The Best Ski Jacket Review

We scoped out the best of the best in men’s insulated ski and snowboard jackets, put them through the paces on the resort, and pushed their limits in the backcountry. Our expert skiing testers slammed through foul weather and slid on rock-hard steep descents.

The products we reviewed are each excellent pieces of technical outerwear. Some perform better than others, and each brings its own style to the market. Manufacturers make lofty claims and come from a variety of backgrounds. We used our testing to score them in warmth, weather resistance and ventilation. We carefully considered each coat’s style, comfort, and features. In the end we had some favorites, and identified those that may appeal to a more select audience.

To learn about what we feel are the important consideration when purchasing an insulated option, read our Buying Advice article, which details all the notable factors.
You might also be interested in our Best Ski Jacket for Women review.

Read the full review below >

Review by: Jediah Porter ⋅ Review Editor, OutdoorGearLab February 25, 2014

Top Ranked Ski Jackets - Men's Displaying 1 - 5 of 12 << Previous | View All | Next >>
Our Ranking #1 #2 #3 #4 #5
Product Name
Patagonia Primo Down Jacket
Patagonia Primo Down Jacket
Read the Review
Video video review
The North Face Vortex Triclimate
The North Face Vortex Triclimate
Read the Review
Video video review
Arc'teryx Macai
Arc'teryx Macai
Read the Review
Flylow BA Puffy
Flylow BA Puffy
Read the Review
Video video review
Columbia Whirlibird Interchange 3-in-1
Columbia Whirlibird Interchange 3-in-1
Read the Review
Video video review
Editors' Awards  Editors' Choice Award  Best Buy Award       
Street Price Varies $324 - $649
Compare at 5 sellers
Varies $174 - $294
Compare at 2 sellers
$850Varies $145 - $188
Compare at 3 sellers
$140
Compare at 1 sellers
Overall Score 
100
0
90
100
0
86
100
0
82
100
0
82
100
0
80
Editors' Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
100% recommend it (2/2)
Be the first to rate itBe the first to rate itBe the first to rate it
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
1 rating
Pros Down insulated. Proven shell technology. Fits and protects very well.Versatile, warm, with neutral stylingVery warm and very well made.Versatile styling. Excellent hood. Great ventilation.Very warm. Modular design. Understated style, bold colors.
Cons Uninsulated “hand-warmer” pockets. Fiddly hood toggles.Minor construction inadequaciesExpensive, stains easilyModerately insulating. Simple construction and detailing.Bulky feeling. Limited wind and water protection.
Best Uses Resort skiing and riding, for a long time.Season-long ski area wearBurly conditions skiing.Resort skiing, around-town wear.Resort skiing for the occasional user. Resort-town visits.
Date Reviewed Feb 25, 2014Feb 25, 2014Feb 25, 2014Feb 25, 2014Feb 25, 2014
Weighted Scores Patagonia Primo Down Jacket The North Face Vortex Triclimate Arc'teryx Macai Flylow BA Puffy Columbia Whirlibird Interchange 3-in-1
Warmth - 25%
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
7
10
0
10
Ventilation - 15%
10
0
9
10
0
10
10
0
6
10
0
9
10
0
10
Weather Resistance - 20%
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
8
Ski Features - 5%
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
8
Fit Comfort - 20%
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
4
Style - 15%
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
7
10
0
10
10
0
8
Product Specs Patagonia Primo Down Jacket The North Face Vortex Triclimate Arc'teryx Macai Flylow BA Puffy Columbia Whirlibird Interchange 3-in-1
Main Fabric 2-layer 4.3-oz 70-denier 100% recycled nylon GORE-TEX® HyVent® 160g/m Nylon. N40r-X GORE-TEX® Fabric Two-layer Intuitive Fabric Omni-Tech waterproof/breathable
Insulation 700 fill power down (unknown amount) 100g Heatseeker synthetic fil 60g Coreloft and 750 fill power down (unknown amount of down) Thinsulate (unknown amount) 80g Polyester fill
Waterproofing Gore Tex HyVent® Gore Tex Two-layer Intuitive Fabric Omni Tech
Unique Features recco
Weight 2 lbs 5 oz 2 lbs 14 oz 2 lbs 0 oz 2 lbs 6 oz 3 lbs 2 oz
# of Pockets 6 3 inner, 6 outer 2 inner, 4 outer 9 3 inner, 6 outer
Hood Option? non-removable removable non-removable non-removable removable
Pit Zips? yes, long and work in both directions Yes, in outer layer only Yes, long, mesh-backed and work in just one direction yes, long and work both directions yes, in outer layer only
Cuff construction gusseted velcro gusseted velcro on outer, lycra piping on inner gusseted velcro gusseted velcro gusseted velcro on outer, lycra piping on inner
Ski Features zip off powder skirt, pass keeper, straps to attach to Patagonia Pants Powder skirt. removable powder skirt and Recco reflector removable powder skirt, straps to attach to Flylow pants fixed powder skirt on outer jacket

OutdoorGearLab Editors' Hands-on Review


  • Review Photos
  • Editors' Choice Winners
  • All Reviewed Products
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Arc'teryx Modon
$699
100
0
75
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Arc'teryx Macai
$850
100
0
82
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Flylow BA Puffy
$290
100
0
82
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Armada Nelson
$350
100
0
70
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Helly Hansen Enigma
$700
100
0
74
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Spyder Sentinel
$275
100
0
62
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Spyder Titan
$400
100
0
71
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Burton AK Stagger
$380
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Marmot Sidehill Component
$325
100
0
66
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Selecting the Right Product
Wading through the incredibly diverse field of ski outerwear can be a trying task. Fear not, as we have selected twelve of the best ski jackets made. Each piece we review is excellent, and every skier or snowboarder will find something here for him. Our field reflects the entire spectrum, from budget options that work just as well commuting to the office on a blustery day as they do on your favorite ski resort, to purpose-built, high-end offerings that will protect and warm the most discerning riders in the most trying conditions. Choose the right one for you, and burly conditions on serious peaks will seem downright pedestrian. Of course, these will protect in less gnarly weather as well. All are comfortable enough for all-day wear and our selection represents a broad cross-section of fashion tastes. From youthful skater-inspired styles like the Armada Nelson to the subdued and neutral design of the Arc Teryx Modon, there is a parka here for you. For a step-by-step guide to navigating the entire ski jacket market, please consult our comprehensive Buying Advice article, linked above. If, however, you are looking to choose from the OutdoorGearLab selection of skiing outerwear, read on.

Types of Ski Jackets
This review concentrates on ski-specific jackets. Many will also serve other purposes, but their primary function is as ski resort upper body protection. Ski area specific designs are characterized by durable and thick shell fabrics and integrated (though sometimes removable) insulation. Within the overall ski outerwear category are three primary divisions. Here we've reviewed contenders in the first two, and will refer you to other OutdoorGearLab reviews for the final.

Modular "3-in-1"
These are the most versatile. Like our Best Buy winning The North Face Vortex Triclimate, these are perfect for the skier looking for multi-function, customizable protection on a budget. Each entry in this category is comprised of an insulating liner, either fleece or synthetic "puff" fill, and a shell. The two pieces can be worn separately, or zipped and snapped together for an easily donned and doffed cold-weather jacket. Two primary disadvantages stand out. In their combined configuration, are inherently more restrictive and less comfortable than one-piece ones of a similar warmth. And, for reasons unknown to us, the modular jackets on the market are generally made of at least slightly lower quality materials. If you want this sort of function with high-end down insulation and the best shell fabrics on the market, you will find precious few options.

Insulated Shells
The majority of products in our review fall into this category. The amount and type of insulation may vary, and the shell fabrics represent a wide spectrum of quality and durability. However, all are purpose built for riding chairlifts up and sliding down on snow. Price, fit, quality, style, and weather protection vary across the selection. Rest assured that there is something in this category for everyone.

Layering Options
Some people choose to ride the ski resort with a combination of other types of clothing. Many will choose from a plethora of hard- or soft-shell jackets to block precipitation and wind. They'll insulate beneath that shell with fleece, synthetic insulation, or down pieces. Finally, many climbing and hiking inspired winter jackets can be pressed into service for ski area usage.

Criteria for Evaluation

Warmth
Skiing and snowboarding take place in cold environments. An insulated jacket, built specifically for resort riding, is the first line of defense against that cold climate. Wearing all these, back to back, in stormy weather allowed us to make fairly accurate assessments of their relative warmth. The Helly Hansen Enigma, Arc'teryx Macai, Columbia Whirlibird Interchange 3-in-1, and the Patagonia Primo Down had high insulating values virtually indistinguishable from one another. On the other end of the spectrum, the Arc'teryx Modon and Spyder Sentinel offer lightly insulated options for the warm-blooded or temperate-climate enthusiast.

Infrared photos to show the difference in insulation. The dark colors ...
Infrared photos to show the difference in insulation. The dark colors indicate cooler temperature and therefore warmer insulation. The top right shows a thinner insulation while the bottom right shows a different insulation in the sleeves.
Credit: Jessica Haist

Ventilation
Not all cold environments are created equal. Nor does a single ski day involve uniform conditions. Being able to adapt your insulation to better match your surroundings and exertion is key to resort comfort. A rider will sit, sedentary, for long periods of time. Lift lines and lift rides expose a still skier or boarder to all the weather with little opportunity for generating body heat through exertion. And then, polar opposite to the lift ride, the rider will drop into a few minutes of high output athletic activity. Additionally, the day can heat up or cool down, and one day may be very different from the last. Traveling to new mountain ranges is a primary driver of the passionate skier. All these changes require adaptable gear. Ventilation performance is crucial for adaptation, both in the short term of one run to the next, and long term of one day, week, season, or range to the next. The Columbia Whirlibird, Marmot Sidehill Component and The North Face Vortex Triclimate offer modular, “3-in-1” designs that are particularly well suited to ventilation and adaptation. These each come in one beefy, insulated and weatherproof package. In usage the inner liner of each can be unzipped and unbuttoned to be worn alone. The shell of each can also be worn on its own. That gives you two parts, worn together or each individually. Hence the “3-in-1” descriptor. They earned our highest scores for ventilation. The option to mix and match the layers does indeed take some time, but it gives far better climate control than any of the other ones in our test. If it is crucial to you that you can vent or seal up in a matter of seconds, look for one with long (longer than a foot or so), non-mesh -backed pit-zips with multiple zipper pulls. The Flylow BA Puffy has the best venting of any non-modular models in our test.

Click to enlarge
Jason, Mike and Jed on Chair 5, Mammoth Mountain. Testing The North Face, Burton, and Helly Hansen in these stormy conditions highlighted vast differences.
Credit: Jessica Haist

Weather Resistance
Weather resistance is a function of three things, in declining order of importance: construction, waterproof laminate, and durable water repellent coating (DWR). For routine resort use, construction and design will be the primary force influencing the degree of wind and precipitation protection the wearer receives. The jacket needs to be constructed of good waterproof and breathable fabric and coated with an effective DWR, but design truly differentiates. We discuss mainly water resistance. However, anything that resists water will resist wind and snow as well.

Click to enlarge
Stormy conditions on Mammoth Mountain. Helly Hansen brings a long pedigree of weatherproof clothing to the Enigma. Used properly (ie. remember to batten down the numerous zippers) the Enigma keeps out the gnarliest weather.
Credit: Jed Porter

Manufacturers and sales personnel will make a big deal of the technology in the shell fabric laminates. Each fabric or jacket manufacturer uses its own qualifiers to describe the weather resistance of its offering. Gore-Tex, a well-established brand manufacturing raw materials and licensing its use to many clothing companies, describes its fabrics and company-certified garments as “Guaranteed to Keep You Dry”. This claim implies both protection from atmospheric solid and liquid water, and transmission of body-generated water vapor. Other manufacturers use a pair of 5-digit numbers to describe both waterproofness and breathability. (“10,000/10,000”. Or, alternately, further abbreviated “10k/10k”) The first number in the pair describes waterproofing. The number describes the number of millimeters of water the fabric can withstand over a 24 hour period. That’s all in theory, in perfect conditions. The second number describes breathability, in grams of water vapor that can pass through a square meter of fabric in a 24 hour period. Now, what does all that mean in real life? First of all, these numbers and claims are assigned by the manufacturer. Little to no independent qualitative testing is performed. Secondly, basically all fabrics available on the market (certainly all in our tests) are good to claimed 10k/10k performance. And that is plenty. All this is interesting academic information, but we can move on now, as all the jackets in our test are made of high performing fabrics.

Each company does it differently, but at some point in the process of construction the manufacturer coats the outside of the fabric with a DWR. This is what makes water “bead up” on the surface of a garment. The above described waterproof, breathable coatings or laminates are inside of the shell fabric. In order to keep the outer fabric dry (and therefore breathable - soaked fabric does not breathe) it is treated with a somewhat inappropriately named DWR. In actual usage, the DWR is often the least durable part of the entire jacket. We tested the durability in our sprinkler test. While soaking the fabric, simulating rain or wet snow or both, we rubbed the forearm of every one. This simulates the reality of actual usage. Arms rub against the body, bodies rub against the snow, chair lifts rub against backs and shoulders. Patagonia garments, the Editors' Choice winning Primo Down and Patagonia Rubicon Rider have the best DWR in our test. The Spyder Titan and Spyder Sentinel and Burton AK Stagger all wet out in this test. In each case, however, the truly waterproof part is protected and hidden by the shell fabric.

As noted, far more important is design. All the contenders in our test are made of waterproof, breathable fabric. Weather resistance performance is therefore a function of construction and fit, with durable water repellent playing a role as well. We looked for thoughtfully designed hoods, high stiff collars, effective cuffs (with inner secondary cuffs a bonus), protected zippers, and long sleeves and hems.

Click to enlarge
Helmet and hood compatibility. From L-R and top to bottom: Armada, Helly Hansen, Columbia, Marmot, The North Face, Patagonia Rubicon, Flylow, Spyder Sentinel, Patagonia Primo, Spyder Titan, Arcteryx Macai, Arcteryx Modon.
Credit: Jediah Porter and Jessica Haist
]

Weather resistance and warmth often come from the same features. Jackets that came out on top in our overall scores were ones that performed best in weather resistance and warmth.

Ski Features
A handful of potential niceties can really augment a well-designed jacket. We looked for plentiful pockets, ski pass clips, integrated goggle wipes, and systems to join jackets and pants into an integrated package. The top scoring jackets in this category were the Helly Hansen Enigma and the Marmot Sidehill Component.

Fit/Comfort
Fit is king. We go to the mountains to feel good. We want to feel good in our clothes. Fit and comfort, like weather resistance, is a function of both fabric and construction. Carefully constructed garments fit better. However, fit will vary from one person to another. Second only to style, fit and comfort is a very subjective measure. We tested on a variety of athletic body shapes. Primary testing, however, was done by thin, size medium men. All the jackets we tested were marketed as size medium by their manufacturers. The Helly Hansen Enigma and Patagonia Rubicon Rider earned high scores in fit and comfort, coming to that performance from two very different directions. The Enigma is constructed with what seems like 15 different soft and flexible fabrics. Virtually every part stretches and hugs the body. Visible bulk mainly comes from the insulation. The Rubicon Rider is far more loose in fit, with a brilliant hood and sleeve design that virtually disappears on the wearer. None of the other jackets really stood out for fit, one way or another. Each will fit someone “like a glove”. And every jacket will have its limitations on someone.

Click to enlarge
L-R and Top to Bottom: Marmot, The North Face, Spyder Titan, Patagonia Primo, Flylow, Spyder Sentinel, Patagonia Rubicon, Columbia, Arc Teryx Macai, Arc Teryx Modon, Armada, Helly Hansen.
Credit: Jediah Porter and Jessica Haist

Style
Style is highly subjective. Our test team of dirtbag ski bums, former fashion students, and cosmopolitan mountain town refugees brought a whole range of experiences and opinions to the scores. Your opinion may vary even further still. In our ratings we tried to evaluate each piece in context. Of course, we considered fit, colors, and versatility. What statement does this jacket make? Can a wearer “pull it off” in town and on the hill? Will it look out of place in Instagram backcountry photos? Out of place on a snowboard, or on skis? We also considered branding, intended use, target demographic, and resort fashion trends over time. Nonetheless, you may choose to throw our assessments of style completely out the window. And we are fine with that.

Some of the jackets we evaluated make strong visual statements. The Spyder Titan shouts “I’m a skier”, the Armada Nelson swaggers to the half pipe, the Columbia Whirlibird Jacket says “I go to the mountains, but don’t take myself too seriously.” Others such as the Patagonia Primo Down, Helly Hansen Enigma, and The North Face Vortex Triclimate have more understated, neutral looks that blend in on the hill and around town without being too conspicuous. The Flylow BA Puffy is the only jacket that received a random compliment in the lift-line during testing, and is the most appropriate for someone looking for a layer to wear from first chair to last call.

Editors' Choice: Patagonia Primo Down
Click to enlarge
Jed Porter on Esha Peak in the Sierra backcountry. Light to carry, well vented, protective and warm, the Primo Down is the best jacket in our test for crossing over to backcountry usage.
Credit: Andy Lewicky

We awarded our Editors' Choice award to the Patagonia Primo Down jacket. The Primo Down delivers high performance in all categories, and crushes the field in warmth per weight and durability. Down insulation is the primary distinguishing characteristic of the Primo Down. Properly protected from moisture, and the Primo Down’s Gore-Tex shell does that, goose down is an unequalled insulator. Anecdotal and formalized testing with other garments over the long term indicates that down insulation can keep its r-value high for up to 10 times as long as similar synthetic insulated pieces. Interestingly, the Primo Down did not score at the top of any one of our categories. However, solid performance across the board and anticipated durability tip the balance solidly in its favor.

Top Pick Award for Light Insulation: Arc'teryx Modon
Click to enlarge
Opening day, '13-'14 season, on June Mountain. The Arc Teryx Modon, for its comfortable fit and bomber wind protection, earns instant respect among testers.
Credit: Jediah Porter

Our Top Pick in this test is an unlikely standout. The Arc'teryx Modon only really wowed our testers with its fit and windproofness. However, elsewhere in the test, not unlike our Editors' Choice, the Modon delivered consistent results. The true value of the Modon comes in its purpose-built design. This is a very lightly insulated shell jacket. The shell fabric keeps out the gnarliest of wet mountain weather, while the insulation dampens the chill and helps the breathable fabric do its job.

Best Buy Award: The North Face Vortex Triclimate
Click to enlarge
Neutral styling in the Vortex mellows out the more aggressive and colorful pants and helmet. Test editor Jediah Porter dressed up like a bag of Skittles.
Credit: Howie Schwartz

Right off the bat it was clear that our Best Buy award would go to one of the “3-in-1” style jackets. Each tested jacket in that style is priced near the low end of our selection and provides unmatched versatility. While the Columbia Whirlibird Interchange 3-in-1 offers slightly greater warmth than the award winner, The North Face Vortex Triclimate is much more comfortable and more visually pleasing for this price point and target demographic.

Check out all of our favorites in one place on our Ski and Snowboard Gear Dream List.

Jediah Porter
Buying Advice
How we Test
Helpful Buying Tips
How to Choose a Ski Jacket - Click for details
 How to Choose a Ski Jacket

by Jediah Porter
Get More OutdoorGearLab
Follow us on Twitter, be a fan on Facebook!
Subscribe to our Newsletter
Recent Editor's Award Winners