< Go to Hardshell Jackets

Hands-on Gear Review

Patagonia M10 Review


Hardshell Jacket

Click to enlarge
  • Currently 3.5/5
Overall avg rating 3.5 of 5 based on 2 reviews. Most recent review: July 29, 2016
Price:   $379 List
Pros:  Extremely light, packs very small, versatile, affordable
Cons:  Large fit, crinkly and noisy, only one hood drawcord, not very weather protective
Manufacturer:   Patagonia

Overview

The Patagonia M10 jacket is our favorite hardshell for backpacking and the lightest jacket that we tested. At $379 it is also one of the more affordable hardshell jackets in our review, although by no means the cheapest. Our tests show that this jacket is more durable and more versatile than other light shells and nearly as tough as jackets that weigh twice as much. Advanced fabrics and streamlined features make the M10 fantastically versatile; it's small and light enough to accompany you anywhere and it is one of the most comfortable jackets we tested.

For 2015-16 the M10 remains virtually unchanged from the previous year, except for color options. Though the Patagonia M10 is fantastic, our testers prefer the Arc'teryx Alpha FL (4 oz. heavier) for alpine and ice climbing and backcountry skiing because of its more ergonomic fit, larger chest pocket, better aesthetics, and astonishing durability. For many people, and backpackers specifically, the M10 could be the best hardshell due to its extraordinary light weight and tiny packed size. It does come with a laundry list of limitations, however, and thus is only recommended for someone who needs a very specific type of jacket.

RELATED: Our complete review of hardshell jackets

Compare Side-by-Side

Compare all Hardshell Jackets >

Analysis and Hands-on Test Findings

Review by:
Andy Wellman
Senior Review Editor
OutdoorGearLab

Last Updated:
Wednesday

As we went live with this review, Patagonia released a new version of the M10. On the surface, it looks like there are a couple of differences, including two additional hand pockets and an extra ounce of weight. It's also more expensive, ringing up at $400 vs. $380.

Hands-On Review


The Patagonia M10 is a lightweight hardshell that is designed to do everything, but is best used as an emergency shell. It uses Patagonia's proprietary three-layer H2NO performance standard membrane that is simultaneously thin, breathable, waterproof, and stretchy. It is a minimalist jacket with a set of features designed to save weight at all costs. Sonically welded seams mean there is literally no stitching in the main body construction, which makes it more abrasion resistant, durable, and lighter. Patagonia considers this to be one of their top-of-the-line products for fast and light alpine climbing. However, we by no means think this is the best fast and light option in this review.

Performance Comparison


Click to enlarge
The M10 did a good job as an outer layer on this day, but it was pretty much totally clear, if a bit cold. We found that in our tests that the M10 offered subpar weather protection overall, and so wouldn't be our first choice in a rain storm.

Weather Protection


Click to enlarge
The hood of this jacket was perhaps the smallest of any that we tried, and even without a helmet on here in the shower, we had water pour off it and down the neck, not what you want for weather protection from such an expensive garment.
What this jacket gives you with extreme light weight, it gives up in weather protection. While it did an adequate job as long as it wasn't pouring rain, the reality is that we found it to be one of the least protective hardshells that we tried. Many of its protection flaws have to do with minimalist features designed to save weight. Our biggest complaint is that the hood has only one adjustment point, in the rear of the head, and this does not adequately allow for cinching down around the face if you are not wearing a helmet. Even if you are wearing a helmet, the design of the hood is faulty, something we discovered in our shower test. The brim of the hood is much too small, and the single cinch point means that we couldn't tighten the hood around our face well enough to keep water from pouring off the hood and down the collar, soaking us inside the jacket. In last year's testing we found that the DWR coating wore off very quickly compared to other jackets (especially the Westcomb Shift LT), causing the fabric to wet out in spots after only a few uses. However, this year we found that to be less of a problem, although we aren't sure if Patagonia changed their DWR application, or whether our testing was of a different variety. Regardless, with the drastic flaws we found with the hood and collar, we only gave the M10 a 4 out of 10 for weather protection.

Weight


At 8.8 ounces for a size large jacket, no other jacket was lighter than the M10. Due to what we find to be odd sizing in all of Patagonia's garments, we ordered ourselves a size medium this year, and found that it weighs only 8.1 ounces. Only the Marmot Nano AS packed down into a neat little package anywhere close to as small as the M10. In order to pack the M10 down, you can stuff the entire jacket into its chest pocket; there is also a reinforced clip-in loop for help storing it. These features made the M10 our favorite choice for backpacking and we gave it a 10 out of possible 10 points.

Click to enlarge
The Alpha FL in its stuff sack on the left and the Patagonia M10 stuffed into its inside out chest pocket on right. They are about the same size, although the M10 weighs about 3 ounces less.

Mobility & Fit


This was clearly one of the most mobile jackets in our tests, receiving an 8 out of 10. The nylon face fabric is highly stretchable ripstop that moves with you as you move. We loved the stretchy fabric and the fit of the hood while wearing a helmet. The hood gripped the helmet perfectly and the entire hood opening turned with our head and face, as opposed to the storm hood on the Arc'teryx Theta AR, that doesn't grip the head as well and instead allows for movement inside the hood. The M10's sleeves were plenty long enough for swinging ice tools overhead, a major bonus for use while climbing, and not a feature present in all jackets. (In fact, short sleeves was one of our many complaints about the REI Shuksan II).

Click to enlarge
Our size medium was trim and fit us well, although we found the hem line to be a bit short. Last year we tested a size large of this exact jacket and found it too large for comfort. As you can see here, it shave weight it has only one chest pocket, like the other fast and light style of jackets.

While the M10 is very mobile and supple, one thing that bothered us was the fit of the jacket. Last year we ordered a size large, exactly like every other jacket we tested, but found it to be boxy and quite large. Our head tester almost always wears a men's large, but this large was just too big. This year we opted for a size medium, and enjoyed the fit better, although we still wished it was trimmer in the chest, and we felt like the hem was just an inch or two short for optimal coverage. Regardless, if you have a frame that often lands you on the edge of sizes, we would recommend sizing down in Patagonia garments.

We recommend sizing down when ordering this jacket. Our size large tester found a better fit in a size medium.

Click to enlarge
The hem rode up a bit when stretching our arms overhead, although the sleeves were still long enough. Getting a size large may have helped, but then we found the jacket to simply be far too baggy.

Breathability


Similar to the other lightweight alpine climbing jackets we tested, like the Arc'teryx Alpha FL or Westcomb Shift LT, the Patagonia M10 eschews any sort of pit zips or extra venting in the name of saving weight. If the H2NO standard membrane breathed better, then this would work out OK. But in our treadmill test we found the M10 to be our obvious lowest performer. Not only did we feel the absolute hottest while running in this jacket, but we found noticeable moisture built up on the inside of the jacket at both the neck and wrists. For this reason we only awarded it 5 out of a possible 10 points.

Click to enlarge
The interior layer that covers the membrane in the M10. While Patagonia does not disclose what the membrane in this jacket is actually made of, we found it to be the least breathable of all the jackets in the treadmill test.

With that said, it would be unfair of us to not point out that our treadmill test provided only subjective test results, and there was no way to substantiate what we felt with numbers or concrete data. For that reason we didn't give out high scores for this category, and also didn't penalize the M10 too much. It is possible that lengthening the time spent running in each model or other similar changes would have allowed this jacket to breathe better - we aren't sure. So within the context of our testing, we stand behind the fact that the M10 seemed to breathe the least, but take our results with a grain of salt.

Features


This shell has the same set of features as our other favorite lightweight alpine climbing jackets: a helmet compatible hood, water tight zippers, single chest pocket, Velcro wrist closures, and a waistline draw cord. However, we feel that other jackets' features are a bit more refined and function a bit better. The M10 has only one hood adjustment point, and we wish it had three. We do love how the entire jacket stuffs into its own pocket, but we wish that the buckles on the draw cords were a little larger or easier to manipulate with gloves. Like the Arc'teryx Alpha FL, it features only a single chest pocket, but we found it to be a bit small for all of the things you would like to fit in there. In short, it doesn't have nearly the amount of cool features as the Outdoor Research Axiom or the Mountain Hardwear Torsun, but then again it wasn't designed to.

Click to enlarge
The wrist enclosures on this jacket are large swatches of velcro that bonded well to each other and worked well. Some jackets used much smaller pieces of velcro, that obviously didn't work as well.

Click to enlarge
Like the other Patagonia jacket we tested for this review, this one uses only a single pull cord for tightening the enclosure on the hood in a system that we thought was pretty ineffective compared to all the others.

Best Applications


This is the lightest of the fast and light hardshells in this review, and in our opinion, it is best used as a back-up layer when you don't really want to carry it but feel like you should just in case. It is a good climbing shell in dryer climates. Additionally, its small packed size and light weight make it a good option for backpacking. With its poor grades in weather protection and breathability, we wouldn't recommend this shell to people that know they are going to encounter rough winter conditions or lots of rain.

Click to enlarge
The headwaters of the Animas River, deep in the heart of the San Juan Mountains, locked in winter. With the road buried under snow, this area turns into a virtual wilderness, perfect for alpine climbing adventures that feel like they are in a much bigger range.

Value


For only $379 a brand new M10 can be yours! Given what we feel is a limited range of application, we are not sure you should invest this much money in this jacket. While it is one of the more affordable ones we tested, for only a tiny bit more you can purchase the Editors' Choice winning Arc'teryx Alpha FL, which is a far more solid alpine-worthy hardshell.

Conclusion


The Patagonia M10 is an extremely lightweight and minimalist hardshell that is ideal for just-in-case or relatively fairweather use. Despite our reservations, it remains a highly versatile piece of gear that has been used by leading alpinists on crazy missions all over the world, so don't let us tell you what can or can't be done with it. Compared to many of the jackets in this review it is pretty affordable and is backed by Patagonia's Ironclad Guarantee.

Click to enlarge
The M10 is light enough that you'll hardly feel it.

Other Versions


Click to enlarge
Women's M10 Jacket
  • Women's specific cut
  • Lightest H2No jacket
  • Well made, performance raincoat with Rock and Alpine climbing in mind
  • $265

Click to enlarge
Women's Leashless Jacket
  • Burlier, Gore-Tex technical jacket
  • Ideal for alpine climbing and ice climbing where a burlier, more waterproof jacket might be needed
  • 11.4oz (compared to 7.1oz)
  • $279
Andy Wellman

OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews


Most recent review: July 29, 2016
Summary of All Ratings

OutdoorGearLab Editors' Rating:   
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (3.0)
Average Customer Rating:   
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (5.0)

100% of 1 reviewers recommend it
Rating Distribution
2 Total Ratings
5 star: 50%  (1)
4 star: 0%  (0)
3 star: 50%  (1)
2 star: 0%  (0)
1 star: 0%  (0)
Sort 1 member reviews by: Most Recent | Most Helpful
Write a Review on this Gear

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
   Jul 29, 2016 - 02:28am
Jrmenke · Road Biker · Jacksonville, FL
I love this jacket. This is by far the lightest hard shell that I own and is easy to take just about anywhere, especially as it folds into its own chest pocket. The jacket feels comfortable on my skin in a way many other shells with cold inner liners do not. The breathability is excellent and the pit zips are not missed at all. While the reviewers at outdoor gear lab had trouble with water leaking in from the hood, I have not had any such problems and find that the jacket passes the shower test. I am happy that Patagonia brought back hand warmer pockets for the 2016 version. In summary, this jacket includes only the bare essential features into one very streamlined package and as such it can be used for a large variety of activities (climbing, mountaineering, cycling, around town, etc.). If I only could bring one hard shell with me, the M10 would be it.

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this product to a friend.
Help other readers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? 
Yes
 
No


Have you used the Patagonia M10?
Don't hold back. Share your viewpoint by posting a review with your thoughts...

Write a Review on this Gear
Helpful Buying Tips

Unbiased.