The Best Flip-Flop Sandals For Women Review

Whether you live for flip-flop weather or you're simply looking for some open-toed footwear to wear on your next beach vacation, our updated women's flip-flop review has you covered! We tested out 11 pairs of sandals that ranged from insanely cozy to ultra supportive. After flipping up rocky trails and flopping down beautiful beaches, we're here to help you score some open-toed footwear that will keep your feet happy throughout the season. We've ranked each piece according to support, comfort, water resistance, traction, and style. Read on to learn which products excelled across all categories and which ones just didn't make the grade.

Read the full review below >

Review by: ⋅ Review Editor, OutdoorGearLab

Top Ranked Flip-Flop Sandals - Women's Displaying 1 - 5 of 11 << Previous | View All | Next >>
Our Ranking #1 #2 #3 #4 #5
Product Name
OluKai Ohana - Women's
OluKai Ohana - Women's
Read the Review
Chaco Flip - Women's
Chaco Flip - Women's
Read the Review
Reef Women's Fanning
Reef Women's Fanning
Read the Review
Video video review
Keen Florence Flip
Keen Florence Flip
Read the Review
Teva Women's Mush II
Teva Women's Mush II
Read the Review
Video video review
Editors' Awards  Editors' Choice Award    Top Pick Award    Best Buy Award 
Street Price Varies $51 - $65
Compare at 6 sellers
Varies $50 - $65
Compare at 7 sellers
$27
Compare at 1 sellers
$50Varies $17 - $25
Compare at 4 sellers
Overall Score 
100
0
87
100
0
80
100
0
73
100
0
71
100
0
66
Editors' Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating Be the first to rate itBe the first to rate itBe the first to rate itBe the first to rate itBe the first to rate it
Pros Amazing arch support, Classic styling, Grippy footbedGreat traction when wet, Very durable, Excellent arch supportWide ergonomic straps, Integrated bottle openerLightweight, feminine design, smooth straps and footbed for comfort.Good support for inexpensive sandal, Comfortable
Cons Expensive, Toe post can cause agitationTextured footbed uncomfortable, Straps can cause chaffingBulky, wide soleDesign can be limiting, slippery footbed, expensive.Lacks in stability and traction
Best Uses All-around warm weather wear – from beach to light hikingCasual rafting or kayaking, Light hikes/walks, General water/outdoor useBeach wear, Spring break!General around town use, Dressier flip flop occasionsGeneral around-town and outdoor use
Date Reviewed Mar 16, 2014Mar 16, 2014Mar 16, 2014Mar 16, 2014Mar 16, 2014
Weighted Scores OluKai Ohana - Women's Chaco Flip - Women's Reef Women's Fanning Keen Florence Flip Teva Women's Mush II
Stability - 25%
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
6
Comfort - 25%
10
0
9
10
0
7
10
0
7
10
0
7
10
0
8
Water Resistance - 20%
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
7
10
0
6
10
0
7
Traction - 15%
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
9
10
0
5
10
0
5
Style - 15%
10
0
8
10
0
7
10
0
5
10
0
9
10
0
6
Product Specs OluKai Ohana - Women's Chaco Flip - Women's Reef Women's Fanning Keen Florence Flip Teva Women's Mush II
Sole material Gum rubber EcoTread⢠rubber (Flip Vibe has Vibram) Molded rubber Rubber EVA
Footbed material ICEVA footbed over EVA midsole LUVSEAT⢠polyurethane footbed EVA Leather Durapontex rubber/foam compound
Strap Material Synthetic nubuck leather Polyester jacquard webbing Synthetic nubuck Leather Nylon
Width of strap 7/8" - 1 3/8" 1 1/4" - 2 3/4" 1"
Length of size 10 11 3/16" 10 15/16" 11"
Length of toe box (just above toe post) 4" 4" 3 3/4"
Weight 14.1 oz 14.4 oz 7 oz
Dry time (full-half sun) Footbed dry in 15 min, straps dry in 1 hr, 20 min Footbed dry in 15 min, straps dry in 1 hr, 20 min Footbed dry in 15 min, straps dry in 2 hrs, 10 min Footbed dry in 15 min, straps dry in 1 hr, 50 min
Unique features Amazing arch support Sole has 25% recycled content Heel airbag, integrated bottle opener Leather straps and footbed Fun strap patterns, narrow toe box
Colors/Patterns 18 Colors 6 to 10 Black w/14 different accent patterns; taupe w/pink and white accents More than 12
Animal products? No No No Yes No

OutdoorGearLab Editors' Hands-on Review


  • Review Photos
  • Editors' Choice Winners
  • All Reviewed Products
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge
Chaco Flip - Women's
$65
100
0
80
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Keen Florence Flip
$50
100
0
71
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Crocs Capri IV
$40
100
0
58
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Sanuk Yoga Mat - Women's
$30
100
0
57
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Reef Sandy Sandal
$28
100
0
63
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Nike Comfort Thong
$34
100
0
49
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Sanuk Yoga Spree 2
$32
100
0
44
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Havaianas Top - Women's
$18
100
0
48
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Selecting the Right Product
It's that critical moment: summer's just around the corner and you're out shopping when you pass by the big display of $5 bargain zories. Sure, you could rock a pair of these thin, traction-less flips for half the summer, but we're here to introduce you to a whole new world of open-toed, warm weather footwear! Although choosing the right sandal is less important than finding the right trail running shoe or the best fitting hiking boot, opting for a sandal with extra support, traction, and comfort can help keep your feet and joints healthy, especially if you spend lots of time in open-toed footwear. In this article we'll break down the pros and cons of 11 different pairs of flops and describe the metrics we used to rate them. For more information, be sure to check out our buying advice article How to Choose Women's Flip-Flop Sandals.

Click to enlarge
Left: The pieces in our updated review (L to R, Front to Back): Havaianas Top, Reef Sandy, Crocs Capri, Sanuk Yoga Spree 2, Sanuk Yoga Mat, OluKai Ohana, Nike Comfort Thong, Teva Mush II, Reef Fanning. Right: From our old review! (L to R): Keen Florence, Chaco Flip, Reef Sandy, OluKai Ohana, Sanuk Yoga Mat
Credit: OutdoorGearLab

Types of Women's Flip-Flops
In our review, we limited our product selection to pieces with thong-style straps that join together at a toe post between the first and second toes and then create a "V" shape across the top of the foot. That said, there are numerous other strap configurations on the market. For example the Teva Olowahu and the Chaco Zong both have straps that criss-cross across the forefoot, but don't have the heel strap. These models are a little more difficult to slip on and off, but they stay in place a little better once you have them on, especially for individuals with low-volume feet. They also offer a different look than their thong-style sisters. Once you decide on a strap configuration that works for you, another thing to consider is footbed type. In our review, we tested products with the following different footbed styles:

Contoured Footbed
Models such as our Editors' Choice winner, the OluKai Ohana - Women's and our Top Pick Award winner, the Reef Women's Fanning both feature contoured footbeds with a fixed anatomical mold. Generally, these footbeds offer more support, specifically underneath the arch, and they provide greater overall stability. Typically, they are more expensive, but if you spend lots of time in open-toed footwear, they are definitely the way to go.

Click to enlarge
The OluKai Ohana's contoured footbed provides enough support for light hiking, like this trip to the top of the tungsten hills outside Bishop, California.
Credit: Darla Heil

Foot-Molding Footbed
The Reef Sandy Sandal and our Best Buy Award winner, the Teva Women's Mush II, both have foot-molding footbeds. As the wearer begins to break in these flops, the footbeds form to the shape of the foot. The personalized fit increases comfort and provides some support, but typically does not offer as much stability as a model with a contoured footbed.

Click to enlarge
A foot-molding flip with a broader sole, the Reef Sandy is a comfortable, affordable choice.
Credit: Amanda Fenn

Novelty Footbed
In our review, we tested several products that have "novelty footbeds." The Nike Comfort Thong (with its memory foam footbed) and both Sanuk models (with their yoga mat footbeds) offer an interesting take on sandal comfort. We found that these pieces didn't provide much stability or support, but they do have a unique "Ahhhh" effect that earned them extra comfort points.

Click to enlarge
The Sanuk Yoga Spree 2 has a novelty yoga mat footbed that offers unique comfort but very little support or stability.
Credit: Rebecca Fenn

Criteria for Evaluation

Support & Stability
Although many of us would like to think that support and stability are not important in a flip-flop, at OutdoorGearLab, we know that unsupportive footwear (sandals included!) can lead to a variety of long-term problems. In some ways, it would be nice to be able to get away with wearing budget pieces like the Havaianas Top - Women's forever, but the sad truth is that abusing your feet with thin, unstable sandals can lead to arch and joint issues down the road.

To help highlight the pieces that will really keep your feet healthy, we made our "Support & Stability" metric one of the most important and heavily weighted categories in our review. Overall, we found that only the higher-end models like the OluKai Ohana and the Chaco Flip - Women's really scored well in this category. These pieces have contoured footbeds that support the arch, and their soles are stable enough that they provide a little more protection against ankle rolling than thinner competitors. Additionally, models like the Reef Fanning and Crocs Capri IV have extra padding in the heels to absorb shock. These features also help make these products easier to wear all day long.

Click to enlarge
The Reef Fanning has a stiff sole that provides enough support and stability to carry a pack for short distances. Here, Amanda wears the Fanning while heading out rock climbing.
Credit: Amy Sturgill

Comfort
While factors like arch support certainly play a role in overall comfort, our Comfort metric solely reflects the amount of "Ahhhhh" effect we experienced when wearing each sandal. Sometimes, you just don't need a product that's going to hold up during a three-mile hike or stay on your feet during a long river paddle…you just want a sandal that's going to make your feet feel pampered while you sit at your favorite beach-side coffee shop, or one that will help your feet relax after a burly workout at the gym. And that is what our Comfort category is all about!

Click to enlarge
For some people, flip-flops are all about comfort. The Nike Comfort Thong is a great post-workout sandal. Here, our tester slips out of her running shoes and into the memory foam Comfort Thong.

The Sanuk Yoga Mat - Women's offers a comfy, novelty yoga mat footbed but earned lower scores in metrics like support and water resistance. Models like this one and the Nike Comfort Thong are designed to make you say "Ahhhh" the minute you slip them on, but try to wear them all day and you will discover that the lack of support will probably leave you hanging.

Other critical comfort concerns include strap width and lining, sandal weight, and footbed width. In general, our testers found that wider straps are more comfortable, especially when they feature some sort of lining or padding. The two pairs with the least comfortable straps include the Havaianas Top and the Sanuk Yoga Spree 2, which have thin, poorly lined straps. Some people find heavier flops to be less comfortable, so we weighed each pair and factored this into our scores. Finally, our individual reviews discuss the footbed width of each piece, so that individuals with wider or narrower feet can optimize their comfort.

Click to enlarge
The Sanuk Yoga Mat also ranked highly in our Comfort metric. It has that "Ahhh" effect we were really looking for in this category.
Credit: Trish McGuire

Water Resistance
It's that moment when you're packing up your gym or beach bag and you realize that your flips are still soaked with water. Nobody likes being stuck in this situations and we're here to help you avoid it. Throughout our testing process, we romped through waves, crossed creeks, hiked sloppy trails, and visited a hot tub or two. Then, just to make sure that we compared all the products evenly, we soaked each pair and then laid them out to dry. Throughout this process, we considered how much water the sole and straps absorbed and timed the whole drying process.

The only flip that truly excelled in this category was the Havaianas Top (we simply dried these off with a towel and called it a day), but several other models, including the Reef Sandy Sandal also took top marks. Meanwhile, pieces like the Sanuk Yoga Mat, the Sanuk Yoga Spree, the Keen Florence Flip, and the Nike Comfort Thong took upwards of four hours to dry completely. Aside from these four models, we were surprised to find that the soles and footbeds of all the other pieces dried in just 15 minutes of full sun. Ultimately, it's the straps that take a longer time to fully dry.

Click to enlarge
Flip-flops are so often used around water, and then packed up and taken home, that we decided to see just how long it took each one to dry. The Reef Sandy Sandal was one of the fastest drying pieces in our review.
Credit: Amanda Fenn

Traction
At first, we thought about traction only as a bottom-of-the-sole thing, which, to be fair, is how most people think about traction. But then we realized that a major portion of sandal slipping and sliding is caused by a lack of footbed traction. But let's talk about sole traction first: we ran all the pieces in this review through a traction obstacle course complete with slippery rocks, steep inclines, and wet logs. Top performers included Chaco, OluKai, and the Reef Women's Fanning. Meanwhile, Havaianas, Sanuk, and Crocs earned significantly lower scores. Throughout this process, we learned that traction is not only affected by the treads and the type of rubber used on the sole, it's also directly related to the amount of stability that the shoe provides.

Click to enlarge
The soles of two of the top-performing flips in our traction metric. Left: Reef Fanning, Right: OluKai Ohana. But soles aren't the only important part of traction, the grip of the footbed also plays a big role in this metric.
Credit: Amanda Fenn

Next, on to footbed traction: when we wore the Sanuk Yoga Spree 2 in a dusty environment, our testers constantly dealt with foot slippage. The slick yoga mat footbed on this piece doesn't provide any grip, which increases the chance of the heel slipping off and getting scraped, or worse. Our Editors' Choice Award outdid all its competitors in this regard. The OluKai Ohana features an inset ICEVA footbed that maximizes grip, while still remaining remarkably comfortable.

Click to enlarge
One of our favorite things about our Editors' Choice winner, the OluKai Ohana is that it has a grippy footbed that helps keep the foot in place, maximizing traction
Credit: Darla Heil

Style & Fit
The pieces in this review range from athletic and techy to delicate and feminine. We polled an array of women via social media to generate our style scores; not surprisingly, our respondents found the more athletic models - like the Nike Comfort Thong - less stylish, and awarded higher scores to products like the Sanuk Yoga Spree 2 and the Keen Florence Flip. Both of these sandals can easily be paired with a casual dress or skirt for a beach-side happy hour or afternoon barbecue. Several models, like the Reef Fanning and Crocs Capri IV fell in the mid-range of our style metric. We think these pieces appeal to more specific audiences, so be sure to check out our analysis of each sandal's style in our individual reviews.

Click to enlarge
Sometimes, you need a flip-flop with a little style. Here, Emily and Courtenay complete their outfits with the some of the flips from this review. The sandals in this review ranged athletic to classic to fun. Check out our individual write-ups for more info!
Credit: Emily Zell

Our individual reviews also break down the fit of each piece. This type of footwear normally only comes in whole sizes, and since our main tester is a half size, we have some helpful information about whether to size up or down. We were surprised at how much we learned about fit during our testing process. Aside from assessing length, width, and strap volume, we learned that toe box shape makes a big difference in fit. A sandal may fit you perfectly length-wise, but if you have longer or wider toes and the flop's toe box is just a bit narrow, your toes might hang slightly off the front. For more information on finding your perfect flip fit, be sure to check out our buying advice guide: How to Choose Women's Flip-Flop Sandals.

Click to enlarge
All our size 10 flip-flops from the side, L to R: Reef Fanning, Havaianas Top, Crocs Capri IV, Teva Mush II, OluKai Ohana, Reef Sandy, Sanuk Yoga Mat, Sanuk Yoga Spree 2, Nike Comfort Thong
Credit: OutdoorGearLab
Click to enlarge
All our size 10 flip-flops looking down, L to R: Reef Fanning, Havaianas Top, Crocs Capri IV, Teva Mush II, OluKai Ohana, Reef Sandy, Sanuk Yoga Mat, Sanuk Yoga Spree 2, Nike Comfort Thong
Credit: OutdoorGearLab

Editors' Choice Award: OluKai Ohana - Women's

Click to enlarge
We can't say enough positive things about the Editors' Choice award winning OluKai Ohana. We constantly reached for this sandal whether we were heading out on a hike or just biking to the coffee shop.
Credit: Darla Heil

When we tallied up the scores at the end of our review, we weren't surprised to learn that the OluKai Ohana - Women's had far out-performed its competitors. Although it is fairly expensive, this sandal is 100 percent worth the investment. It offers stellar support (even for light hikes), excellent comfort (even for those lazy coffee shop mornings), and top-notch traction (even on slippery creek crossings). Designed by people who obviously spend a TON of time in open-toed shoes, the OluKai Ohana took home the Editors' Choice Award in our old women's review, and the men's Ohana holds the top place in our men's review. All hail to the reigning queen and king of flip-flops!

Best Buy Award: Teva Women's Mush II

Click to enlarge
We absolutely loved our Best Buy award winner. From its comfy footbed to its fun patterns, this affordable flip stole our hearts.
Credit: Amanda Fenn

One of our favorite products of the bunch, the Teva Women's Mush II is a comfy foot-molding sandal that has decent support and traction. The squishy rubber/foam footbed offers that "Ahhhh" cushioning, while an inset arch provides more support than any other inexpensive (sub $40) sandal we tested. At only $25, we think the Teva Mush II is an awesome deal if you're looking for something more than bargain flip, but aren't quite ready to drop the $65 for a high-end piece like our Editors' Choice winner.

Top Pick Award for Spring Break: Reef Women's Fanning

Click to enlarge
Our Top Pick for Spring Break! The Reef Fanning is a stable flip that has wide straps and athletic styling. We think it's the perfect accessory for the college student heading to the beach.
Credit: Amanda Fenn

A higher-end sandal, the Reef Women's Fanning features a contoured footbed with a low arch, a rubber sole with great traction, and wide comfortable straps. This sporty sandal gives off a distinctly beachy vibe (which is no surprise, since it was designed by a professional surfer) and it has an integrated bottle opener in the sole. Our testers agreed - the Fanning says "college spring break!!" At $50, this stable and supportive flip should keep your feet happy almost all day long, whether you're strolling the boardwalk or hitting the surf.

Amanda Fenn
Buying Advice
How we Test
Helpful Buying Tips
Get More OutdoorGearLab
Follow us on Twitter, be a fan on Facebook!
Subscribe to our Newsletter
Recent Editor's Award Winners