The Best Daisy Chain For Climbing |
|
|
What is the best daisy chain for climbing? We look at seven of the best options and test them head-to-head. We evaluated them on four criteria: fall absorption, ease of hooking, durability, and weight. While daisy chains can be used for free climbing, in general, we recommend an anchor chain instead.
Read the full review below > |
| Review by: Chris McNamara ⋅ Founder and Editor-in-Chief, OutdoorGearLab | February 3, 2010 |
| Top Ranked Daisy Chains | Displaying 1 - 5 of 7 | << Previous | View All | Next >> |
| Our Ranking | #1 | #2 | #3 | #4 | #5 | ||||||||||
| Product Name |
|
|
|
|
| ||||||||||
| Editors' Awards | | | | ||||||||||||
| Street Price | $25 | $18 Compare at 1 sellers | Varies $28 - $33 Compare at 5 sellers | Varies $12 - $16 Compare at 6 sellers | $30 Compare at 2 sellers | ||||||||||
| Overall Score |
100
0
84
|
100
0
80
|
100
0
78
|
100
0
72
|
100
0
70
| ||||||||||
| Editors' Rating |
|
|
|
|
| ||||||||||
| User Rating | Be the first to rate it | Be the first to rate it | Be the first to rate it | Be the first to rate it | Be the first to rate it | ||||||||||
| Pros | Reinforced clip-in point, light | Reinforced clip-in point | Light, easy to get a hard bounc test with | Good value, reasonably durable, big loops are easy to hook with fifi or clip with carabiner. | Loops are easy to hook, good value for Dynex. | ||||||||||
| Cons | expensive | A little heavy, flat loops are not the easiest to hook. | Expensive, end wears out faster than other daisy chains, loops are a little hard to clip | No reinforcement at end. | Too short. | ||||||||||
| Best Uses | Aid climbing, big wall climbing, trad climbing | Aid climbing, big wall climbing, trad climbing. | Alpine climbing, fast and light walls | Big wall aid climbing. | Free climbing. | ||||||||||
| Date Reviewed | Mar 08, 2010 | Jan 16, 2010 | Oct 05, 2010 | Oct 05, 2010 | Apr 05, 2011 | ||||||||||
| Weighted Scores | Metolius Monster Daisy Chain | Metolius Nylon Daisy Chain | Black Diamond Dynex Daisy Chain | Black Diamond Nylon Daisy Chain | CAMP Dyneema Daisy Chain | ||||||||||
| Fall Absorption - 20% |
10
0
8
|
10
0
10
|
10
0
5
|
10
0
10
|
10
0
5
|
||||||||||
| Ease Of Use - 20% |
10
0
7
|
10
0
6
|
10
0
10
|
10
0
8
|
10
0
9
|
||||||||||
| Durability - 30% |
10
0
10
|
10
0
10
|
10
0
6
|
10
0
6
|
10
0
5
|
||||||||||
| Weight - 30% |
10
0
8
|
10
0
6
|
10
0
10
|
10
0
6
|
10
0
9
|
||||||||||
| Product Specs | Metolius Monster Daisy Chain | Metolius Nylon Daisy Chain | Black Diamond Dynex Daisy Chain | Black Diamond Nylon Daisy Chain | CAMP Dyneema Daisy Chain | ||||||||||
| Weight (grams) | 70 | 99 | 43 | 98 | 63 | ||||||||||
| Material | 64% nylon/36% Dyneema | Nylon | Dynex/Dyneema | Nylon | Dyneema | ||||||||||
| Length (inches) | 55 | 55 | 45, 55 | 45, 55 | 46 | ||||||||||
| Width (mm) | 13 | 19 | 12 | 18 | 12 | ||||||||||
| Loop Strength (lbf) | 300 | 300 | 674 | 674 | ? | ||||||||||
| Warranty |
OutdoorGearLab Editors' Hands-on Review
Fall Absorption
If you are going to take a lot of daisy falls, the nylon daisy chains absorb more force than the the Dyneema ones. So we gave top scores to the nylon daisy chains, followed by the nylon/Dyneema mixes followed by the Dyneema. How important is this score and what is the difference in forces between nylon and dyneema daisy chains in real aid climbing situations? It is very debatable. Read our how to buy a daisy chain article to learn more. Ease of Hooking With a Fifi or Clipping With Carabiner The Black Diamond Dynex scored the best because it has big perky loops that are thin and easy to clip. All the other Dyneema daisy chains scored well as they had loops that stock out more, even when the daisy chain was twisted. Nylon daisy chains tend to have the loops lie flat more easily and be harder to hook when twisted. Durability The most durable daisy chains are the Metolius Monster and Metolius Nylon Daisy chains. They each are the only ones with big beefy reinforcements at the clip-in point. This is something that all daisy chains made for aid climbing should have. Unless you plan to do only a couple of walls, it is great to have this point reinforced. Weight and Bulk The Black Diamond Dynex Daisy chain is by far the lightest we tested, the thinnest, and the least bulky. It was less than half the weight and bulk of most nylon daisy chains. We really noticed a difference when pushing ascending ropes with this daisy. Where it is partially psychological or not, it really feels like this daisy weighs next to nothing. All the other Dyneema daisy chains were also fairly light. The Bottom Line The Metolius Monster Daisy Chain wins our Editors' Choice award. It has the best combination of being light and durable while maintaining some of the fall absorption properties of nylon. For most aid climbers we recommend this daisy. The Metolius Nylon Daisy Chain wins our Best Buy award. It is one of the least expensive daisy chains but scored almost as high as the Editors' Choice. It is also 100 percent nylon, which people wanting the absolute most daisy fall force absorption will appreciate. The Black Diamond Dynex Daisy Chain wins our Recommended award. It is by far the lightest daisy chain available. For speed ascents, alpine climbs or if you are mostly just following, this is a great choice. While in general we recommend an anchor chain for free climbing, this is lighter than the lightest anchor chain. So if you are a free climber obsessed on having the lightest gear, it is worth comparing the pros and cons of this against the BlueWater Titan Loop Chain. If you are mainly a free climber, check out our anchor chain review and our how to buy an anchor chain article. — Chris McNamara Buying Advice
How we Test
|
Helpful Buying Tips
Get More OutdoorGearLab
Follow us on Twitter, be a fan on Facebook! Recent Best-in-Class Reviews
Recent Editor's Award Winners
|
||||||||||||||||||







