Hands-on Gear Review
Compare climbing harness for women ratings side-by-side >
Street Price: $55 | Compare prices at 6 resellers
Pros: comfortable, easy to clip rigid gear loops, great value, adjustable leg loop system is light and easy
Cons: no ice tool holders
Best Uses: sport climbing, trad climbing, multi-pitch climbing, gym climbing- almost everything!
This is the speed adjust buckle version of the popular Black Diamond Primrose AL. If you like adjustable legs loops and self-locking (aka speed adjust) buckles, this is a great value and a great first harness. It is comfortable, has easy to clip rigid gear loops, clever features, and costs $55. You have to spend a good deal more money to get just minor improvements in weight, comfort, or features.
You will probably go many years before buying another harness, and this is a perfect all-around harness that can be used for any kind of climbing. If you want a very style-specific harness, you may want to look at others, such as the Black Diamond Xenos for ice climbing or the Petzl Hirundos for sport climbing. For the ultimate women's sport climbing harness, you can shell out another $15 for the Black Diamond Siren or an extra $50 for the Black Diamond Aura, but in the end the Primrose SA will be more comfortable, more versatile, weighs the same, and comes at a more attractive price. Only the Mammut Ophira and the AL version of this harness are less expensive. You will have to decide if the $15 extra you pay for the Primrose SA is worth it.
View the complete Best Women's Climbing Harness Review to see how this stacked up against the competitors.
Compare top rated competitors side-by-side >
OutdoorGearLab Editors' Hands-on Review
Using Black Diamond's redesigned leg loop adjustment system, this harness manages to be surprisingly lightweight and inexpensive for a fully- featured and duly-adjustable harness.
With a wide waist belt, the Primrose SA is comfortable to hang in and load with gear. It uses Black Diamond's weight-reducing Dual Core construction in tandem with an OpenAir insert, which uses two slim bands of webbing on the outer edges of the belt, and then incorporates a foam piece in the center with holes for additional breathability. Topped off with a mesh outer fabric on the center of the belt, the harness is surprisingly breathable for its width. The waist belt does not have any uncomfortable pressure points and fits snugly and securely high on the body.
The gear loops are appropriately positioned for easy reach to the front and back loops, unlike both models of Petzl harnesses, which have frustratingly far away rear gear loops. This allows for comfortable use in all positions encountered while climbing.
The Primrose is a great all-around harness that works well in any climbing application. The comfortable waist belt and easy to clip rigid gear loops make loading the harness with gear for multi-pitch trad climbs just as easy as racking up for a single pitch sport climb. The one feature it lacks is a loop for ice tool holders, so it will not cross-over to winter use as easily as the Petzl Selena or Petzl Luna.
Ease of Use
Three primary features on this harness make it stand out as an easy to use harness: the speed-adjust buckle, the gear loops, and the adjustable leg loops. Having a pre-threaded speed adjust buckle means that you don't have to worry about doubling back the waist belt every time you put it on. The gear loops are encased in hard plastic, leaving them rigid and standing out from the side of your harness. This makes them very easy to clip gear to and unclip gear from, though they are not as comfortable if wearing a pack and a harness at the same time.
The newest update to this harness included the addition of the trakFIT leg loop system. Rather than a buckle, this system consists of a plastic slider on the leg loops that moves easily around the leg loop to adjust the size quickly and effortlessly. The slider is small and light, and does not need to be double-backed, so it adds almost no weight or complication to the harness, while allowing it to fit women of all proportions.
When we weighed in our women's harnesses, we were actually quite surprised: the Primrose SA weighed in the exact same as the Black Diamond Siren, which is supposed to be an ultra-light sport climbing harness. At 11.84 ounces, both are extremely light. However, the Primrose is far more comfortable and versatile with no extra bulk holding you down, and still costs $15 less than the Siren.
This is a great all around harness or first harness. It works well in the gym, at sport crags or on multi-pitch climbs. It is a comfortable, easy to wear harness in any application.
This is one of the best values in harnesses with speed adjust leg loops. You only have to pay another $5 over the Black Diamond Primrose AL to get the speed adjust waist buckle, which we find to be worth it for the added convenience and safety. This harness is durable enough to last you years and versatile enough to be used for anything, increasing its worth, which is why we give it our Best Buy Award.
To further maximize your dollars, you can buy the Primrose SA package, with includes this harness, a chalk bag, and a belay device and locking biner, for a total of $100. This is an excellent buy for someone just getting started in the sport of climbing.
This harness was tough competition for our Editor's Choice award. It is inexpensive while still ebing light and fully-featured.
There are many versions of the Momentum/Primrose line including the Black Diamond Momentum, Black Diamond Momentum SA, Black Diamond Momentum AL and the women's version: Black Diamond Primrose AL. The main difference between the Primrose SA and AL is that the SA has a Speed-Adjust buckle, while the AL does not.They all share similar padding and gear loops but use different waist and leg tightening systems. They are vary in cost.
How to Adjust this Harness
— McKenzie Long
Compare this product side-by-side to top competitors >
OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews
Most recent review: August 11, 2013
Where's the Best Price?
*Help support OutdoorGearLab. If you click on one of the seller links and make a purchase, a portion of the sale helps support this site
Related Best-in-Class Review
Helpful Buying Tips
Get More OutdoorGearLab
Follow us on Twitter, be a fan on Facebook!
Related Gear Reviews
Other Gear by Black Diamond
Recent Best-in-Class Reviews