorel Tofino Herringbone might be right up your alley.
UGG Australia fitted the Adirondack IIs with a Vibram sole for extra traction and grip. These outsoles have horizontal treads that aren't quite as deep as those on the Ahnu Northridge or Vasque Pow Pow boots. Although the Adirondack IIs certainly perform on slick snowy surfaces, they aren't quite as grippy as these other winter hikers. We did, however, like that the soles on the UGG model were not quite as thick as those on the Vasques. The soles on both of these boots wrap up slightly over the tip of the toe box, adding a bit of extra traction where it matters most.
Ease to Take On & Off
Overall, these boots were easy to pull on and kick off, but the laces cost them a few points in this category. After just a few weeks of use, the sheath on the Adirondack II's laces started to bunch up. This made them increasingly difficult to pull through the lace eyes. Additionally, the design of the roll down cuff complicates the laces just a bit more. However, we found that the continuous sheepskin lining almost made the interior feel slick, making them slip on and off smoothly. The boots are also fitted with a back pull tab to help ease the process.
We liked the UGG Australia Adirondack II leather boots for everything from light hiking to around town errands. We biked all around Boulder in these beautiful boots (and found they had great traction on our bike pedals). They were also great for exploring the outdoors or shoveling the sidewalk in up to nine inches of snow (with the cuffs rolled up). Although they weren't the warmest, if you are moving, these woolly sheepskin boots will keep you plenty warm.
In the case of the UGG Adirondack IIs, you get what you pay for. These boots won our Editor's Choice because they are incredibly cozy and comfortable and performed highly in such categories as warmth, traction, and water resistance; however, they were also the most expensive models in our review. The UGG Adirondack IIs ring up at $240, which is almost $100 more than our Best Buy and Top Pick Award winners, the Sorel Joan of Arctic and the Sorel Tofino. It's also double the cost of boots like the Sorel Women's Tivoli.
The first thing to consider when deciding whether or not to purchase this winter boot is whether or not you like its "rugged-chic" look. We think the leather on this boot is beautifully crafted and we loved the fluffy roll down cuff, but this look does not suit everyone. If this boot is your style and you are seeking a piece that will meet needs that vary from light hiking to outdoor winter chores and errands around town, then these boots are absolutely worth the money, especially because you might not want to ever want to take them off. Seriously. After trying out the Adirondack IIs, our testers now want sheepskin lining in all their footwear. Moreover, we have known friends and family to get years and years of use out of their UGG boots. On the other hand, if you are looking more for a hiking specific winter boot and don't mind a rugged look, then the Vasque Pow Pow is a great deal at only $150.
These ultra-plush boots may just change your whole perspective on winter. With their beautiful leather uppers and touchable sheepskin lining, the UGG Adirondack IIs are a treat to wear. And better yet, they offer high outdoor performance in categories like water resistance and traction. Although they are not ideal for women who live in areas that get feet upon feet of snow, they can handle drifts up to nine inches deep and puddles up to 5.5 inches deep. Whether you opt to leave the cuff rolled down or decide to roll it up to increase warmth and snow protection, our Editor's Choice winner will leave you feeling glad that winter has finally arrived.
Our Editor's Choice winner comes in several other versions: the Adirondack II Tall, $325, and the Women's Adirondack Tweed.
— Amanda Fenn
Compare this product side-by-side to top competitors >
OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews
Most recent review: December 9, 2013
Where's the Best Price?
*Help support OutdoorGearLab. If you click on one of the seller links and make a purchase, a portion of the sale helps support this site
Related Best-in-Class Review
Helpful Buying Tips
Get More OutdoorGearLab
Follow us on Twitter, be a fan on Facebook!
Related Gear Reviews
Recent Best-in-Class Reviews